I'll admit, I'm not watching anime much for fanservice nowadays.
For story, my picks would be Another and Symphogear, mainly because Another is a rare horror anime that's gotten pretty competent. Symphogear meanwhile has a really intriguing story going along with it.
I'm frankly just watching Natsume Yuujinchou Shi for the heck of it, since i've already watched the first three seasons and even if the stories are getting repetitive, it's always fun to see what new yokai gets introduced. Same with Last Exile 2 as well... even though the story is all over the place.
Most of the rest, I really watch for the character drama. Ano Natsu, Aquarion Evol, Moretsu, Rinne, Chihayafuru and Nisemonogatari are great examples for nice character drama even though I can pretty much predict how the story is going to be like. Good production values from the shows I mentioned also help.
I mean after over 5 years of anime watching as my main source of entertainment, I can say I've seen quite a bit of the same, but hey I still haven't gotten bored of it yet. There's always some aspect or another in shows that keeps me coming back. I've found out that just choosing anime based on fanservice or story will really make you miss out on a lot of interesting gems if you don't try to even watch them. Comedy anime are a great example, for instance.
umm not i like im saying but..story is good symphogear seriously? Another i understand i too got hooked on to it...after reading the manga...and watching the anime..but symphogear seriously? lol...i watch symphogear for the heck of girls doing extreme punches to monster n stuff like music...lol
back to topic...
once again shu has decided not to kill gai..shu WHEN WILL U FREAKING REALIZE U NEED TO KILL SOMEONE GOD DANG IT!!