@TS, here my opinion on the three systems. I'm previously a Form 6(Physics Stream) students and now currently studying Economics in Nanyang Technological University, Singapore. So my view might be biased and also, a bit of my background, I also got selected into Matriculation programme at Changlun, Kedah right after my SPM. And below are the differences between the three :-
A-Level
- If you are financially sound, I highly suggest you take A-Level as the duration is shorter than STPM and also widely recognized like most people in the topic had mentioned.
- I also believe the syllabus in A-Level are slightly easier than STPM because I compare with my Form 5 classmates(who are not my class top 20) whom most of them entered A-Level actually managed to score all As easily compared to the top 10 students in my form 5 who entered STPM due to financial problems and only 2 only them score CGPA 4.0 while the rest not really doing it well in STPM. So my conclusion is that A-Level is easier than STPM(But that's my conclusion only, might not be true considering my sample size is quite small)
- But then again, who care whether is hard or easy, in the end, STPM and A-Level are both widely accepted, so if you are financially sound, go for A-Level as it is easier for you to score(which in a way increases your chance to apply for scholarships upon the completion of your A-Level) and also the duration is shorter.
STPM(Form 6)
- 1st, it is darn cheap ! But having said that, cheap doesn't mean good, there's always a trade off, it is tough and some of my form 6 classmates actually did badly in STPM and now some of them give up and start to work while some of them restart their Pre-U at foundation/diploma. So can you take the risk? Of course the usual rule, higher risk, higher return apply.
- Obviously the duration is longer than A-Level and tougher, but that is during my time cause starting this year, the STPM system had been revised into Modular System so I can't really comment on this "new" STPM much and I guess telling you about the STPM i had will be quite irrelevant now.
- But same as A-Level, it is internationally recognized, but not sure if this system will affect its reputation a not.
- But then, STPM can give you a wider choice cause you can also enter local uni with that which A-level cant. Cause some might have sufficient money to study A-Level but later to continue degree in private uni, its another huge lump sum to pay but on the other hand, studying degree in local uni is a lot cheaper comparatively.
Matriculation
- Actually, after I got selected into Matriculation, I went to my campus for a week but then later I left and joined Form 6 due to several reasons, but before I go to my reasons, let me explain some on Matriculation
- Matriculation is a special programme created by the government for students to enter LOCAL university in an expressway. However, the Matriculation Certificates are not recognized anywhere(someone plz verify this with me, but i think few private uni in Msia actually recognized it) and it is definitely not internationally recognized. One of the important reason you should join Matriculation is that you want to enter LOCAL university for certain courses that is super expensive if you don't do it in local uni such as medicine, dentistry and etc. As for the content, I gotta tell you, it is definitely easier and really easier compared to STPM and A-Level, by seeing how many ppl can get CGPA 4.0 easily in EACH matriculation campus you will know how easy it is to score and also my Form 6 Mathematics T teacher who was a head marker for Matriculation maths paper and she disclosed some info to my class tat to score a grade A in maths paper for matric is extremely low mark until around 50 marks.
- As for the facilities in Matriculation campus, i went there once and it was huge, lots of basketball courts, squash court, running track and etc.
- But then again, it is quite tough for non-Bumi to get selected into this programme. During my time in Kedah Matriculation's orientation, I was told that there's a total of 4K new intake and only 100 Non-Bumi and 1 Indian guy only(which i can verify is true cause during their prayer session, we non-bumi actually gather at one lecture theatre by the seniors and yes, there's only one indian guy)
- As for the reason I quit Matriculation,
1. I find it not suitable for me to have that kind of lifestyle[maybe for me living outside of city in KL making me feel the life there kinda boring + my room got no internet]
2. I wasn't really know where I was heading during that time, but finally I realised my ultimate goal is not to enter local uni, but I want to try my luck again in getting admission into overseas uni.
3. Taking courses like medicine, dentistry, pharmacy, engineering are definitely not what I want, so I guess i don't really find a reason to enter local uni since the courses i want are just business, finance, ecnomics and etc which deemed "not-so-prestigious and competitive" courses for uni courses application and therefore i think i can risk it with Form 6.
So yeah, that's my opinion on the three programmes. Just to conclude :-
1. Got money, go A-Level, save time, save effort and who cares if it is not as challenging as STPM, in the end, both are internationally recognized.
2. Having financial problem? Go STPM, but can you take the risk? Remember, higher the risk, higher the return. Somemore you have more choice, continue degree at private uni, overseas or local u
3. Matriculation, this is a one way express to local uni. Much much much easier and faster, but the downside is only local uni.
Thanks for your long comment. You have actually answer all those questions that I want to ask about matriculation, stpm and also A-levels. I'm afraid that I can't cope with the new surroundings(usually matrik as you said, they will send me to maybe somewhere out of the city) And I am a computer freak, I need to online at least one hour a day, I guess matrik life doesn't really allow me to leisure like usual.
I definitely agree with you that A-levels and stpm are both international world-recognized. STPM going to be tough, VERY tough life though. But at the same time, I want to challenge myself to study STPM and take the risk.
Mind asking you, what's your stpm results? I want to know so I can decide my path correctly and no feeling regretful for my rest of life. Thanks once again. ^^