Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Android GPS Software, What is your pick?

views
     
ThisIsBoletaria
post Dec 9 2010, 11:30 AM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
108 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: Jemapoh To Manchestee
Papago X5
+ MFM maps currently updated monthly
+ 3D turn preview so that you don't get confused about which junction to take

- MFM maps is slow to update for Papago
- Impossible to import saved locations from other programs
- Difficult to input precise location data

NDrive
+ Fast
+ Can import .kml files to your location list.
+ British voice

o Cannot input coordinates in the program, but you can put in exact coordinates in Google Earth, export to .kml and then import into NDrive

- Confusing interface
- Maps are not very up to date (about 6 months old at the minimum for Malaysia)
- No free maps

Garmin
+ MFM maps
+ Frequently updated MFM maps
+ Can enter location by coordinates

- Currently exclusive to Asus-Garmin models. In the future, it will be exclusive to Asus models.
- Slow POI searching since it does not use indexed POIs.


Brut Google Maps
+ Uses Google Maps data, so worldwide availability

- You must view the map on your phone before Brut will save the map data. If you did not zoom in to an area and only looked at it from a lower zoom level, you will not have the zoomed in data.
- Downloading map data using third party programs is possible, but will take you days and days and days for just the Klang Valley if you take all the zoom levels you think you will need.
- Saved data takes up a lot of space on the phone (at least 300 mB for Klang Valley detailed map data alone)
- Must be connected to the Internet to calculate route if you use the Navigation feature

This post has been edited by ThisIsBoletaria: Dec 13 2010, 03:37 PM
ThisIsBoletaria
post Dec 9 2010, 12:07 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
108 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: Jemapoh To Manchestee
QUOTE(lch78 @ Dec 9 2010, 11:53 AM)
Nice review. I think so far only Ndrive has support for coordinates input...
*
Ndrive does not have support for coordinate input. However, as I said, you can fake it by using Google Earth to enter the coordinates and export to .kml. That's the closest I can get to Garmin's coordinate input, which is why I use it.

@khalpowers: Can you put in locations using coordinates?

This post has been edited by ThisIsBoletaria: Dec 9 2010, 12:18 PM
ThisIsBoletaria
post Dec 9 2010, 12:53 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
108 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: Jemapoh To Manchestee
QUOTE(khalpowers @ Dec 9 2010, 12:52 PM)
Cannot but can search coordinate from my contact list...so need to add coordinate on the contact list...
*
Sounds good. I will give it a try.
ThisIsBoletaria
post Dec 13 2010, 02:26 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
108 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: Jemapoh To Manchestee
After using Sygic Aura for a few days, this is what I found:

Pros:
+ Superb interface and easy to use for the most part, thanks to the multitouch zoom feature and the fast rendering.

+ AGPS support?
I think Aura uses wireless network data or cell tower data to make a rough placement even if GPS is off. I might be wrong about this, but that is what it seemed like to me. If it's true, then this is the only GPS program I've used so far that actually does it.


Cons:
- Expensive maps. Seriously, Sygic, 60 USD 30 Euros for a map of Malaysia and Singapore? Ndrive charges 20 Euro for the same thing.

- No free maps... which makes the previous point worse.

- Cannot import other locations from previous GPS programs. So far, only Ndrive has the ability to do this out of the box.

- Cannot edit a favourite location that you have already recorded. Change name? Yes. Update location? No.

- Damn near impossible to cancel navigation.
For some reason, Sygic buried the Cancel Navigation button three menus away from the map screen. At the bottom of the page. In a program that otherwise has an intuitive and easy to use interface, this stands out a lot.



QUOTE(buntutwoman @ Dec 9 2010, 01:53 PM)
papago can enter exact co-ordinates also.
it just uses hddd.ddddd format which u have to do some maths or use mapsource or use a garmin.
professional mappers uses hddd.ddddd format. only regular people uses hddd mm.mmm format.
I would like very much for you to teach me how to do this, because I've been trying for ages and I can't figure out how.

QUOTE
another thing which you have failed to mention is that papago is on indexed poi's. meaning your search turns up in under 1 second.
garmin searches for it via radius.
to find a poi in papago in much faster than in garmin.
i would say almost instant searches in papago.


This is true. I forgot that Garmin uses radius while Papago, ndrive and sygic all use indexed searches. I have updated the previous post to reflect this oversight.


QUOTE
and to say mfm is giving out slow updates on papago is a very wrong and unjustifiable statement.

...

honestly, things that come to you free, you cannot complain. you pay, you have the right to complain. mfm does not owe anything to anyone. if they release papago map every half yearly also we have to be patient and still thank them for the efforts put in. mana ada orang complain free punya barang ? no one has the right to do that ler.


It is correct and completely justifiable.

In six months, they have put out exactly one mapset, which is the first one that they produced. I don't know about you, but this counts as slow in my book, especially since a new Garmin version comes out once every 1 - 4 months.

To be fair, we all know MFM is Garmin-centric - they started with Garmin devices, after all - so it's not too surprising that the Papago updates are slow. There simply aren't as many members doing Papago updates, and the main head of the project seems to have retired, casting the future of the Papago updates in doubt. They are also trying to get the Papago updates back up and running.

This is not a pointless rant or being thankless for the effort MFM puts into their completely free map updates. People do need to know that the MFM updates for Papago are much slower compared to their Garmin updates, so that they don't get their hopes too high up and be disappointed.


No longer applicable as cwleong59 has helpfully pointed out that the MFM Papago updates are finally up and being done on a monthly basis.

This post has been edited by ThisIsBoletaria: Dec 13 2010, 03:41 PM
ThisIsBoletaria
post Dec 13 2010, 03:01 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
108 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: Jemapoh To Manchestee
QUOTE(lch78 @ Dec 13 2010, 02:49 PM)
I thought maps are downloaded free from Aura downloader?


Maps downloaded from the Aura downloader within the trial period are only valid during the trial period. For a license to use the maps after that, you have to pay.

QUOTE
Where you find the USD60 price tag?


Sorry, it's supposed to be 30 Euros for a Malaysia + Singapore map. I was looking at the price for the full world map, which is 60 Euros. Previous post corrected.

I found the prices here: http://www.sygic.com/index.php/how-to-buy.html

My mistake.



ThisIsBoletaria
post Dec 13 2010, 03:36 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
108 posts

Joined: Jan 2010
From: Jemapoh To Manchestee
QUOTE(cwleong59 @ Dec 13 2010, 03:34 PM)
Strange to hear that MFM is slow to update papago map. I update once a month in the MFM site and my latest map is dated 1.12.10.
*
Someone should update the thread I linked to, because there was no mention.

Updated my comments on Papago X5 to reflect this. My apologies for any confusion created.

This post has been edited by ThisIsBoletaria: Dec 13 2010, 03:38 PM

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0141sec    0.54    6 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 14th December 2025 - 04:42 AM