Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 [WTA] Grundfos Water Pump, CH-PT or CH-PC

views
     
luckykid5
post Jun 17 2012, 12:33 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


QUOTE(zheilwane @ Apr 14 2011, 08:03 AM)
Actually, Grundfos CH2-50PC is good enough for most houses.
- 0.75 HP
- Max Head      : 45m
- Max Flow rate : 56 l/min

But if u are using big rain showers (10" and above), you might wan to get CH4-40PC to increase the flowrate.
*
can pm me the best price for CH2 and CH4? Btw, i read from the website that PT is far more quieter compare to CH2. is it true?

QUOTE(mhhee @ Apr 21 2012, 06:03 PM)
Recently I just bought Grundfos CM3-5PC water pump from Zean. Get my plumber to install it on Thursday & have a chance to test it today.

Here is my experience on this water pump & conversation with my wife after I tested it...

Me   : Oh... I felt so stupid & regret after I bought this Grundfos water pump.
Wife : Why? I tot u said it's good?  hmm.gif
Me   : No! U listen to me... I tested it just now... Now look at my pants...  cry.gif
Wife : Huh? OMG... U pee on ur pants?  shocking.gif
Me   : Urrrr.... No lar...
Me   : Hai...  Becoz of the water pump lar... Just now I opened my water stopcock in my bath room. The water is coming out from the water tap hole (I haven't installed water tap yet) & shooting at me around 1ft long... Where I'm standing 5 ft away from it... Then, I asked my contractor to open water pump to test...  shocking.gif The water just shooting at me directly on my pants...  Damn... I'm standing 5ft away from the water tap hole!!! My contractor & I laughing non-stop...
Wife  : I tot u said regretted buying it?  sweat.gif
Me    : Ya lar... I should have bought this earlier...  tongue.gif 
Wife  : doh.gif


In conclusion, this is a MUST BUY item.  thumbup.gif
*
who is zean? and how you come to choose CM3, instead of the normal CH2? care to share more?

QUOTE(zheilwane @ Apr 22 2012, 04:42 AM)
For those who are scared of burst and wanna get the right pressure, can consider Grundfos UNI E model. This model comes with a control panel where by u can control the pressure from 2.5 bar - 4 bar. This is a variable speed pump and it can maintain constant pressure
*
so what do you advise now? mine is a double storey terrace house.


Added on June 17, 2012, 12:34 am
QUOTE(JinXXX @ Apr 21 2012, 11:52 PM)
+1 high pressure... = risk to joints and etc..

ngam pressure + correct pipe sizing = perfect flow at ngam pressure smile.gif
*
so you ended up buying which water pump?

This post has been edited by luckykid5: Jun 17 2012, 12:34 AM
luckykid5
post Jun 18 2012, 12:26 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


QUOTE(zheilwane @ Jun 17 2012, 08:17 AM)
PC & PT pumps have the same noise level as they are using the same pump but PT pumps have lesser vibration as the PT can absorb some vibration and the weight of the PT will dampen the vibration as well.

CH2 has been discontinued and replaced with CM pump.

Who is Zean?

Zean = Zheilwane

If you wan to get a quiet pump, constant pressure and lesser water hammering, go for UNI E but it is double the price of normal PC pump.
*
can you pm me the price of this Uni E and the CM pump? So in your opinion, CM is good enough?
luckykid5
post Jun 21 2012, 05:14 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


QUOTE(stevie8 @ Jun 19 2012, 12:10 PM)
These pumps are cheap and durable. But as it is the continueous on/off of the pump is too noisy to have it in the house. When it cannot be installed in the house due to the noise you cannot have it on the roof but outside the house. That means the pressure from ground to the roof is lost especially so it it is double storey.

Unlike Grundfos pump you can install on the roof/celing. The pressure from top to the bathroom is not lost but even stronger as it comes down with gravity assist. When pumps are installed at ground it loses its head/pressure due to height/gravity.

