Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Motherboard Decision., DFI nF4 SLI-DR Expert or ASUS A8N32-SLI?

views
     
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 02:34 AM, updated 20y ago

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



Having a hard time choosing one from these two boards. Seems both boards overclock well with DFi having a slight edge in that aspect. But the ASUS is capable of running their 2 PCI E lanes at x16 and x16! Seems more future proof.

Any of you have any opinion or views or bad and good points of the boards I mentioned? Don't mind listening.....
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:09 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(Torniquet @ Jan 23 2006, 03:07 PM)
hmm...y not consider Abit A8N Fatal1ty Sli also
*
Only considering these two, no Fatalitys. Abit has not been good as of late.
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:12 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(ah_khoo @ Jan 23 2006, 03:08 PM)
my entry level opinion...  laugh.gif

asus:
-betta coolin for chipset  thumbup.gif
-8-phase power thingy  thumbup.gif
-weird layout (pci slots)  doh.gif
-bios support status unknown  tongue.gif

dfi:
-stock coolin for chipset not so impressive  shakehead.gif
-betta layout  thumbup.gif
-good support for bios  thumbup.gif

assume both oc almost d same, asus has my vote if graphic benchies is important to u (thou just few hundreds point diff > due to 16x mode in SLi, but I assume it's import for u)  tongue.gif
*
I was thinking the same about the PCI slots. Imagine I have a phase change evaporator hanging there, how am I going to use the PCI slots???? Weird layout.

Well here are my thoughts, and I need opinions on these issues:

1. I am going to have a DD with 3 evaps for the CPU and the SLi videocards. So I will need space between the two SLi cards for the evaps. Which one has a wider gap?

2. These two motherboards, which one overclock better? Well I know the DFi Expert has been crowned the best boards for overclocking, but how does the A8N32 comparison?

3. The A8N32 is capable of running the the 2 x PCI - E x16 lanes at full x16 x16. The DFi expert does not have that feature. Would that make the A8N32 more future proof?


This post has been edited by kcnyc: Jan 24 2006, 03:17 AM
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:32 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(ah_khoo @ Jan 23 2006, 03:23 PM)
1. I believe asus has wider gap between d 2 pcie slots, take a look closely at d pics u'll notice that.  smile.gif

2. Perhaps Shamino (VR-Zone) can answer you regarding this.

3. IMO, yes.
*
Ooh, I have this thread also in xtremesystems forum and it seems that someone helpful measured the two board gaps! Both SAME width - 60.5mm.

How are the overclockers here in the forum? Nobody using the Expert or A8N32? Complaints? Praises?
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:45 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(ah_khoo @ Jan 23 2006, 03:39 PM)
oopss... my bad... need to get myslf eyeglasses ledi...  laugh.gif

not everyone here can afford asus bro, it's wayyyyyyyyyy too expensive here, expert sellin cheaper...  smile.gif
*
Oh I just checked the prices....and you are right.
At newegg:

A8N32 SLi Deluxe = USD257 including shipping
DFi SLi Expert = USD195 including shipping

A USD62 dollar difference! My god!

This post has been edited by kcnyc: Jan 24 2006, 03:46 AM
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:46 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(Holi^oNe @ Jan 23 2006, 03:40 PM)
DFI Expert coming out with a new revision in the coming 1-2 months if not mistaken. As for the Asus dual PCIE running at x16 each. I think some benchmarks shown that it doesn't really effect that much just yet. Not sure if it's due to graphics technology or the mobo. I think waiting for the Expert newer revision would be better.  Most newer revisions iron out the flaws and improve on things already better isn't it ?
*
Anywhere I can read about the new revision?

Coz I have some doubts about a new revision being released since the new AM2 socket mobos should be out in a few months.

This post has been edited by kcnyc: Jan 24 2006, 03:50 AM
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 06:31 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(PCcrazy @ Jan 23 2006, 04:58 PM)
Not at all in the same league as the two boards mentioned by kcnyc in my opinion.
I've had so far received very positive feedback regarding the Asus new board. DFI expert is a proven board with enormous potential but a bit tricky to handle. Frankly I kind of preferred the new Asus (I like the snakey heat pipe cooler).

So far I heard it's reliable (perhaps because of the implementation of 8-phase power that should deliver very consistent power to the CPU and therefore should increase overclocking performance up to par with DFI expert if not better), not very tricky and performs really well. No issues with dual channel with a command rate of 1T.

Plus it looks good too. But then comes the problem of the placing of the PCI-E slots. As we know, graphics card nowadays is getting bulkier so extra space is always good to have. Vdimm max out at 3.1v. So at stock standard, BH5 is a no go. Vcore is also limited, but I heard new BIOS should tackle the problem.

As for the two full-width PCI Express x16 slots which claim to improve the efficincy of SLI system, I'm a bit skeptical of that. While I applaud every improvements that is made, but this will not have any effect at all at least for the moment, I mean surely having this chipset is not neccesary. So Asus have no advantage having this chipset compared to the DFI. But if money doesn't grow on trees at the back of your house, I would suggest DFI expert anyday. But knowing you, I would suggest take them both and enlightened us with reviews.

