Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 The Watch Thread v4, no watch is 2 cheap or 2 pricey 2 talk

views
     
ytkwong
post Nov 25 2011, 09:59 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
Seagulls are cheap china knockoffs ... they're selling Tourbillons for RM20k ... LoL

My personal favorite JLC Amvox 5, IWC Portofino 8 Days Power Reserve, Patek Calatrava, Richard Mille RM010, Breguet series of Tourbillon watches, Hublot Aryton Senna series, and of course Mont Blanc's R100 and R200 in-house mechanism ... but it's a Mont Blanc sad.gif ... hate em' Rolex ... So far, I only own a Tag Heuer F1 Kirium since 8 years back, Ball Aviator 46mm, a bunch of G-Shocks, and recently, 2 weeks ago IWC Portuguese Automatic 7 Days Reserve ... I've been saving for 2 years to buy this watch ... love the 7 days pr ...
ytkwong
post Nov 26 2011, 02:13 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
QUOTE(patryn33 @ Nov 26 2011, 04:56 AM)
what comment is for frostfrench. U should know me better ck77.

below is the 1940 IWC pilot watch
http://www.calibremagazine.com/node/305
user posted image

this is the 1940 Wempe B-UHR
http://www.heirloom2.com/military.htm#WEMP...E_HANDSOME_ONE_


Added on November 26, 2011, 5:02 am

what to LOL? Seagulls are not knockoffs. they did put their own brand and didn't copy JCL, IWC, PP, Breguet, Hublot design.

yes they sell tourbillon for ~20K, at least they are true tourbillion. workmanship is better than the other Chinese brands Tourbillons.
yes its cheap so whats your pt when U LoL?
http://usseagull.com/EnProduct.asp?ClassID...itle=TOURBILLON
*
What to no LoL? If you do understand the purpose of Tourbillon, you'll notice they're designed to provide extra accuracy, as Tourbillon is supposed to remove the gravity factor from the watch ... therefore making it a little more accurate ...
Go read about Seagull's user review, you'll notice that it is not an accurate watch ... not even COSC certified, and ppl are getting +-2-3 minutes a day. I'd rather save the 20k and buy a piece of shit Rolex/Panerai ... or top up a few thousand more to buy an IWC Chronometer (with modified ETA movement), or RM28k for IWC Automatic 7 Days Power Reserve, or in fact, any COSC certified watch with ETA movement ... My personal opinion, is to never buy cheap movement, or generic movements if you're paying such money for it ... coz you can buy in-house movements ... Rolex for one is in-house, and IMHO it's garbage, because they're being mass produced ... the only watch Rolex is worth looking at is the old Daytona which uses the Zenith movement, which is no longer in circulation ...
ytkwong
post Nov 26 2011, 03:08 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
I'm not supposed to quote which dealer I bought it for, but I got 32% discount for IWC. Retails for RM42k. I just bought mine 28k brand new from authorized dealer ... go ask around, and if you are buy watches often, you'll know of that huge retailer ...

Rolex is good, but not great. Not worth the money. I don't think I stirred the hornet's nest ... Rolex is like BMW ... if you want to be noticed, buy it ... but ppl who knows mechanical watches, will avoid ... same as BMW ... What makes Rolex famous, is celebrities ... Same as TAG Heuer ... they endorse super stars ... but most ppl know they're piece of shit ... I bought my TAG Heuer 8 years ago ... I just learnt to appreciate watches 5 years ago, and really found out I made the biggest mistake in my life buying TAG Heuer Kirium F1 ... for one, it's TAG, 2nd it's a Quartz ... Quartz movement ain't worth that kind of money ... The only thing good about Rolex is their service center in Malaysia provides excellent service ... unlike the others ... the other service center I can think of that provides excellent service is "BALL" ... they're cheap and fun watch ... great value for money ... they'll do whatever they can to satisfy you ...

Anyway, go to WatchUSeek and you'll find out about all the craps they talk about Rolex ... only good thing about it is it will get you "seen" and it maintains good 2nd hand value ... but a true watch lover will not think about 2nd hand ... coz they'll keep it forever ... like Patek Philippe's motto says it all: "You never actually own a Patek Philippe. You merely look after it for the next generation." .... love the watch ... enjoy it ... take care of it ... pass it on to your children ... smile.gif

Only 2 best of the best watches but they're out of my league now ... Patek and Breguet ...
ytkwong
post Nov 26 2011, 04:01 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
Okay. I'll come back with more reasons, I promise. I love this discussion thingy, as I'm a huge fan of watches.

Let's compare mass production to non-mass-production items in general.

Why don't you buy a Swatch? Swatch Group owns ETA. Which means ETA is in-house mechanical movement for Swatch. There are Swatch models out there within the -4+6sec guideline. Why buy Rolex?

Why buy Mercedes/BMW/etc. when you can buy Proton? Mass produced ... CamPro is a technology developed by Renault, but the patent has been bought over by Proton ... so they own the rights to it ... and it is widely considered/claimed by Proton to be their in-house engine ...

