QUOTE(Rotuham @ Aug 24 2011, 07:39 PM)
Not really.I dont underestimate his worth because i know he only plays well when the team is playing well.When the team is poor or when suarez is out
his performance dips immediately.
I have said this many times.But to play in the wing position,you need to have pace and take on defenders.Eg barnes,c.ronaldo etc who like to cut inside,open up space and shoot.
Either that or you should be the classic english wide man,putting in crosses from the byline although you cant run at defenders.Beckham,ray houghton etc
There are some who are a cross of both types: david silva,giggs,downing.
So can you tell me what quality of a wide man does maxi possess?He looks best as AM but we have many players who can do it better than him.
meireles,gerrard,kuyt.
It's not only his game that suffers when the team plays badly. A lot of other players are affected by that as well - football is after all, a team sport. If you think back, you'll be able to recall how Lucas got the same thing thrown at him, that he only played well when the team played well. If you're gonna use Suarez as a stick to beat Maxi with, then why not use it against other players when their form dipped whenever Suarez didnt take part in the game ?
Maxi is not a conventional winger, he's just a modern attacking forward who can play in various attacking positions. He's not the greatest player in that position but he's not terrible in it either. You could say the same for most of our players too but that's not all that important. The important thing is his ability to play along sides his team mates. As Kenny puts it, his strength is his football intellect. Give Maxi's brain to Babel and you'll have a killer footballer. If i'm not mistaken, just last season he had the highest ratings of creating non converted chances. His assists ratings would be unquestionable had those chances been converted. At the moment, he's still alot better than most of the lads from the Academy.
Imo, it's not important to get world class or 9/10 type of players. You can get away with lesser players just as long as you can get the whole team operating at optimal level. Especially when Maxi is now being used more as a squad player - a security blanket. It's far cheaper to keep him than it is to replace him.