Btw, sorry for the non-technical feedbacks, I haven't had the luxury of time to keep up on this hobby as much as I like nowadays.
*
Well you seem to have done your homework, hats off to you for that. I checked the BIOS and even the beta ones, there was no change to VCORE. And buying a VCORE crippled motherboard is like asking me not to overclock. And moreover with phase change, I can use higher VCORE values. So I have really decided to go with the DFi.

TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 09:19 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(babyelf @ Jan 23 2006, 08:55 PM)
well i've seen both boards selling very well in aus.. and 32 lanes only come in use if you have cards that need that much bandwidth..

you can call the asus future proof yes.. anyway who uses a full overclock for their rig 24/7? i'm only running 2.4ghz myself lol..

so if you have the $$ i'm thinking go Asus..

if you want to squeeze everything from your system go the DFI and you still save some $$ for other stuffs..

myself.. i'm more of a DFI user.. feels more in control.. and i don't have 2 cards to run sli tongue.gif
*
Its not about money. I gave a long thought about it.

First of all,new socket, new mobo and new DDR2 - that is what AMD is planning in a few months. Me getting this board now, use for 3 months or so? Not worth it.

Moreover, the videocards out there don't even use x16 x16. So why buy it. Another waste of money.

And asking me to mod the board just for VCORE, is quite lame. How can you make a good overclocking board with a low VCORE limit?

So after all that, I will definitely be going the DFi Expert way.
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 09:48 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(babyelf @ Jan 23 2006, 09:26 PM)
u mean the new cards out don't even use x8 x8? lol..

well me myself i have a feeling i'll be jumping on AM2 once it's out.. but remember that it took quite a long time before socket 939 is fully matured so things can get a bit buggy at first..

for ram overclocking the normal DFI will be better.. especially with TCCD.. revision ADO of the boards apparently have improved circuitry..
*
ASUS has 2 PCI - E slots which is capable of running x16 x16. But no hardware uses this not even the videocards. So why buy it. It's called useless technology. LOL

And I doubt they will come out with anything which will utilize them, in the next few months before the new boards come out. ahhahaha

This post has been edited by kcnyc: Jan 24 2006, 09:52 AM
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 11:53 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(abubin @ Jan 23 2006, 10:15 PM)
If you can afford ASUS, I would say go for ASUS. It is well known as a reliable brand and the warranty is 3 years compared to dfi 2 years. IF you are concern about x16/x16 then don't waste your time. That is something AGP4x vs AGP8x - no difference but somehow people care about it...hmmmm.

If you are concern about new board coming out soon. Go ahead and wait if you have the TIME. Can you wait 3 months? Then when the board is out, you have to wait 1-2 months for feedback on those boards. It might turn out to be nothing special. Can you wait that long? Like I always say, if you can wait then just wait or else get what is in front of you and forget about what's coming.
*
Ahhhh abubin, I don't buy boards. I request for them from manufacturers for reviews. lol. I am not concerned about boards coming out either, just that I have to keep up with technology because I review hardware.

But there are difference between 4X and 8X boards! Try putting your videocard on an 8x AGP slot and benchmark it. Then put it onto a 4X board and do the same. You will see - difference. lol But in the case of x16/x16 and x8/x8, yes there is no difference because no hardware uses x16/x16 anyway.

This post has been edited by kcnyc: Jan 24 2006, 11:55 AM
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:45 PM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(almostthere @ Jan 24 2006, 02:00 AM)
Well kcnyc, there's two sides of the coin at the moment. For the expert, there's still the issue of BIOS maturity which has spooked everyone since Pedro publicised the frying of his 4Ghz FX. Then there's also the irritation of the placement of the RAM slots which unless your gonna run barebone can be a pain to access especially when doing RAM reviews.

Meanwhile, the Asus has a more conventional design, a more stable (if not that complete in terms of volts options and timings) BIOS, but still a lack of a proven record for AMD's in terms of benchamrking (Which I presume you'd be using these boards as part of your websites reviewing repertoire?)

And abubin, trust us on the 4x/8x. I had once a Ti4200 which allowed switching between 4x/8x modes and the bandwidth differences was alot...a whole lot more then one can expect actually. It's just that for now, PCI-e GFX's which are able to exploit fully the full-duplex bandwidth of the PCI-e lane hasn't arrived yet
*
Well said about the 4x and 8x AGP. It was a huge jump for me too when I changed from 4X to 8X.

About Pedro, he is a freak! He is a level above us in terms of overclocking. And he did a 4GHz overclock, so if it fries, it is not surprising.

But I don't think there is any contest here, the DFi is far superior in terms of overclocking. And ASUS limiting the VCORE voltage is already an indication for me to stay away. And in terms of overclocking and benchmarks, I see DFi on top of almost every benchmark. So I guess go with the flow....lol.