Think economics ... once an item has been produced in mass quantity, price tend to fall ... You can't design a movement 20 years ago, and sell for 20k back then (today's currency with inflation factored in), and sell the same movement for 20k today after selling millions of the same product. Initial cost should be high, because companies need to recoup their investment in research and development ...

IWC / Patek / etc. always come out with new models, with new movements or upgraded/modified/etc. which justifies the whole cost thing ...

Another example ... Will you pay RM300k for latest Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution that's using the first generation Evo engine? Technology advances ... todays in-line 4 - 2.4L engines easily get you 30+miles per gallon ... back then, 20-30 years ago even 1.8L engines can't get 20+miles per gallon ... I just refuse to pay today's technology price, for old technology ...

The best a Rolex could do is 40-70 hours Power Reserve ... the best IWC can do is 7-8 days power reserve ... Patek and Breguet does 10 days ... back then 40 hours Power Reserve is pretty damn good ... but today's standard, at least to me ... for a watch lover, who wears different watch everyday ... go for higher Power Reserve ... or buy em' mechanical boxes ... smile.gif

More to come ... smile.gif


Added on November 26, 2011, 4:06 pmOh yeah I forgot ... I love em' German made watches "Lange and Sohne" and "Glashutte Original" ... I love em' Grand Lange 1 tongue.gif


Added on November 26, 2011, 4:12 pmHowever, I will give credit when credit is due ... Rolex are great diving watches ... and it's rugged ...

But when you pay such price for a watch, a watch should represent you ... Rolex makes you look rugged ... but I prefer a watch that represents me ... "CLASS" ... smile.gif

This post has been edited by ytkwong: Nov 26 2011, 04:14 PM
ytkwong
post Nov 26 2011, 08:19 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
I guess it was my mistake, I apologize for calling certain brands "garbage/piece of shit". I guess I'll just clarify myself. What I meant was, those brand are not worth the money. It's like paying RM300k for a Proton Saga. Some of you do have your points right, to some, a Proton is in fact worth RM300k, but not to me.

One of you did mention about my taste 8 years ago, as to purchase a Quartz Kirium F1 TAG Heuer. Back then, I was only 21 yr old. I was young, and naive, or shall I say, I was totally new to luxury watches. It was a watch from my mother, as a gift. I went for purely look, and functions. Only to regret it years later, after evolving, learning to appreciate the beauty of the engine that drives a mechanical watch. I've found out that Quartz/Digital watches are simple watches to produce, can be easily produced. The most important part of it is an integrated chip that stores all the algorithm to record time, and of course a battery to power it up. Whereas a mechanical watch consists of many separate pieces, and in same cases, are handcrafted and installed piece by piece. After reading the history of mechanical watches, and how a movement was designed, I learned to love mechanical watches, as though it is an art. I'd compare Quartz vs Mechanical, to Photos taken by cameras, to pictures drawn by painters. Once you understand how much effort is being spent on it, only would one truly appreciate the final product. But of course, there are ppl out there who prefer camera pictures than hand drawn, as they believe it looks more realistic.

There's also another reason why I didn't quite like TAG Heuer. After owning the watch for 2 years, I needed to have the batteries replaced. So I sent it to KL Plaza's service center. After they serviced it, which I believe they didn't seal it properly, or a small amount of water moisture went in, and the chrome hour/minute/second hands had moist corrosion approximately 2 months after service. I took it back to to KL Plaza and blamed them, but they refuse to take the blame for it. Anyhow, I had them chrome hands replaced for RM1100 (and I still have the receipts as of today), and guess what? 3-4 months later, same shit happened. I brought the issue up, and my brother told me he warned me against buying a TAG Heuer, but I ignored, as he had same issues with his watch TAG Heuer 4000 Series Automatic back in the days, and my Uncle's 4000 Series too. Time wasn't accurate from day one, and sent for servicing, the watch became way too fast. I'm talking about tens of minutes too fast. Tried numerous times to fix it.

The way I look at things are pretty simple ... a brand is as good as it's service center ... technicians at TAG Heuer's service center in Malaysia are not qualified at all ... for as long as I remain in Malaysia, I would at least avoid that brand. That's also a reason why I avoided purchasing Zenith. I loved Zenith, but I went with IWC instead because of this sole reason.

