Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Investment (Local and International), Everything About Investment

views
     
pidah
post Sep 10 2006, 10:43 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(Darkmage12 @ Sep 9 2006, 08:45 PM)
EPF dun wan let us take out the money for investment doh.gif
*
Investment frm EPF is allowed.. but only for account 1
and the money only can be invested in the SC list.



just my 2 cent.thanx
pidah
post Oct 9 2006, 05:35 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(hamster9 @ Oct 8 2006, 10:07 AM)
I see Public Mutual is kind of good. However something I hate about unit trust is that the management fee is kind of high in Malaysia.  shakehead.gif
*
I do agree with you unit trust management fees is quite high in malaysia, however try to look at different side of view about this. The 6.5% fees is only charge once when u invested. Let say u invest your money for 5 yrs, u only have to pay about 1.3% per year while your return is about 8-12% per year. i think its still pretty reasonable.

In Public Mutual, the fees only will be charge for the first 3 yrs of investment, if you invest more than 3 yrs, there will be no more charge frm Public Mutual execpt for the management fees. For your information also, here we in Public Mutual manage to cover back the service charge fees within 12 months and some of our fund manager takes only 3 months to cover it back.

This post has been edited by pidah: Nov 3 2006, 05:15 PM
pidah
post Oct 9 2006, 05:47 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
There are a few tips before you like to consider investing in any unit trust:

a. The expected return is always from a medium to long term investment (3-5 years). There is a case where a client already insisted for return after one month of investment even though I have mentioned about ROI vs. time invested

b. Get yourself the best unit trust consultants (UTC) or so called financial consultants among the best by checking is/her sales, promotions, achievements, etc.

c. If you are not ready for any risk, please do not invest. Just save wherever place you are comfortable with.

d. There are fees and charges involved and investors are adviced to consider the fees and the charges before investing in the fund


The best one also should be able to advice you with the following things:

1. The right time when the fund is good to redeem/cash out the money.
2. To use switch from one fund to another whenever there is dividend or split unit to be announced, so that it can maximize the ROI
3. Explain detailed about the Dollar Cost Averaging
4. Clarify that NEVER invest the money that you plan to use in 1-2 years if you do not feel to take any risk. Invest in others.
5. Explain much about the risk level in unit trust. Here, of course, I cannot tell much about it.


and also you must remember that there are 3 type of source of return from UT which are:

1. The rise in unit price (We call it capital appreciation)
2. The annual dividen/distribution/bonus declared
3. The unit split declared.

Of course at one point of time, once the item 2 and 3 declared, there is no value added, but once the unit price increase.., the value RM will definitely increase..


just want to share my 6.5% knowledge about unit trust.

This post has been edited by pidah: Oct 10 2006, 04:45 PM
pidah
post Oct 9 2006, 06:31 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE
So the service charge is monthly or what? I haven't receive my statements in this yet.
the 6.5% charge will impose only on your FIrst Innitial investment, its not monthly charge. On the subsequent investment there will no more 6.5% charge, only the management fees about 1.5% per annum of Net Value Aset (NAV)




QUOTE
*PS* I am interested in the Global Fund newly offered by Public Mutual. I understand is a high risk and I do not mind.


Well if u interested maybe we can meet up. i will explain everything.

some info about Public Global Select Fund - Public Global Select Fund




QUOTE
zOMG i never thought of that.  the fund company allow the loophole like this? i though it'll be too late whenever we heard of the announcement coz they use the backdate calculation or sumthin, hence new buyer got no benefit from that?


thats the benefits in Unit Trust, we got Switching facilities to minimize all the risk. and at the same time gain more returns.

This post has been edited by pidah: Oct 10 2006, 04:37 PM
pidah
post Oct 10 2006, 06:02 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(hamster9 @ Oct 9 2006, 07:43 PM)
I tot switching funds there's charges and not really that worth it?

Yes, I am interested in the promotional period but I'm not around Malaysia  sweat.gif
*
QUOTE(leekk8 @ Oct 9 2006, 08:39 PM)
Some of the fund apply switching fee, but some don't. If not mistaken, public mutual has no switching fee, pidah please correct me if I'm wrong. However, you only can switch among the funds that have similar service charge, else, you need to pay the extra service charge.

