Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

Portable Players Please Recommend a portable media player please, version 3

views
     
liquidgal
post Dec 31 2013, 12:41 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(Lego Warfare @ Dec 30 2013, 07:43 PM)
When i had it i didn't have any problems with the firmware.
*
X3 firmware is consider quite mature as compare to the rest. So far so good, support CUE as well.
liquidgal
post Feb 20 2014, 02:04 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(ezpoir @ Feb 17 2014, 08:51 PM)
Hey guys, looking for a music player below rm500
whats good?
*
Fiio X3, Ibasso DX50, HiFiMAN HM700 + RE400B combo are same level DAP, just different sound signature.
RM680~RM850, Slightly out of your budget lah~haha.

Colorfly C3, clean and neutral sound. Mid and bass is not very thick, details not bad. Build in amp soso, but enough to drive most of the IEM.
Weak point: Only got Headphone out, no line out. Touch screen a little bit lag.
This one is cheaper, around RM350.
liquidgal
post Feb 22 2014, 09:57 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(Lego Warfare @ Feb 22 2014, 08:52 PM)
Stay away from Nova N1, a failed product.
C3 and Sansa are good products, but with some flaws. C3 has better build quality and a brighter sound signature but poor UI and controls. Not much dynamics in the sound too. Sansa build quality is not as good but with better UI and SQ just below C3.
If you want a better all rounder product, try looking for a second hand X3 or DX50.
*
Agree with Lego Warfare's opinion. N1 is very......not good. haha.
haven't tried other dap except C3. Its sound is refined, clean, slightly bright and transparent, but not warm and dynamic enough. UI and controls quite lag.

X3, DX50 and HM700 definitely are higher range products.
liquidgal
post Feb 28 2014, 03:06 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(eugenelimys @ Feb 27 2014, 09:17 PM)
omg... I found AK120 for 32000 TWD... .__.
Should I just go for AK120 ? rather than getting AK100 and Pandora?
*
This price range should consider Ibasso DX100 and HiFiMAN HM901 too. smile.gif
Design, build quality and UI of AK120 is much better, but the sound quality of HM901 still very very good.
liquidgal
post Jun 2 2014, 02:08 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(H3LLKEEPER @ May 29 2014, 07:11 PM)
Current setup
PC->UD110->Shonyun 306a->Stock Cabler HD600

Looking for either X5 or the DX90
Mostly 16bit 44.1 flacs

I got an ipad mini as well, if there is a cheaper portable amp that is comparable to those two let me know
*
Indeed, music source is the biggest weakness in your system right now.
Shonyun 306a pairing with HD600 actually will be quite rich due to both emphasise on mid, slightly thick and warm with sparkling treble. Shonyun can tighten the bass of hd600 and give it a stronger music body though the sound stage is not very wide but with a good depth.

I have DX90, 306a and HD600 with me. I would say DX90 match them quite well. DX90 is soft, refined with thin music lines, which helps to neutralise the richness and warmness of shonyun and hd600. Tested with songs like move like jagger, faye wong- tine kong, yuna- photo of you, sounds quite decent biggrin.gif

I haven't really auditioned X5, can't comment much. But if X5 is closer to X3 sound signature which is slightly warm, I would say go for DX90.
liquidgal
post Jun 3 2014, 08:00 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(siles1991 @ Jun 3 2014, 02:22 AM)
Guys any good portable budget amp-dap combos? Only one I know would be Colorfly C3 with the C&C BH. Any others within that price range? Currently using a sansa clip, will be using it for CIEM in the future. Also anyone here has a C3 I could try?
*
Don't have a C3 for you to audition but I tried it before. So probably can share you some opinions.
C3 is a very clean sound DAP, details not bad and build in amp is a bit weak. The bigger problem would be the UI, it's a bit lag. At this price range, it's still quite decent for the SQ. And one more thing, it doesn't have line out so I don't encourage adding an amp to it. It will be double amping.

If you do like clean sound and your hand phone can support OTG, can up your budget a bit and consider Fiio E17. It's also more to DAC. To me, it's around the same range with fiio x3 but different sound signature.
liquidgal
post Jun 3 2014, 09:13 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(siles1991 @ Jun 3 2014, 09:01 AM)
yeah but a lot of people have very good experience with it double amping with the C&C BH, a lot of them prefer it over the fiio x3. I don't want to use my handphone for battery reasons, I use my phone a lot so prefer something else to play my music.

