i need all of the opinion that i could get..
as i will be going to buy a car.
which is best in your opinion between satria gti or satria neo,
which includes on fuel consumption, reliability, and etc2..
really do need ol of your peeps here on these two car.
as i need it to used it to travel from kl- Malacca and sometimes malacca- kl- Terengganu.
so which is best on comfort, reliability and fuel consumption

This post has been edited by qwerty111: Dec 23 2010, 12:33 AM

satria gti...

high risk car.

whenever ppl talk abt sgti
first thing pops up in my mind is tat thieves like it

take the neo and sleep tight at night....friend lost his GTI TWICE in less than half a year....now claiming total lost and getting another car

really..
thought so.
as it happen 2 my uncle a few years back..
his gti had been converted 2 4g93t with a lot of goodies and got stolen in front of the house...

ok2 what about that neo though

for me neo can be reliable,..
lotus handling,..
if alwez long driving, FC not so much,,.
last day i travel on neo from kl to ipoh oni take RM20++,
coz at first i filled in RM40 only,..
arrived at ipoh still have half of it,..
1.6 CPS, so couldn't expect more on FC...
for comfort,..
if you have a family,..not recommended,..
if u alwez hitchiking people,..
a bit difficult for access & egress to back seat,.

you better be more specific with what you want.

relaibility - there is a possibility of high maitenance when buying a 2nd hand car.

Fuel consumption - 20 sens / km? 15 sens / km? Note that you are comparing a 1.8 and a 1.6. Layman, 1.6 is much better interms of consumption.

etc... - we don't know what else you are considering when you put this.

By being more specific, we all can answer and help you get a good car.

fast car - gti
slow car - neo

take ur pick.

More appropriate list.

Better take Neo, new car fresh engine. No hassle

You travel long distance, better go for new car

This post has been edited by yehlai: Dec 22 2010, 09:17 AM

if u r not living in KL, penang, or JB its kinda ok to opt for gti.

coz king of thieves only lives in 3 area, KL, penang, JB

This post has been edited by archonixm: Dec 22 2010, 09:24 AM

SGTi = higher power output, higher range in modified n of course cheaper, many option in parts, recaro seat as standard, etc
NEO = agile in cornering, new design, anymore?

Even KB oso no safe anymore..many SGTi stolen nowadays..

---

Added on December 22, 2010, 10:43 amIs 4G93P SGTi as revvy as campro engine ..
i once drive my fren SGTi, its drive on pure torque from its 1.8 L engine combine it with light body but its quite hard to rev the engine IMO..i dont know whether this happen on my fren car oni

This post has been edited by pedanglaut: Dec 22 2010, 10:43 AM

yeah, thanks for all.
yeah as i am still studying at malacca,,
my house is at terengganu and my kampung is in kl...
so will have to travel quite some place..
so that's the case.
as my father only give me two choice to buy a satria gti or a satria neo..
hence i need to know which have better fuel consumption as some say gti have better fc even though it has a bigger engine..

---

Added on December 22, 2010, 12:42 pmyeah i am oretty sure that i will just get a second hand car as there is no newer model of satria gti aite,,
and for that neo i am not sure it all depends on my dad..
which is more reliable when it is used to travel up terengganu back to kl then to malacca

This post has been edited by qwerty111: Dec 22 2010, 12:42 PM

Satria neo cps FTW

what is the problem with neo cps dude

nothing if you opt for neo go for the highest spec which is happen to be neo cps. and put another 10k for r3 performance kit. hehe will give you additional 15hp and 15 Nm.

hahahha.
pocket ain't that deep la bro to do that kind of stuff

wonder nowadays, what is the satria neo cps and GTi worth how much? atleast 30k right?...

TS @.@ why not fork out another few thousand to get yourself a new saga BLM Fl?

For sure, SGTi will have higher FC.

Why?

was thinking bout it 2 ..
as will only be using it.
just need a two door car dude

---

Added on December 22, 2010, 2:45 pmreally??

This post has been edited by qwerty111: Dec 22 2010, 02:45 PM

how sure are u??

Sgti has more power and torque to push a lighter body

while the neo has lesser power and torque to push a heavier body...

+1
Thats what i'm thinking too..
if u opted for normal neo..u got torque dip around -+ 3000 rpm which is cruising rpm at high gear..u got tough time when facing the slope road thus FC shud higher
if u opted neo cps on the other hand, the high Final Drive sure not cruising friendly so u oso got higher FC on highways..
with less weight and high torque car u might be gettin lower FC in SGTI IMO

this would be nice though....

Civic EF with Y1 gearbox and B18C GSR

light body...low 4.2 Final Drive... power and torque from a 1.8

ha ha ha ha ha

hahahah..
i am confused with all that ..
but to me my father's car is has the best fc in the house rather than my mum's car..
har har har..
at first he offered his car then after a while he changed his mind.
har har ..
there it goes

what is ur fathers car?

he drives a honda accord cl7 or cl9 ..
i am not sure

Wow..Euro R accord? ur dad must be Fujiwara Bunta rite?hehe

haha.
no lah .
his just like any other ordinary chap with his age.
he already sold of the car last week..
he will be using his old car for a while till he managed to get his new car

Editted : For my opinion

My bad...

---

Added on December 22, 2010, 4:27 pmMy opinion... Old ride, wear and tear, user feedback (driving style). I might be wrong though.

Personally, I prefer SGTi.

This post has been edited by jason4883: Dec 22 2010, 04:27 PM

Good for you.

Good luck with your purchase..

yeah..
still haven't had in my mind which one will i get

4G93P stock can go up to 7.5k rpm
Campro hits the rev limiter earlier

Neo's weight is around the SGTi's weight

1.8cc with 11xxkg kerb weight does have better fc

wow..

it seems that the sgti have a lot of wow factor than the neo.
as i'm considering a car that will have good fc and not forgetting handling..
as most of u know traveling up to terengganu will have to go against karak highway, and not must not foresee the jabor jerangau highway which i think needs a car with a good handling

and also beware of thief ok.

yeah will take that advice.
as i have said earlier.
my uncle lost his sgti ..
being stolen in front of the house

why your dad only give 2 options? And what is his budget? And which neo are you looking at? Cps or non-cps? Btw, your dad was driving a euro-r accord?? Cool car

yeah it seems that most probably i will just look for a satria neo..
besides normal neo or a cps neo i am not sure..
depends on luck and my abah le.
so there goes.
if there is anyone here who would give me any opinion on other car within the same budget i will surely like to know bout it

This post has been edited by qwerty111: Dec 23 2010, 08:28 PM