When choosing a pump, you have to know what you want it for? What is the objective, what you want to achieve? You got semi-d 2 storey you should go for high range pump, not because cheap pumps are not good, because you can afford for luxury. Drive expensive car with re-treaded tires?

The plumbling charge is reasonably cheap for double story semi-d.
*
so basically, grundfos is a more recommended pump compare to others huh? brands like hitachi or panasonic? and moreover you can install it on the roof, which is outside the house.

what other brands comparable to grundfos, with similar specs, are good in your opinion?

QUOTE(JinXXX @ Jun 19 2012, 08:37 PM)
cthardware @ tmn mayang/pj that side got sell hitachi pump ...

700 bux i think its the 180gp... cause i checked out the pricing last year... it was 680...

didnt do any comparison between hitachi vs panasonic..

can't seem to find anybody selling panasonic one when i was doing my r&d..

i compared my hitachi with grundfos.. lol

i found that that.. grundfos is overkill for my usage so i opt for hitachi
*
so why you say gundfos is overkill compare to hitachi? you stay in double storey?

what you suggest for a landed property, double storey with 3 rooms and 2 bathrooms should use? i'm not using rain shower, just normal hand shower.


Added on June 21, 2012, 5:16 pm
QUOTE(leeandy @ Jun 20 2012, 10:21 PM)
Rm930 pump itself. Model have to look for the receipt.
*
where do you purchase it? compare to the grundfos model, which is quieter?

This post has been edited by luckykid5: Jun 21 2012, 05:16 PM
luckykid5
post Jun 22 2012, 01:30 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


QUOTE(stevie8 @ Jun 21 2012, 08:29 PM)
You cannot install pump outside the house exposed to sun and rain. You must provide cover.

I have experienced only grundfos and panasonic. Dont know about others. For panasonic you can install a bladder tank to reduce the frequent on/off but still it is noisy to be on the attic (between roof and ceiling).

Bathrooms (shower, toilet and wash basin) water are supplied by tank. Since the tank sit just above the upstair toiler the pressure is very very low as low as 5 psi. So people re-do the piping with main supply. In such case the tank water can never be used and turn dead water. One of the way to increase water pressure and same time using tank water is install a pump next to the tank. The pump draw water from the tank instead of direct main pipe. When you install pump on ground still the problem remains that you still need to re-connect main supply to bathroom and tank water goes dead. That explains why people pay so much RM1k plus when they can pay only RM400.
*
so grundfos is lesser noise compare to panasonic huh?

another question on the 1k plus and rm400 installation. i do know that if you install a water pump next to the tank, it will greatly increase the pressure to all the upstairs bathrooms like you mentioned. but why some pays rm1k and some pay rm400? what is the right way to install?

also, some have water tanks above the roof. then what is a good way to install it then?
luckykid5
post Jun 24 2012, 06:00 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


[quote=stevie8,Jun 22 2012, 09:23 AM]
RM1K plus refers to the price of a grundfos pump. RM400 refer to a Panasonic pump. Not the cost of installation or labour/pipe materials.

Not because install near tank increase pressure. It is because the tank sit at the top of ceiling/roof. The pump do not need to pump water up and lose at least 10psi of pressure. Instead the pump pumping water down and increase its pressure. Let say you throw stones with your hand. One throw from roof down on you and you throw up to him. With no effort he can just drop the stone and still the stone come down with force. if he uses full hand force throwing the stone at you you die if it hit your head. On the other hand you must use force and if you use full force still it is not as forceful. Who is at disadvantage? You la at the ground. Xun Zi said never engage battle with your enemy when your enemy is at high ground. Their arrow is double, 3 times the force. Their aim are few times more accurate. their swords are forceful, their spear can penentrate your armor. Whatever they throw at you stone, rock, arrow you cannot block. You will be tired climbing the hill and be killed.