I'll probably try the Fiio x3, but are there other options?
*
yeah I don't deny the fact that sometimes double amping can have good sound also though it's not the usual way to connect the device. It's more like the "coincidence" that just happen, the amp pairs well with the dap or dac cum amp while double amping. But have to test or audition first to find out because double amping might cause distortion also.

You can also consider Ibasso dx50, more to the clean side, soft and refined. X3 is more pop sound, slightly warmer and richer. If you have higher budget can go for Ibasso dx90.
liquidgal
post Jul 23 2014, 02:16 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(power911 @ Jul 15 2014, 10:28 PM)
sudden sad moment that no one helped me when I asked bout Cube C30 replacement but yea

Sansa Clip is the way to go for budget player as it is stable as well as very responsive playback

and like ben3003 said the Cube C30 is harsh sounding
you'll experience better comfort by listening through Sansa Clip
I can't hear any difference with sansa clip vs HTC Rhyme (My current smartphone) so I'm a little hesitant on getting it yet still whistling.gif
*
thought they already answered you smile.gif
Colorfly c3 +1
It's a quite decent sounding dap at its price. Very clean sound and good details. The bad side, the touch screen is a bit insensitive and build in amp not so strong.
liquidgal
post Aug 8 2014, 01:28 AM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(Schampoo @ Aug 7 2014, 02:34 PM)
hi, my budget is around rm300
it seem most people recommended sansa clip plus.
is there any other better option available or sansa clip plus is good enough within my budget?
*
can try colorfly c3. Clean with good details but build in amp a bit weak. For IEM is good enough
liquidgal
post Jun 14 2015, 06:06 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(-milo- @ Jun 14 2015, 12:27 PM)
Hi guys,

Recently started to appreciate better quality audio, and would like some advise and guidance as I am pretty fresh in this scene.

Currently I only have a Shure se215 and Goldring dr150, and listen to music from my phone/iPad. I am considering to get a dap. Which route would be the better one for the following?

1) Fiio x1 plus DAC
2) iBasso dx90

Generally my idea is since I'm a beginner, should I start slow with lower budget, or go straight to something better than beginner gear and thus able to forget about upgrading till the device breaks. I mostly listen to pop, rock, rap, electric and metal.

Any ideas or advice will be much appreciated!  notworthy.gif
*
X1 only has line out and phone out, no digital out. Can't connect with external dac ya. smile.gif
liquidgal
post Jun 14 2015, 11:10 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(-milo- @ Jun 14 2015, 09:22 PM)
Hey guys, thanks for the replies!
One of my concerns is also that the DX90 would be too good for the earphones that i have now and I would be essentially wasting it..
I'm not in a big hurry to get a dap. So yes thanks for suggesting this, i would wait and try both then decide! smile.gif
What you say actually does make sense. Is the X1 considered a step up from a smartphone though?
Thanks for letting me know! I was confused with the picture of FiiO X1 DAP + E11K amplifier and thought the E11K a DAC.

So thank you everyone. Sounds like either the Fiio X1 and the iBasso dx90 both have their pros. I will find a day to try them both (and maybe even the Fiio x5ii) before finally making a decision. smile.gif
*
If you will upgrade to a big cans later, can consider HiFiMAN HM650 also.
Size is bigger, but the build in amp should be the strongest among dap below RM2k. Tried it with HE400i and HD600/650 before, can drive those high impedance/low sensitivity headphones quite well. Not need to consider adding another portable amp below RM800. Tried to connect with Cayin C5 before, not much improvement.
» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

liquidgal
post Aug 17 2015, 04:25 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(stringfellow @ Aug 16 2015, 04:04 AM)
I'm in a position to consider a purchase of a new DAP as well. Here are my criterias:

1. Digital transport only. Never felt that I can get enough power and drive from a DAP alone. If it was a light travel day I'd be with my WS99BT or B&W P5 Wireless and AptX it with my S6 Edge.

2. Large enough storage. Herein lies the dilemma. DAPs with dual storage slots like X5ii aren't Tidal-friendly (which will be my 3rd criteria later). Although storage problem will be solvable with swapping microSDXC cards (when are the 200GB microSDXC getting here la?), that is not really ideal.

