QUOTE(ghane @ May 22 2012, 11:46 PM)
The internal HDD controller chipset for the PCH (and similar players) is extremely slow. This is for two reasons:
1. Cost of chipset
2. Power (remember, all power you consume becomes heat)
As such, there is no way you will get more than a few MB (I estimate 5 MB/s, 50Mb/s) in actual read/write speed to the disk. There simply isn't enough horsepower there, and insufficient use of NCQ, etc.
Why is this not a problem, normally? Think of the files you play. A 720p movie, 90 mins, is 2GB. So you need 22MB/min read speed. That is
MUCH LESS THAN 1MB/s !!!! (Sorry for shouting. but this is critical). Compare this to the 5MB/s that you can achieve. You have enough headroom for even your 10GB movie rips.
So in normal practice, when using the PCH as a media player, disk speed is so low a constraint that you would not even bother to benchmark. That is why it makes no difference if you have a 10000RPM Raptor, or a cheap USB dongle, for playing your BR Rips.
(And this is the entire point of x264, mp4, etc. We are using compression to lower the physical bit rate required).
However, if you use the PCH as a NAS, and start expecting it to serve your 200MB photoshop.psd file, you WILL hit speed bumps.
You may achieve 20MB/s over the network interface (I have my doubts, the Gigabit chip is being run in a low-power mode as well), but there in no place for the PCH to write a 20MB/s stream to.
(And by the way, most nome NAS boxes also claim Gigabit interfaces, but their disk access speed is poor. )
--
Sanjeev Gupta
Happy PCH user for 4 years
This has been an enlightning explanation, thanks, I must click your reputation.
Let me get this right, even though Popcorn and all the others claim Gigabit interface they will never be able to achieve it?
What frustrates me most is having what is supposed to be a Gigabit NAS Media Player which when I try to copy movies from my Network PC via wired LAN using SAMBA or similar to the Internal HD on the Media Player it takes forever.
By the way, I personally don't have a Gigabit Media player at the moment I have an old AC Ryan PlayOn HD, ACR-PV73100 which I have really regretted buying, in simple terms it has never done everything AC Ryan claimed, again the most frustrating thing being the Network / SAMBA interface. Forget things like YAMJ the network speed is far to slow, forget copying large 1GB plus movie files over the Network, overnight at best, mostly crashes.
My friend has the PlayOn HD 2 and it seems no better except the GUI is faster / more stable.
That being said I am looking for a new Media Player but from what I'm reading here nothing on the market now or being released soon will meet my specific requirements, namely Gigabit transfer of files over the network from a network PC to an Internal Media Player HDD, right?
Seems like like I need a seperate HDD, WD My Book Essential or similar, except I don't know of one with BOTH USB (2 or 3) AND LAN, the LAN to copy stuff from the Network PC and the USB to be conected to the Media Player. Any suggestions?