so you are pretty much suggesting that SAF shouldn't let Scholes come out of retirement even if he himself wants to?

It's a good mentality what. They fought very well IMO. I'd say something similar to avoid frustration.

i am sure Scholes won't made that offer if we're not so depleted due to all the injuries

yea, i believe some of our players might feel that way or say the same thing too..
had the reverse happened today.
it was a game of two halves really today.
city played really well wit 10 men in the 2nd half.

yeah, maybe he didnt actually get tackled so he'd rather focus on getting the ball back...still doesnt take away the fact that it was a dangerous tackle

somehow we took our foot off the pedal although this was a very good chance to stump them. surely with a man advantage plus our quality we could have controlled the game. and city jsut took advantage of it.

no comment on that, only Scholes himself knows

as my peer posted below.

First of all, is not that after he retired and just stay at home and be with family and after 230 days, suddenly said want come back play. He still will train with the team to tutor/inspire the youngsters

Secondly, Ferguson already said that he will not make any transfer during Jan window

Thirdly like wat mhyug, spending also need to understand the current transfer market situation. As we all know, the market price is rocket way higher and now buy a players at least 15m, not yet consider he can adapt into our style or not. If compare to new signing with Scholes come back, i take Scholes anytime even though he can't play week in week out

good for himself only, avoid frustration by being delusional. he could have said we lost today but proud of the team spirit etc, no idea how that relates to anything of a win in any form

not butthurt tho, juz found it funny

This post has been edited by SGSuser: Jan 9 2012, 12:31 AM

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/...y-sent-off.html

just scroll to 3rd pic..united fans trolling..wish that i'm with them..

Well Scholes should be used as a stop-gap and cover for the midfield while waiting for others to be fit...from certain POV it looks like we're desperate but for me it looks like a good move, and perhaps shows SAF's intent to wait until the youngsters are fully ready. If we buy someone it can affect team play, I think.

During the game there is one time he shoots straight to the GK I was hoping that he scored

Scholes : I want to retire .. tired legs ..

SAF : No signings in January ...

An hour before kick off ..

Scholes : I want to come out of retirement ...

SAF : Scholes is on bench ..

SAF & Scholes : Problem? *trollface*

The fact that it was announced only less that an hour before the game already suggested that it wasn't a desperate move.

boxy dah datang

wut's the problem of scholes comin out of retirement for one last season..
he wanted to play himself.
class is permanent..quality is permanent even after 200 no competitive football.
he can still play home games against lesser teams where we have much of the possession. i'm mroe happy to see scholes in our shirt than messi..yeah someone said it jz now but call me an idiot but that's how i feel

Can Beckham offer himself too? And Keano as well?

Cheap or not, their presence will definitely change things..

kecian hargreaves, less 1 cup competition to play

and we wont cost a dime..but really weird to see him with no 22 at the back..

This post has been edited by fronaldo: Jan 9 2012, 12:44 AM

cant play 40 games liao