QUOTE(sherlynwen @ Aug 12 2013, 10:11 PM)
Failed P5 for first time .... 45 marks! Why i keep on failing those Optional Paper in marginal marks like 48, 45, 42 ? I jump from P7 & P6 after failed twice each papers to P5 and now still fail!!
Any Sifu can advice me ? =(( why i keep on fail in 40+ markss? what went wrong?? T^T
btw, i can answer all question required completely

P5 is the only paper that most students say they did it well and when the results come out - it is opposite or vice versa. Those that went in crapping - tend to pass, those that knew what was asked - failed. Funny
The meaning of failing it marginally means that you missed reading the requirement for 50% of the paper. If you read the examiner report - it seems that P5 has a higher chance of students misunderstanding the requirement than other papers.
The other issue is that P5 has P3 + F5 + APM. The paper itself has been "rojak"ed by ACCA - dumping whatever they thought is important - you have IS, Management, Strategic models, Costing, Management Accounting, Internal controls, Quality
Compared to P7, that has 2 major areas - Audit + Accounting knowledge,
P4 - Finance knowledge + bits of economic and P3,
P6 is the most narrowest in scope - only tax.
In that aspect, you can see why Malaysian have the best results for P6, followed by P7/P4 and finally P5. The P6 Malaysia paper seems to be the one with the highest past rates in Malaysia - but if you hate memory work - i would ask you to reconsider.
In my view, F1, P3 and P5 are the rojak papers in ACCA, the rest are quite focused on their knowledge being tested. If your ability to integrate knowledge is strong, then life is a bit easier.
Snowmiss review of the reasons for failing is really good and should be something that should be included in future study plans.