Oh yeah I know about the ram placements. Awkward to say the least. But I will be benchmarking on my cooler. Chilly1 made my cooler with a benching table where I can screw in my motherboard and what not. So that is the least of my problems. smile.gif
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 03:51 PM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(charge-n-go @ Jan 24 2006, 01:36 AM)
If you are doing review, why not request two boards and do your own comparison? Maybe u can wait till new Expert is out, and then compare it with Asus A8N32-SLi. drool.gif

btw, DFI has the edge on 6 layer PCB, whereas Asus has the edge on the 8 phase power. Feature wise I'm not sure, as it's not my main concern on choosing mobo tongue.gif
*
The thing is we will be using the board for our benching rig. And if we request it and not use it for the benching rig, it will look bad on us that we used a better board or something. So we have to take into account the company's reputation and ours. There is this saying,"Don't bite the hands that feed you". lol

I called DFi's Marketing and PR person, Ming Huey, and she said she has not heard anything about the new revision of Expert coming out. And she is going to see whether they are really releasing it. I should get an answer tomorrow about the revision.
TSkcnyc
post Jan 24 2006, 10:37 PM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(almostthere @ Jan 24 2006, 04:11 AM)
Yeah that's true, but here's the nagging worry. He wasn't even clocking it past 3Ghz when it went puff on Expert. That's what's spooking the hell out of the OC'ers over at XS. It seems it's traced down to the cycling of the voltage signals or summat which after altering the voltages a few time causes a 3.0v spike for a few milisecond of the VCore. Got bawls with that?
*
Ahhh yeah heard about that. This was because of the very new bios. Now those problems have been fixed. Quite crazy that the bios spiked your CPU to 3V.
TSkcnyc
post Jan 28 2006, 03:19 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(grafreak @ Jan 27 2006, 02:33 PM)
whoa  blink.gif can you guys show me the link? would love to see the article  biggrin.gif
errr, n00b here. so does that mean that in every few milisecond, the VCore jumps to 3.0 from 1.xxVcore?
*
Poke around xtremesystems.com and the forum area. You will see super LN2 cooling and cascade cooled chips and mobos. But they are undergoing upgrades right now. So give it a day or two.

Yeah the old DFi bios has this bug, which made the VCORE jump from your desired voltage to about 3Vs! But fixed already. smile.gif
TSkcnyc
post Jan 28 2006, 03:30 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(charge-n-go @ Jan 24 2006, 10:10 PM)
hehe kcnyc, decided with DFI Expert already? biggrin.gif
*
Decision made.
TSkcnyc
post Jan 28 2006, 07:05 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



Roger that PCcrazy..........
TSkcnyc
post Mar 9 2006, 04:34 AM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(jarofclay @ Mar 8 2006, 04:03 PM)
Just changed to A8N32 SLI. For once, it did some improvements over my Abit Fatality SLI. Here are the findings:

1. Prime stable for my Manchester at 2.4ghz using only 1.44V. With Abit, I had to use 1.55V...yeah yeah... I have a bad cpu chip.

2. The UCCC 2GB kit can now finally run at 270Mhz @ 1T. With Abit, anything above 210/220Mhz, it will need 2T.

3. Becoz of the north bridge, the whole two pci-e slots are pushed down further compared to DFI. So, beware if you plan to run SLI with dual slot coolers and a discrete sound card.

4. The heatpipe solution is really hot unless I have an active fan on the heatsink... it really can cause a hang if you use watercooling and not have an active fan on it.

5. The Vcore limit is not high by default @ 1.55V only. However, you could enable overvolt. I tried setting it earlier on at 1.5 and the voltage went upto 1.6V. DIdn't try harder since 1.44V is all it takes to tame my lousy Manchester.

6. VDimm at 3.2V only. However, most of the Redlines or BH5 based memory are over. Most of the current TCCDs, TCC5 and UCCC doesn't need anywhere more than 2.8 or 2.9Vdimm. As a matter of fact, they do not like extreme voltages.

I do not have an Expert board to test, so I can only benchmark it against my former Abit boards. Please post here if you have further questions on this mobo. And yes, this mofo is expensive; got it at RM960 in Penang.
*
Thank god you got rid of the Fatality! lol Told you it was the board holding u back...lol.



TSkcnyc
post Mar 9 2006, 10:46 PM

OC Addict!
*******
Senior Member
3,557 posts

Joined: Jan 2003
From: Brooklyn, New York



QUOTE(Tsukasa @ Mar 9 2006, 08:50 AM)
Why use expert to bench as venus had arrived from DFI. Heard its even better than expert as the chip are better and 100% made in japan . Duh all lanparty chip is made in japan but i find venus kinda cool as the diod chip out here and there

http://us.dfi.com.tw/Press/press_header_co...407.jsp&SITE=US
*
Only the capactitors are Japan made. And they are USD300 each. Which I think is not very worth it being that in about 3 months - socket AM2 will be out. And it is a limited edition board. Supposedly only 1000 boards made.

I dunno, if I will be able to sell these two boards I have now - I might get one.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0201sec    0.77    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 28th November 2025 - 12:30 PM