3. Tidal-friendly. That covers Qobuz too if or should I decide to splurge on that. Therefore the DAP must be able to install the Tidal app. Hence either iOS or Android only. Unless you go desktop route, which what I am doing with my 2015 MacBook and Chord Hugo.

4.. Minimum 24bit/384khz, DSD for future-proofing(somewhat). I could live with 24bit/192khz, since that's where highest quality of the content I listen to is at. Therefore requires data stream to the DAC after playback decode on the DAP to the DAC at those quality rates, via whatever connection that it has (coaxial, SPDIF or USB).

With these criterias, the DAP only works as digital transport, therefore the bigger storage size it is, the better. And please no clunky UI bullshit like in the Lotoo PAW or its equivalent, no matter how godly the DAP's sound processing or amplification circuitry is, it's useless since the DAP will be digital transport only. The DAP fucntion is to display the UI smooth enough, and to process, decode and play the files of the quality mentioned above, pass those signal to the DAC (Chord Hugo) via SPDIF, coaxial or USB.

With all those said, I believe my option has been reduced to either Android smartphones with USB OTG function, iOS device with Onkyo HF player (can decode and play up to DSD via PCM conversion), or hybrid DAPs with Android functionality(to be able to install Tidal, Spotify, Qobuz app) such as the Sony ZX1 or ZX2. Am I correct to assume this?

I'm sure if I eliminated the need to Tidal, my options are wider open than it is now, but I use Tidal (and to a certain smaller extent, Apple Music) to discover new music and new artists. Don't get me wrong, there are artists who are my staple diet in music, I cant live without Charles Mingus, Ella Fitzgerald and Diana Krall, but I like the new upcoming ones like Ed Sheeran and Charlie Puth as well, and would not have discovered them without Tidal or Apple Music.

So, are my choices limited to Sony ZX1/ZX2, iOS devices (iPhones, iPads, iPod Touch) and <insert whatever Android smartphones here>? I've just tested my S6 Edge--> Chord Hugo, works fine but damn crackly and noisy unless I turn on airplane mode. No such crackle and fuzz with my iPhone 6 Plus. And then there is the problem of storage. Which I foresee will never be enough with the burgeoning filesize of HiRes content. Hence why I see Tidal being the solution.
*
Even just use the player as digital transport, sound quality and signature might be different also. smile.gif
I've tried the coaxial output of Fiio X5ii, iBasso DX90 and Cayin N6, the difference is quite obvious.

Not really recommend Andoird phone + OTG. Sound quality is not up to audiophile level. A HiFi quality OTG cable is difficult to find also.

X5ii and N6 both can support DSD natively, but it will convert to PCM format (normally is 88kHz/ 24bit) when using coxial output.
Most of the digital transport and DAC can only transfer or receive PCM signal via coaxial. smile.gif

If you can accept desktop unit, Oppo 103 / 105D will be a good choice. They support Tidal and Youtube. Also support SACD/ CD/ DVD/ Blue-ray. Can connect to USB thumb drive or hard disk, then use iPad/iPhone or Android device to control and select music.
liquidgal
post Oct 10 2015, 08:34 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(-Hzu- @ Sep 26 2015, 04:11 PM)
A total disbeliever of DAP here. I want to know if it's worth it to get a DAP. I currently plays all my music on my OnePlus One, which have a good enough DAC for all my needs. My only concern is the amp. Which made me come to this thread, to ask if I really should get a DAP or not.

If yes, any recommendations? My budget would be just below RM2k. Because everything above it must be overkill. It should be. Anything that is suitable for IEM, especially for a really sensitive one like the SE846 (which is my main driver) but is also powerful enough to drive the 300ohm HD650.

What I have in mind are the Cayin N5, FiiO X5 (1st gen, 2nd gen doesn't seem to worth the price because of those little upgrades) and the AK Jr. But I'm also pretty hyped for those new Onkyo/Pioneer and iBasso DX80 DAPs too.