Pidah, about the global fund of Public Mutual, does this fund invest directly into foreign stock market or invest to foreign funds?
*
1. Switching - yup we do have switching fees at Public Mutual. Normally we charge RM25 at NAV price. Switching fund is worth it lohh, the mechanism is like this;
when the Composite Index going higher, the Fund Manager will switch the Equity fund to Bond fund/Money Market Fund (Fixed Deposit) where as here you will gain more RM. But when the KLCI going down, the FM will switch back the fund frm Bond Fund to Equity Fund. (here u gain more units). As i mention before, source of U.Trust - Rise of Unit Price (Capital appreciation).

2. At Public Mutual u can move/switch you investments between various funds in response to changing financial goals or market conditions.

3. As for the Public Global Select Fund (PGSF), the fund will invest in blue chips stock, index stocks and growth stocks listed on selected global markets. THe fund may also invest in fixed income securities such as sovereign bonds, corporate debt and money market instruments to help generate returns. (source: prospectus PGSF)

4. hamster9 - too bad uhh.. well may i know when u'll be back here? btw gimme a
call or text me on 019-2088600 or else just PM me here when u're ready to invest with Public Mutual.




pidah

This post has been edited by pidah: Oct 10 2006, 06:13 PM
pidah
post Oct 10 2006, 10:50 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(hamster9 @ Oct 10 2006, 09:21 PM)
So who's job is it to switch funds? The customers or the agent? I personally have no time in switching funds and monitoring here and there.
*
all the investments will be monitored by the agents. The switching thingy (depends on market conditions), selection of potential funds (which is related to investors financial goal), diversification of the investments; everything will be managed by your agent. Unit Trust its not like in shares market where you have to monitor everything all by yourself. So its kind of time winning on the investor;s side.
Besides, job as unit trust agents/consultant is not more than just do sales but at the same time we have to do financial planning (partially) in order to help investors achieve their financial goals.

and the most important thing is, we have to be a smart investor. Dont just leave everything blindly to the agents. 3 important things to be a smart investor;

1. have a good knowledge about investment
2. choose a Unit trust company with a good track records
3. choose a good agent, who can maximize the investors investment.

and smart investors may fully utilize the agent as well. The agent responsible not only to make sure the smart investor get what they want, but also to assist the smart investor in any ways... They just can't leave them alone.

pidah
post Oct 10 2006, 11:12 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(hermantino @ Oct 10 2006, 11:08 PM)
When you invest in UT, it will not be smart to monitor the market on daily basis. Also, it will not be smart to monitor the 1400+ counters in the market. That will be overkill. However, it is smart to monitor the market at least on weekly basis. If you are into syariah based UT, monitor the syariah index as well as KLSE index. If you are into bond, monitor bond index too. If you read from the paper that one counter nose dive by 90%, you smile, raise your eyebrow, and continue your breakfast.

When you invest directly in Bursa Malaysia, you must pick your own counter from the 1400+ available counters, and must monitor that counter closely. If you are short-medium term player, you must monitor the market index and the sector you are in. If you are into long term, you must check the company fundemental as well. If you read from the paper that the only counter you picked nose dive by 90%, your breakfast will start to taste like rotten egg. Got it?
just my 2 cents. icon_rolleyes.gif
*
What ever kind of investment you do or where ever you invest, you must check your potfolio and your net worth periodically. List down all your assets and liabalities, see whether u are better then before.. Take necessary action to improve the situation...

and a smart investor, u must put your own effort to study the market
doesnt matter whether u invest in klse or unit trust....since there is volatility in prices
however, unit trust helps u spread your risk in the market..
whereas if u invest in klse..u have to do stock picking on your own..of course the gain will be higher since the risk is also high...

so its up to u as investor to choose...use your appetite and your brain




pidah
post Oct 20 2006, 03:25 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(ky_khor @ Oct 10 2006, 11:31 PM)
if u can monitor and analyse market so well, might as well invest in stock straigtaway, lol.

correct me if i'm wrong:
1. let say i want to switch fund from PB Fixed Income to PB Growth. i need both account number, which means that i need to have both fund account. i can't switch to the fund which i never buy before.

