This is a "weird" movie.
Why?
Firstly, this is the only "Tsui Hark" involved movie, that got such a small cinema release over here in Malaysia!!
Second, this is a Ku Long Wu Xia novel, and his works are... hard to adapt.
He supposedly writes beautifully and hence the issue. it is very hard to translate the "romance" from book to screen!
This novel had be adapted to movie, previously, namely Death Duel (1977). The actor of this movie, Derek Yee, is now the director of the new adaptation!!! I believe the 1977 version made Derek Yee a star and he probably feels, the movie would be better so with Tsui Hark help, he decided to revision this movie.
As I said, WEIRD, and have to add, in a good way!!!
I have watched the 2016 adaptation, and is currently reviewing the 1977 version, right off the bat, I see the 2016 version is more edgy.
Alot of topics that were deemed to risque, are brought up in the 2016 version.
As for the casting, I have to say it is pretty good, with one proviso... Lin Gengxin who plays San Sau Yeh is a little underwhelming compared to the "bad guy" Peter Ho as Yan Shisan.
I am not saying that Lin Geng Xin is a bad actor, it is just that Yan Shi San role is very juicy and Peter Ho did a really good job!!
Please also not the middle part of the movie, covers alot of character development and back story so in term of pacing it got slow, but everything else is good!!
So, if you like Wu Xia movie, this is good!!
My Two Sen
Dec 3 2016, 12:22 AM
Quote

0.0354sec
0.40
6 queries
GZIP Disabled