I'm torn between of just getting an external amp for my OPO or spend some extra cash for a DAP.
*
Actually the retail price of X5 1st and 2nd gen are around the same. X5 1st gen already stopped production and supplier are running stock cleareance promo, that's why it's much cheaper than 2nd gen. (I think the promo also stopped already, now local stock only left 2nd gen)

Compare with X5ii, Cayin N5 sounds more solid, lively and forward. Warm sound with typical Cayin color. Sound signature quite similiar to N6 but thicker and smoother. Sparkling treble. Details, separation and transparency will be better than X5ii, but X5ii sounds very smooth and natural. For long time listening or bright/ forward headphones, X5ii might sound more comfortable. For mellow and soft headphones, N5 will give you more enegy and lively sound.

AK Jr has very clean and neutral sound, but the output power not really strong enough to power a headphones. I need to turn the volume to nearly max even just use it to drive Philips Fidelio X2, which is only a low impedance headphne. Don't think Jr can drive the HD650 without external amp.

If you can accept something bigger, heavier and lesser function, I will suggest you to consider the HiFiMAN HM650. The sound signature is the most analog and natural among the DAP above, but the details, clarity and separation still very good. Build in amp might be the strongest if compare with other DAP below 2k. The build in amp doesn't sound very aggressive and powerful, but it's very controll. If you want to find a DAP that can drive your HD650 well, HM650 might be the best. I've tried to connect Cayin C5 and Fiio E12 to HM650's line out, compare with it's build in amp, and I found that the improvement is not that obvious. The build in amp even sounds more comfortable. But...HM650 is very big, not beautiful (or ugly? sweat.gif ) and it doesn't support DSD format. rclxub.gif
liquidgal
post Feb 4 2016, 03:13 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(Paladin @ Jan 7 2016, 11:03 PM)
Oic. I thought the dap only transfer the data and let the dac process it and amp amplify the sounds to earphone/ headphone?

Anyone test it can share your experience or explain in detail?

Thanks in advance
*
QUOTE(shin2l @ Jan 13 2016, 10:00 AM)
haha, try comparing by stacking with AK100II (optical cable) and smartphone (microusb)

see which one has noises and sounds better icon_idea.gif
*
Hope it's not too late to reply. Using DAP to stack with DAC amp, DAP only act as a source in providing digital files. However, the quality of digital out does affect the sound quality and sound signature as well. So different players pairing with Mojo will actually give you different sound.

This is also the reason that you can find very expensive media players that people use in their HiFi system, mainly providing digital source only.

So far from my findings, players digital out is definitely better than hand phone (micro usb otg / iphone lightning)
In terms of player digital out quality, I would rank it this way. (best rank first)
1) Cayin N6 (provide most details and good separation. Sound is solid and could be aggressive to some) -coaxial
2) Sony ZX2 (It's comparable with N6, with softer and smoother sound, more musical and very easy to control)- WM port -micro usb
3)iBasso DX80, DX90, DX50 (iBasso player actually has very good digital out quality, except DX80 is a little bit warm sound. For those who likes cleaner sound may prefer X7 over DX80) -coaxial
4) Fiio X7 (Quite clean and it's android base and support music streaming. UI is not as fluent as ZX2 as a source)
5) Fiio X5, Cayin N5 - coaxial
6) Fiio X3II - coaxial

Haven't really tested out AK players hand to hand with the above players so no comment. Usually coaxial sound quality would be better than optical base on our experience (referring to the same device with both optical and coaxial) and it's easier for you to find a better quality coaxial cable.

Hope this helps. biggrin.gif

This post has been edited by liquidgal: Feb 4 2016, 03:25 PM
liquidgal
post Feb 4 2016, 05:44 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(kimsim @ Feb 4 2016, 04:17 PM)
I guess low end or jk junior level does not come with optical input
*
Yupe, AK JR doesn't come with digital out.

QUOTE(shin2l @ Feb 4 2016, 04:22 PM)
I always bring both: my AK100II on my hand, my Note 5 in my pocket, since my hand palm is big, I can use my Note 5 with 1 hand.

Sound quality wise, it is always a debate between smartphone and DAP, like my case, AK100II vs Note 5, definitely AK100II wins but not edges Note 5 too much, only in tiny details and dynamics.

