I have been with Commuter for 1 month plus. Tried Defender since last week as some bros want a mini review and comparison.
Simply put, at the end, I settled down for Defender. It is bulkier than Commuter but the protection is second to none - it is virtually dust-proof. But styling wise, may not be suitable for ladies coz it is too macho imho for ladies.

The silicone of Defender is at the outer layer but it is not as sticky as some other silicone casing. If you are using a pouch like me, then can totally ignore this sticky problem. It do attract dust and lints but again not as much as other silicone casing. I think may be it is because the ultra smooth finishing. It does not feel like silicone - more like rubber instead.
Thanks for the support but there is no need for you to buy 2 cases from me. You can top up RM40 and change to Defender.

But I do keep my Commuter though.

Now got 3 casing - 1 Epik case from AskarPerang, 1 Otterbox Commuter and 1 Otterbox Defender. Going to get a customised Easecase leather pouch which can fit Desire HD with Otterbox Defender soon. Think I spend too much on Desire HD accessories.
