QUOTE(Jedi @ Nov 19 2012, 03:10 AM)
Hello my dear brother, I understand that there is this 'superstition' going on around invoking intercession of prayers, particularly when we all believe that Christ is the sole mediator between God the Father and men.
I will try my best to explain and hopefully, to clear the confusion. Still, I am very happy you ask me about this one because at the very least, to choose to stand in this interpretation or not, people will understand why RCC and Eastern Orthodox practices intercessory prayer at certain times.
In general perspective, “Pray” for non-Catholics is synonymous with worship. But, not all prayer is worship. There are four types of prayer: 1) Worship 2) Thanksgiving 3) Petition and 4) Intercession. The original meaning and use of the word “Pray” is to “petition” or “ask.” The practice of petitioning Saints or Mary dates to the earliest days of Christianity and is shared by Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, the other Eastern Christians, and even some Anglicans—meaning that all-told it is shared by more than three quarters of the Christians on earth—It has only been with the advent of Protestantism (500 years old or less) that anyone has questioned the use of this word.
In Genesis 30:14, it says, “Then Rachel said to Leah, "Give me, I pray, some of your son's mandrakes."
In Genesis 40:8, the bible says that Joseph prayed to his fellow captives as follows: “They said to him, "We have had dreams, and there is no one to interpret them." And Joseph said to them, "Do not interpretations belong to God? Tell them to me, I pray you." Here the meaning 'To pray' means merely to ask; it does not mean to talk to God only.
In 2 Maccabees 15:13-14, the dead Jeremiah appears to Judas Maccabees and it says that he prays much for the people of Israel. The saints are not dead, they are alive. Jesus says that "God is not the God of the dead, but of the living" (Matthew 22:32).
Paul says that we are surrounded by a cloud of witnesses, in Hebrews 12:1. Witnesses have to be alive in order to testify on our behalf to the supreme judge.
As Scripture indicates, those in heaven are aware of the prayers of those on earth. This can be seen, for example, in Revelation 5:8, where John depicts the saints in heaven offering our prayers to God under the form of “golden bowls full of incense, which are the prayers of the saints.”
In Revelation 6:10, we learn that the saints in heaven know what is going on down here on earth.
In Luke 16:24, we learn that dead people in hell can communicate with the very dead Abraham.
In Mark 9:4, the "dead" Moses and Elijah appear to Jesus and communicate with Him regarding his exodus from earth. People who believe that being dead in the body is also dead in the soul are called atheists, not Christians. It would be sinful to conjure up a dead person, like Saul did with Samuel (1 Samuel 28:14), in order to gain hidden knowledge (Deuteronomy 18:10-12). But asking for intercession (1 Timothy 2:1) from live, holy people is very biblical, due to the power they have (James 5:16, 2 Peter 1:4). Revelation 5:8 and 8:3 plainly state that the saints and angels present our prayers to God in the form of incense.
So, we do pray to saints, but not to worship them. We pray to ask for their prayers. They pray with us and for us, just as others here on earth can pray with us and for us. Have you ever asked a friend or a family member to pray for you? It is the same thing. Saints pray alongside of us to Jesus as our intercessors. They do not stand "between" us and God. There is indeed one mediator between God and man, and that is Jesus Christ. And what is He the mediator of? Paul says in Hebrews 9:15 and Hebrews 12:24 that
Jesus is the mediator of The New Covenant (the Last, Everlasting),
not prayer. Intercession in prayer does not equate to being the mediator of the New Covenant; they are 2 entirely different things. The saints are equal to the angels, and are His sons, according to Luke 20:35-36. John 17:20-23 says that the saints are one with God, and that He has given them His glory.
It also means, Saints enjoy the Beatification of God - Beatified Vision, Meeting God face to face, when we enter Heaven.
Sometimes, certain Christian denominations do pray to them, but some prayer is making a request. We make requests of the saints and of Mary for their intercession, which the Bible says is pleasing to God. Paul says that Christians should intercede: “First of all, then, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all men, for kings and all who are in high positions, that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life, godly and respectful in every way. This is good, and pleasing to God our Savior, who desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Tim. 2:1–4).
A request can only be answered by God. We request God’s help, his mercy, and his divine intervention. Nevertheless, we do ask the saints, the Blessed Virgin Mary and others in heaven to petition our prayer to God for us. All with the same goal, that God will help, have mercy and divinely intervene. Of course, through Christ, whose authority lies in His and Him alone, which is why every prayer, at the end, we say, through Christ, our Lord. Amen.
In real life, for example:
You are a good friend with C. Best of best since childhood. C's mum is also very loving towards you whenever you come over to his house.
One day, you played a prank on C but C got caught in a misunderstanding and was very sad over this situation. He refuses to talk to you for weeks for He is sensitive. You are very sorry, yet C does not want to see you, he needs time to cool off. Seeing you standing at the doorway for a few hours, C's mum, who is very loving to you (it can be C's dad/aunt) wishes for both side to reconcile, and to be loving towards each other. C loves his mum very very much, and upon C's mum enlightening and loving words of encouragement and advice, C decided to give it a try, to talk to you over it. In the end, you all are best friends without problems whatsoever again.