2. PB serie fund can't switch to Public serie.
*
No, i don't think so. For confirmation, U could call agent service,
PB income and PB growth, any thing pertaining PB series, that one direct public Bank..

pidah
post Oct 20 2006, 04:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
user posted image


Fund vs Fund By Fund Type From 01 July 2003 To 06 October 2006

(Fund-1) - PUBLIC ITTIKAL- PUBLIC MUTUAL Return 56.08%
(Fund-2) - MAA MUTUAL ALFAID- MAA KL Return 40.71%
(Fund-3) - SBB DANA AL-IHSAN - SBB Return 14.65%
(Fund-4) - MAYBAN DANA IKHLAS -MAYBANK Return -15.03%
(Fund-5) - AMITTIKAL - ARAB MALAYSIAN Return -16.65%

pidah
post Nov 3 2006, 05:59 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
QUOTE(Drian @ Oct 27 2006, 06:18 PM)
You know I was calculating whether  unit trust is really worth it or is it just hype. So I took one as an example and benchmarked it against the FD to see whether it is really good or is it all hype.
Name of Fund Public Growth Fund

Category of Fund Equity Fund

Approved Fund Size 4.5 Billion Units

Launch Date 11 December 1984

Investor's Risk Profile Moderate

 

 
Fund Objective
To achieve long-term capital appreciation with income considered incidental.

 

FEES & CHARGES
Service Charge 5% - 7% of NAV per unit
Repurchase Charge Nil
Annual Management Fee 1.5% per annum of the NAV
Management Expense Ratio(%) 1.56 (for Financial Year Ended 31 July 2005).
 

Annual Trustee Fee
0.06% per annum of NAV, subject to a minimum fee of RM18,000 and a maximum fee of RM450,000 per annum.

For fund financial report please go to
http://www.publicmutual.com.my/page.aspx?name=PGF

go to review, register and download the report

Now
Assume I have RM100,000 and I invested on 2004 (since they have only 3 years data shown)

Beginning 2004
Service charge for purchasing = RM6000 (average service charge)
Total investment                    =  RM 94,000

Annual return 2006 = 4.78%
Annual return 2005 = 12.3%
Annual return 2004 = 16.79%

Investment value end 2004 = 109782
Management fee                 = 1700
Net Investment Value          = 108082

Investment value end 2005  = 121376
Management fee                  = 1820
Net Investment Value           = 119556

Investment value end 2006  = 125270
Management fee                  = 1879
Net Investment Value           = 123391
End of 2006 Sell
Sale value = 123391
Service charge = 8637
Total amount  = 114754
Net profit over 3 years = 14754
Annual returns =  4.918%
FD returns

4.2% for 36 months (3 years)
Now the point of my post , take a look closely. The unit trust "supposedly" has an average annual return of 11.29%(I think this is considered on the high side) for the three years but after cashing in on the profit you realised that it ONLY ouperforms FD by 0.76%. Can you imagine if the fund annual returns was just average say 7-8%.

Where did all the money go?
1.) Management Fees charged annually. This fees can go up to 3% REGARDLESS of how the fund is doing.
2.) Service charges. Every buy and sell are charged 5-7%.

So if a Unit trust fund boast on high annual returns, please do the maths and calculate how much the fund need to perform to cover all your "losses". I notice most of you just take annual returns figure without taking into account these factors at all.

Now do you still wonder why hundreds of million has been lost in unit trust as reported in the newspaper?
*
FYI, your culculation is too straight forward.
as i mention on my previous post....

3 type of source of return from UT which are:
1. The rise in unit price (We call it capital appreciation)
2. The annual dividen/distribution/bonus declared
3. The unit split declared. Switch from one fund to another whenever there is dividend or split unit to be announced, so that it can maximize the ROI

Of course at one point of time, once the item 2 and 3 declared, there is no value added, but once the unit price increase.., the value RM will definitely increase..


Why hundreds of million has been lost in unit trust as reported in the newspaper?

There is a few reasons why this thing happen
1. The fund they invest not really perform
2. They got a lazy ass fund manager
3. The company they invested in, holds small fund size.
4. Inexperience fund manager. For example; the fund manager put all the money in equity fund which is high risk fund without diversified the investments OR just leave the money fluctuate without do any proper switching method,


* Public Mutual only imposed the service charge once, on your initial/first investment. After that only management fees 1.5% perannum

This post has been edited by pidah: Nov 3 2006, 06:02 PM
pidah
post Nov 19 2006, 10:43 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
LOL, btw... lets start back our topic..
pidah
post Nov 24 2006, 01:41 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
202 posts

Joined: Jan 2005
i would say Unit trust. less monitoring, diversification of your investment, and the return is for sure higher than FD around 8-10%

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0377sec    0.50    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 11th December 2025 - 11:36 AM