Why I insist on in-house mechanism? I just believe that spending RM20k on a watch, is a luxury. I'm not a super rich person. That's why I would like to believe if I spent RM20k on a watch, it better be worth the money. In-house technology represents how deep that company/brand is into "it" ... Why would I buy a RM20k watch that uses an ETA mechanism that's found in watches under RM1k? Just for the design? Someone also mentioned Audi/VW/Skoda using the same 2.0TFSI engine, I appreciate it. But that's different, they are all owned by Volkswagen Group, IMHO. But we're comparing Apples and Oranges, there's nothing wrong with TAG Heuer using Zenith engines, because they're both sister companies under one same roof. Unlike cheaper watches like "BALL", which is a USA company, but purchases engines from ETA, and modify it, and sell the watch as it's own name. Don't get me wrong, I'm a BALL WATCH fan, as I own a Ball Aviator 46mm, it is indeed a very beautiful and great watch, for the money. I paid RM5500 less 32% discount for it. It was worth every single cent of it. As good as the Ball Aviator is, there is no way I would pay RM20k for it. Funny thing is, on certain days, my Ball is actually more accurate than my IWC. So value doesn't just rely 100% on how accurate it is. Also, if you guys ever seen and tried on the actual IWC Portuguese Automatic, look at the back of the watch, the mechanism itself is a true beauty, and I fell for it at first sight after looking at it. I've seen countless generic movements, and none look like the IWC I currently own. To fit everything in that small encasement, and pump up 7 days worth of power, to me is still a great invention/design. I hope you guys understand where I'm coming from.

Please don't come comparing classics to what I'm talking about. A 1960 Ferrari is considered classic, because they're built in 1960, and back then the engine in it was a "GREAT INVENTION". If you build the same model today, and put in the same engine, please do note this, built in 2011, the cost of that particular Ferrari will not cost the same. However what I was referring to regarding the old mechanism/technology, is a Brand New Ferrari, built, and installed with a 1960 engine, I'm willing to bet you whatever I have, it will not make it classic, and therefore not make it super expensive, because it is not classic. But I know, since it is still a Ferrari, the price will be expensive, but it will not be as expensive as a Classic 1960 Ferrari.


I didn't claim that IWC's are fully in-house, they do have movements supplied by ETA, for eg, one of my favorite is IWC Portuguese Chronograph, it has a modified ETA movement, and it costs RM22k after discount. I think it looks great, and is cheaper than the Portuguese Automatic I purchased, but I didn't buy it for the fact that it runs a generic engine. But of course, that is my personal point of view.

I just hope that I didn't really push the limit too much, as it seemed as though everyone is pretty pissed at me for dissing Rolex. I've claimed that Rolex are great watches for diving purposes, and of course the Submariners do look good. But somehow, I just don't think it is worth the price. If you own a Rolex, be happy about it, as a lot of ppl couldn't afford one, and I for one don't own one. Ppl do purchase luxury items so that it could in a way provide a sense of satisfaction, and it is very hard to justify. But again I emphasize that a Proton Saga costing RM300k could probably provide me with a sense of satisfaction as I drive around in it, but it will not provide the same amount/level of satisfaction as though I owned a RM300k Mercedes. But of course, I'd always go for the SATISFACTION/DOLLAR factor. smile.gif

Anyway, everything written above are solely my humble opinion, nothing but an opinion. Wasn't intended to make enemies here. smile.gif

Cheers. I'll be back. smile.gif

P.S. Why I also prefer other brands over Rolex? I can wear an IWC daily, walking through the markets/etc. without having to fear that someone would chop my hands off. tongue.gif I enjoy luxury at my own expense, for my own pleasure only. I don't do it just so that others would notice me, and put my life under jeopardy. My watch is something that I look at it everytime and it gives me the sense of satisfaction that only I, myself, most of the time know ... unlike a Rolex ... I bet you, go to a wet market, ask any random person if they recognize or heard of a Rolex, almost 99%, if not 100% ppl know about it. But try JLC, IWC, Patek, Breguet, Hublot, Richard Mille, etc. it'd be a miracle if more than 1 out of 5 person recognize even one of those mentioned brands. But don't quote me on statistics, I'm just trying to make a point, that's it.

This post has been edited by ytkwong: Nov 26 2011, 08:34 PM
ytkwong
post Nov 27 2011, 11:00 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
I do know Swatch Group owns a lot of em' watches. I didn't know Breguet and Glashutte Original uses ETA ... maybe some of their cheaper models, no doubt, but I know for sure, their high end models are designed in-house in Switzerland and Germany respectively.

Again, comparing Apples with Oranges. It's like VW 2.0TFSI in Audi A4 2.0T, and Golf GTI. But that 2.0T engine isn't in a Polo. VW also owns Bugatti, which they Veyron runs a W16 Engine, but you don't find that same engine in a Golf GTI, or any other cars by means.

This post has been edited by ytkwong: Nov 27 2011, 11:03 AM
ytkwong
post Nov 28 2011, 02:32 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
85 posts

Joined: Feb 2006
Han, I beg to differ. Almost anyone can easily recognize a Rolex. My brother owns a Explorer, and everyone could recognize it. I know coz all his friends go "OH, THAT'S A NICE ROLEX THERE". Even one day, when he was hanging out in my office, some of them made comments about how good that Rolex looked on his wrist.

By the way, another word I was looking at ... "EXCLUSIVITY" ... that's one thing ETA lacks ... smile.gif

Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0189sec    0.63    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 10th December 2025 - 09:08 PM