If choosing smartphone as music player, users should opt for large storage capacity or with support of microSD, inaudible noise when paired with low impedance IEM, better stereo crosstalk (you can check in review of the smartphone). dynamic range etc
*
Not sure if you are referring to the audio quality (DAC/amp) of hp & DAP, or just the digital out quality.
To me, the former brings huge difference. The good quality of DAC amp in a DAP provides us good sound quality. This is also why audiophiles would upgrade to headfi quality DAC amp from onboard sound card and handphone.

The latter is more for audiophiles who find that DAP can no longer satisfy them and prefer to stack up with a better quality DAC amp, OR they want a better quality digital source than a handphone.

Of course, whether the difference is huge, it is really depends and it's subjective.

Using handphone as digital source, I would say iPhone is rather safe even though you have to spend a little bit more money on the camera kit / lightning cable. But in return, not so many compatibility issues like android, also the digital out quality is better than lots of android devices. My previous MI3 with Mojo is a disaster to me. It sounds better when I switch to Note 5 and iPhone.
But again, pairing Mojo with DAP such as N6 and ZX2 give me even greater surprise.

liquidgal
post Feb 4 2016, 05:48 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(shin2l @ Feb 4 2016, 04:47 PM)
Well if there is your choice, please buy the Cowon dock for Plenue S too

my next upgrade is slightly of different than others ---> Sony PCM-D100 laugh.gif
*
Sony D100 is a good choice. Strong amp and good details just that a bit bulky. Hai Wei used to owned a D50 for recording live performance.
liquidgal
post Apr 9 2016, 04:59 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(kimsim @ Apr 8 2016, 12:01 AM)
Lol like that my best choice for only iPod touch 6gen 128gb play with apple lossless file

But at least no issue for iOS update n wifi connection..
*
2-3k should try Cayin N6 also.
UI not very user friendly but overall very stable. Supports DSD and can be used as USB DAC.
Build in amp is using 13 pieces opm, very powerful.
user posted image

I have recorded a Youtube review of N5. There is some comparision between N5 and N6.

liquidgal
post Apr 15 2016, 08:48 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(ikan_semilang @ Apr 14 2016, 09:41 AM)
Guys, i'm thinking to get Fiio X3 Gen II and pair with ATH-M50X. It's should good pair? Or need to get IEM?
*
Depends on what you want. Headphones and IEMs are totally different, can't compare. Noramlly headphones more natural sound stage and IEM can provide more details (around the same price range). Better compare first before buying smile.gif

and yes, X3ii can drive M50x quite well already. It also match well with a lot of IEM.

This post has been edited by liquidgal: Apr 15 2016, 08:49 PM
liquidgal
post Nov 18 2016, 11:39 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(Tsukiko @ Nov 18 2016, 10:13 PM)
Looks like the sony a series supported format is less than fiio x1 2nd gen,is this true?
*
A35/36 support:
AAC (Non-DRM)
AIFF
ALAC
DSD
FLAC
HE-AAC
Linear PCM
MP3
WMA (Non-DRM)

X1ii suppports:
Lossless:
APE(Fast): 192 kHz/24 bit;
APE(Normal): 96 kHz/24 bit;
APE (High): 96 kHz/24 bit;
FLAC: 192 kHz/24 bit;
WAV: 192 kHz/32 bit;
Aiff:192 kHz/32 bit;
Aif:192 kHz/24 bit;
WMA Lossless: to be supported by future update;
Apple Lossless: 192 kHz/24 bit;
Lossy compression:
MP3、AAC、WMA、OGG....

So actually for me the main difference are:
1. X1ii supports APE, which is a quite comon lossless format.
2. A35/36 supports DSD (PCM conversion)
liquidgal
post Dec 11 2016, 10:41 PM

Enthusiast
*****
Senior Member
809 posts

Joined: May 2009


QUOTE(vexus @ Dec 7 2016, 09:01 PM)
between sandisk sansa jam and fiio m3, which one is recommended?
*
QUOTE(ssyycc @ Dec 10 2016, 01:06 AM)
Seems like Fiio m3 offer a lot of great features as a portable player. Anyway I have not personally review any of these products.
*
Can consider top up a bit and go for the Hidizs AP60. Size is as tiny as M3 and also comes with a high quality earbuds.
Support DSD plaback, 2-ways bluetooth and 2-ways USB in and out. Sound signature is clean and neutral.

user posted image

2 Pages  1 2 >Top
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0433sec    0.93    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 1st December 2025 - 06:05 PM