Back to the core of argument, it still go back to what you need.. if you can't see well definitely you need a bigger screen.. if you have a not so sensitive finger of course you still prefer bigger screen.. if you like to be more portability then you may prefer a smaller screen..

imho, it is no point of comparing on what a phone offer.. what most important is what you need and find a phone that can satisfy your need and budget better.. as a consumer you should clearly know what you need (not what others tell you that you need it, and also not what you MAY need - means in most case you probably won't need it)