From the story, C's mum/dad/aunt can be the Mother Mary or saints who enjoy the beatific vision (face-to-face) with God (C - Christ), and through their intercession, sometimes when the God's answer is No, or Not yet, through our persistent prayers and through invoking intercessory prayers, God, who is all-loving, would grant our wish, even though He sees a little good comes from it/time has not yet come, but God always improvise and through us, work something good out of it. But then Protestants may say, why not go to God straight? the answer lies beforehand. God will also not be jealous of this. In fact, He is happy for we are faithful in our prayers, like a loving Father to son, we too, grant our children toys in order to make them happy
Besides this, we also look at the model life of saints when they are human beings on earth. i.e St Francis of Assisi, St Francis Xavier, St Thomas Aquinas. We understand that Christ has placed the perfect role model for us, through His life and His teachings. More often than not, in today's world we are often tempted and swayed, fell down only to be picked up by God's grace again. This is how all of us feel when we, feel like we fail our Lord. But there are people, Saints now, who had done it. We may heard of this saying, 'Every saint has a past and every sinner has a future.' Mother Teresa of Calcutta said, 'Saints are only sinners who keep trying'. They are an inspiration for us, but we definitely do not worship them. Afterall, heaven rejoices when we follow the Lord and our actions are pleasing to Him, through all helps in Christ and through Christ (The Branch and The Vine story) "Suppose one of you has a hundred sheep and loses one of them. Does he not leave the ninety-nine in the open country and go after the lost sheep until he finds it? Lk 15:4
Also exists Saints, who devote their life lovingly to the Lord our God, with such dedication that is admiration and inspiration to us, angels and God alike. Exists a supernatural phenomenon when God grants them grace and sanctity - when you have time, you can read up
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incorruptibility or visit some of these places for a close look-up - again, we do look to them in awe, how they live examples of Christ on earth, not worshipping. It hurts when people say we worship even over these things when we visit them. (Of course, it does not mean one has to reach this supernatural phenomenon to enter the Kingdom of God, but they are prime examples and proof of God's miracle and reward)
Addition: and yes, it happens that many catholics (elders esecially) may not understanding fully or grasp Catechism and foundation of knowledge of Christ, that is why they are constantly reminded by priests to devote attention to our Lord Jesus Christ, and not Mary. For Jn 14:6 No one goes to the Father except through Me. As for me, old habits are hard to change. Sometimes the elders refute this advice, but priest told me once: who are we to judge? (Mat 7:1-2) Do not judge others, then you will not be judged. The way you judge others, that is the way you will be judged. When we condemn that, they are not focusing on Christ! blasphemy! etc etc. For they have a loving heart, and God judges our hearts (1 Samuel 16:7). Afterall, love points to One, who is Love - God. I was satisfied with priest's answer on that one too.
Hi Jedi,
Appreciate your effort, so I've read your entire explanation with due respect. I'm not one of those who practice TLDR because I can get pretty long winded myself at times.
But still it is not Biblical. Bear with me. I will explain in simple summary. So that it is easier to discuss.
Before that, Just a bit of background of myself, so that you know where I'm coming from. I don't consider myself a pew warmer. At best I have an on-going relationship with the Lord just like yourself. No longer young in age but still young at heart.

The things of this world doesn't really interest me that much anymore like it use to.
And I know I don't deserve this, but by God's grace,
God does speak to me. I've been getting revelations from the Holy Spirit. To me it's really an honour, because I believe there could be a platform Ministry waiting, if God is willing.
At times, the Holy Spirit would just highlight certain things. And here's one of them.
You agree that there's only 1 mediator between Man and God, Jesus Christ. If there's only one, then the Bible literally means it. I don't consider prayer the same as worship. IMO prayer is prayer, you can ask or petition or just talk to God, it is still classified as prayer.
The reason why the Holy Spirit
specifically mention Jesus Christ as the only mediator of channel to God and not through anyone else is because only
He alone is the access to God, no one else. He was the
only one who came to
represent us to God, through his death on the cross in remissions of our sins, the apostles didn't die for us. The Bible specifically mention Jesus is also our High Priest to replace the Priest of Old as in the Old Testament. Therefore there is no longer any need for human priest
to represent us to God.Not the pope or any other priest will be able to do so because the Old Covenant has been made obsolete.
Didn't Jesus himself said, No one comes to the Father
accept through me? It didn't say through me and the saints and mary. That's why I say some of the Catholics interpreted the scripture base on loose understanding of it's context.
During the times of the apostles as in the book of acts and so forth, whenever the apostles prayed, Jesus is still their Mediator to God. They cannot access to God without Jesus.
So to say that Catholics pray to them because the saints offer prayers to God? that's the same thing as using the saint or Mary as a mediator to God. It's contradiction.
The keyword here is, you pray
to them. Praying alongside with them, would require for them to be alongside with you, just like your friends in Church. But the stark reality is, they are not alongside with you. They are in heaven. They could be praying to God but that's between them and God. Only God can do so through his omni presence power to be with each of his children alongside. The Apostles, mere human beings do not have that kind of power.
So Imagine the multitude who pray to the saints so to speak, but how can those few saints represent alongside with the millions if not billions of believers? The keyword here is alongside as in together? That kind of practise is akin to treating them like some kind of deity very much like Taoism.
It contradicts this verse.
1 Timothy 2:5. For there is one God and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus,
Only Jesus Christ. No mention of whatever saints.
Another thing I want to highlight to you is that, you err when you say only the saints have power.
You do not understand, we are all saints in the eye of God the moment we put our Faith in Jesus Christ.
We all have the same spiritual gifts In Christ Jesus. The apostles and Mary are on equal ground with all of us with regards to God's blessings.
Is it of your doctrine to believe that the saints are more righteous or better than any of us because of their works?
Because if you say so, I can prove to you, that such doctrines are erroneous. I have a number of devotions that explains this in this thread.
You claim many Catholics (elders especially) may not understanding fully or grasp Catechism. I claim many Christians do not fully understand Righteousness by Faith and not of works.
Especially when you quoted James 5:16 and 2 Peter 1:4, I already more or less understand where you missed out in understanding the scripture.
Go back through the old pages, at least 30-40 pages back or just search by my post, I have written very extensive devotion on this.
This post has been edited by unknown warrior: Nov 19 2012, 03:00 PM