Added on June 22, 2012, 9:38 amYou can install above the roof so long you provide cover from rain and shine. What i will do is to install below the roof with a pipe down from the tank above the roof. No need to be side by side with the tank.
*

[/quote]
thanks for the detailed explaination. so i guess, if my external water tank is on top of my roof, it would be better if i put my water pump inside my roof (can leverage on the gravity force), or can install side by side with the water tank, provided i build something to cover that water pump from rain and shine.

but basically, i guess better recommendation is install beneath the tank huh?

[quote=ozak,Jun 22 2012, 09:47 AM]
The pump that use in average home here call surface pump or booster pump. It mean to use to boost the pressure water for your entire house. Surface/booster pump cannot run dry as it will spoil the mechanisim inside. It also have a height limit of sucktion in inlet.

So the best way to instal is beside or below the water tank. In this way, the pump inside will alway have water and some small pressure inside for the pump primeming.(Easy start water pressure boost and water act as coolant for the pump mechanical)

If you want to boost the water up to your roof water tank, than your pump must install at the downstair main water supply pipe. Which the main pipe always have water and small present of pressure. But remind you that this kind of installation is illegal if I not mistaken. It can cause your neighbour low water pressure and get complain.

The price of the pump different of course got to do with quality, R&D, reputation, specification and durable. Just like proton car and benz.

Get the brochure or catalog of the pump and compare the specification. Check which 1 you willing to pay.
*

[/quote]
ok ok. thanks for the explanation. i wouldnt go for the illegal one, especially later cause more arguments with my neighbours. best is side by side, or below the water tank as you said huh.

btw, besides grundfos, you heard of maxflow from hydro1? i heard hydro1 has been in malaysia more than 10 years and as reliable as grundfos. price quite identical, but grundfos parts from germany, and maxflow from taiwan. any good?

[quote=JinXXX,Jun 22 2012, 04:34 PM]
i got it for my single story semi d...

if double story and your pump put at ground floor.. then you need more power... water is heavy == more power = better

for me single story.. max pump height 2.5 meters.. the hitachi that i got is more then enough for me, both pumping height/sucking height.. smile.gif

as for me i install it in my bathroom.. just above the the door eg 40 cm about that height.. easier to fix/service and what not... smile.gif no need climb into attic get dirty/dark and shit... (i did it that way cause i DIY the installation)

do note that installing in a confined space eg bathroom, will amplify the sound.. smile.gif for me i want to hear my pump run so that i know.. if i have a leak or the pressure switch faulty or what not smile.gif
yes always check the specification it will really tell you alot.. smile.gif
*

[/quote]
true also. so i guess, since mine is double storey, would make more sense to get a higher power huh. any other good brands to recommend?

[quote=leeandy,Jun 22 2012, 10:21 PM]
where do you purchase it? compare to the grundfos model, which is quieter?
*

[/quote]
I have no idea which is quieter as I don't have any experience with Grundfos. Bought it in Melaka. Hope it helps...
*

[/quote]
oh thanks.

This post has been edited by luckykid5: Jun 24 2012, 06:00 PM
luckykid5
post Aug 4 2012, 05:23 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


a friend of mine told me that grundfos company produce 2 brands of water pump.

1 is Grundfos water pump (made from TW) and another 1 is Gemini water pump (made from Italy). logically made from Italy should be better than TW right?

u guys heard of it?
luckykid5
post Aug 5 2012, 12:43 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
217 posts

Joined: Mar 2010


QUOTE(zheilwane @ Aug 5 2012, 12:02 AM)
Both are managed by Grundfos, the have same standard for QC, why must ITALY things must be good? Should look more on the spec and material used rather than the origin. FYI, Grundfos is reputable for their original pumps (GRUNDFOS). Gemini was bought over by Grundfos.
*
zheilwane, well technically QC for Italy should be better than TW right? At least that is my normal perception.

Anyhow, just check with my friend who had purchased this Gemini. He told me that Gemini material are majority plastic (good quality one), whereby Grundfos material is from steel (not stainless) and metal. So that sales people convince him that if get Grundfos, the steel will sooner or later become rusty since it's not stainless steel.

any comment?

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0396sec    0.27    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 27th November 2025 - 12:22 PM