QUOTE(blstz @ Dec 30 2018, 02:42 PM)
been surveying for water pump for my double story terrace house. 3 bathrooms with normal shower head. tank and pump to be located on ground floor, at the back of the house.
was recommended these 3 pumps
1. Ebara AM 8
2. Grundfos CM3-5PM1
3. Gemini EDP240PC
May i know what is the best way to compare spec? Is it by max head at same flow rate or max pressure or rated kW?
I was told that Gemini is with composite impeller, is this in anyway better than SS type?
Price difference between Ebara and Grundfos option is RM400 (Grundfos more exp). Any recommendations on which to choose?
My old house used Ebara before long time ago, remember it got to be quite noisy then one day it died so I sent for repair, the pump came back super quiet. Not sure it's just normal wear and tear that made it get more noisy over the years or not.
Been told that Gemini is made in Italy but i kinda doubt it. Any one know where were these pumps made in? Not that it matter much but just so I know whether shop can be trusted or not. Haha
grundfos is internationally well known for low noise, durability and powerful. For 3 normal shower heads u can actually get CM3-4pm1, however if u love strong pressure can get CM3-5pm1 as well since price difference is only RM 30.
Stainless steel impeller is definitely better than composite in terms of durability and noise level.
compare EBARA AM8 VS Grundfos CM3-5pm1
If u r looking for pressure, compare the head
39.7m (ebara) vS 46m (grundfos)
so is about 3.9 bar pressure vs 4.5 bar
energy consumption Ebara is 600watt vs Grundfos 500watt. Grundfost is more energy saving.
However, many customers like to compare HP (horse Power) which i think is not accurate, u need to compare Flow & Head not HP.
Since Grundfos is more energy Saving, kW is lower, hence HP is also lower as well but the HEAD (PRESSURE) is higher = stronger.
HP = kW x 1.34. So Ebara will b 0.8hp while grundfos 0.67hp, however in actual spec grundfos is stronger. Hence it is not accurate to judge a pump by HP or KW
How much is the EBARA pump? i tried to google online cant find pricing, grundfos is RM 1330 by my shop
This post has been edited by zheilwane: Feb 16 2019, 10:40 AM