just now, a friend in FB posted this pic of his child being "rotan" by teacher in school
i know it is acceptable to get "rotan" if didn't something wrong...i strongly agree
but if u ask me, this is kinda like rapist level of rotan already
and its just a primary school/kindergarten kids i think

UPDATE : got new news from the owner, the kid is 5 years old only


This post has been edited by MR_alien: Oct 15 2012, 09:30 PM

Small case...

18sx pic woi. summoning ah wang

just something brag on later in life

Yes. Education thru violent make Rome a great empire

Spare the cane, spoil the child.

If it's my son, I'd be happy and if he complains, I'll give him 2 more strokes.

how about rotan by own parents till leave a bruise? (same excuse that the child do something wrong)

Acceptable?

padan muka...buat jahat lagi..

Yes.
1 child get abused doesn't mean another 100000 can set free.

sometimes i wondering the teachers at school are always on period, even small stuffs had to scold loudly and rotan students

Violence is not always the anwser

This post has been edited by ustink: Oct 15 2012, 07:50 PM

tell the teacher 'see u in court'

sekolah menengah can rotan on the butt
but for primary maybe just on the hand enough

Span

hoho....if really like tat pic of kesan rotan...

surely will call for police already no play play yo.

ur fren must be rage...

lol last time no camera,i cant report my swollen hand.

Parenting fail = anak fail =kena rotan =complain.

depending on the level of mischief

if the child is really really naughty, he should be caned.

if something small like forgetting to bring textbook, then it's not appropriate, unless it's habitual.

poor him

kisd dont deserved that way of punishment. too heavy for them

i remember when we were in school always pakai seluar tebal2,and if we kena,we put exercise book in d pants

the butt so sweaty, bintiik2 pulak tu
anyway, go to the school and talk to the headmaster and the teacher
i bet the teacher is the makcik type, 40 yrs old makcik

if its a girl... dey can sue the school/teacher if she was found having
birth defect....

true story yo.

Too much la i think...

whoa.... your fren tak tau malu ah? memang dah budak kurang ajar tu

wondering what you people think. first thing when these things happen is to blame the teacher for their actions. have you guys listen to the other part of the story?

what case does the kid do?
if merokok,ponteng, sexual herassment, rotan saja

This post has been edited by zerorating: Oct 15 2012, 08:08 PM

every tuesday assembly for me lol

Mau pukul pun,jangan sampai sudah bengkak lah.....

I kena from Math teacher with a broom lagi,lagi sakit......(True Story)
Never complain....

wut mistake he made?

recover in 3 days. no problem with rotan. just teach your son properly.

lol bende kecil pon nak kkecoh ptui!

bodoh betul parents zaman skg ni..patutla budak2 pun sama teruk

to those who said "padan muka" or the kid deserve it
u have to read properly...its a primary school kid or small...not secondary school
and the stroke of the "rotan", u can see the stroke is very inconsistent, sometime higher sometime lower like loss control already
i agree rotan as punishement, but i personally think this is too over

in US some state cannot even smack the child butt using hand. dont say use cane hand also cannot. is a crime. we must change it here as well. kid kena pukul teacher or disiplinary teacher kena sue or transfer or kena sack. then they will know how painful

i just got new word...the kid in the picture is actually 5 years old only...kindergarden

no wonder new generation all become lembik/sayur/*****

inb4 u got 1 whip, scare go back home bcoz mom and dad will gip u more

Depends on the age of the offender and the seriousness of wrongdoing, if kindergarten, at most can only lightly cane the hand

I kena before also. Luckily my pants is baggy type one if not hailard. But still pain like fuark.

Pinch on the pusat area, steel ruler on both calves.

anak degil mcm bapaknya patutla kene rotan...hehe

teacher are human too sometimes they get too emo, and always think student are bad,

last time I was in secondary, lupa bawa buku textbook kena force halau from class to borrow. Then we say no pass/ prove of permission to go out, later kena rotan, but she still insist force us to go out borrow from other class, then outside kena discipline teacher, say we illegal come out from class during session group of 4 guys including me kena rotan -.-

Lupa bawa buku is a big issue man.... we must be a cyborg so can remember everytime. Until today I still remember that stupid incident.

This post has been edited by Boldnut: Oct 15 2012, 08:38 PM

5 years old primary school student??
Gila ka?

If spanking can deter a child from doing something bad, go ahead, spank away.

If it doesn't, its time to look for an alternative.

Rotan may be effective. But they are not that effective.

'Eh..ni kenapa ni bengkak2 ni? Cikgu pukul ke? Kenapa?'

mak tanya sekembalinya aku dri sekolah

'Tak la mak..kena gigit semut kat sekolah tadi..'

selamba je tipu mak sebab takut kantoi perangai nakal kat sekolah tdi..kalau kantoi,abis la kena lagi pasni..

tu dulu....sekarang? Kena sikit dah mengadu kat mak..ngadu ngan bpk..walhal dah buat salah tu wjar la kena hukum..tak nak kena rotan..jgn la nakal2 kat sekolah...

'Sayang anak tangan-tangankan'

This post has been edited by deanunited07: Oct 15 2012, 08:51 PM

budak 5 tahun kena camni? ingtkan buntut budak darjah 5 tadi..

I don't agree on rotan or beat or anything that leads to bruise. there is a lot of healthier way to punish children.

ask ur friend cari gang go gang back her ~
Tie the teacher then rotan rotan ~~

5 tahun..... too over la rotan sampai like that... however i also know kids nowadays very the degil one...

5y/o not kindergarden?

no rotan anak macam syaitan blame sekolah, kalo rotan report polis.

too pampered.

thats call bondage

yes... kindergarten
i never even thought kindergarten nowadays so ganas
i always thought kindergarten is a place where kids go learn ABC and 123 and play with friends
where got such punishment

dat @ss

Like how they do it in *u know wad im talking bout*
Then confirm the teacher scared

Senang cerita don't hantar kids to tadika.

Mum can quit her job and take care of her precious kid at home. Only then mum will discover that her kid is actually a little monster.

hipokrit child?
if the child is a monster, the child already shown its real nature at home.unless the parents didnt care about the child

so wats ur fren's action?

Nowadays most parents send their children to tadika to outsource the burden of taking care of their kids.
Some would purposely fetch their kids late from tadika and pay the necessary fine so that they have quiet time for themselves.

i want to sm the teacher!

Punish 3 to educate 1000 - confucius

agree on using rotan if student is not too young (come on man, at least not kindergarten la).
and really depends on what the student did. if perkara remeh like pull girl girl hair for fun, forgot book, no pls.
if stealing and beating up people (despite warning) yes pls.

of course very angry, if not angry thn weird
if your own child 5 years old only, sent to kindergarten...came home look like that, what would u feel?
note that its just kindergarten

pls note

thats reaction.

I mean wats ur fren action for this case? lapor polis?

yeah i agree kindergarten should not have such a punishment.

hell there's not even a law that allow rotan at punggung...neither 2ndary nor primary school.
and not to mention kindergarten.

This post has been edited by Terence573: Oct 16 2012, 01:51 PM