unless first 1 is 1150 dps with +100 main stats..

for your case second 1 is definitely better..

cox i tried an axe with 1110 dps, 200+ main stats
compare with a weapon with 980 dps, socketed with 80% critical dmg (no main stats)
they both give me about the same dps.. btw my critical chance is about 18%

just for your reference~