QUOTE(hfi @ Apr 12 2012, 11:25 AM)
After hearing mixed reviews, I held off from watchign this for a long time until last night. And i have to say i was quite pleasantly surprised by it. I kept thinking about BR at the start but after awhile i was totally absorbed by the story. I really like the character Katniss, and i didn't realize the actress was also the lead in winter bone, she was amazing in it - and the male lead was great as a love conflict. But i just wish my active imagination wasn't so intruding during the show. I kept thinking Peter was playing Katniss to gain her trust before doing something dodgy. As it turns out, the story is as predictable as it gets but that's not necessarily a bad thing if done properly.
There were few things i didn;t really like - the shakecam imo was over-done to a point where i felt a little uncomfortable. But there were times it was used to great effect like during violence scenes. The film felt a bit draggy at times but i suppose its meant to be faithful to the book ?
Rip off or not, i thought it held its own. It had good characters and the performances were also quite good.
If Ross didn't sign up for the sequel i say give the reign to Matt Reeves. I think this kind of film is tailor made for someone of his caliber.
Im glad that you gave Hunger Games a chance to proof itself. But the movie did not explain much. A lot of people were confused on the romance part but Katniss did not know that Peeta was really in love with her until the end of the book but then they didnt show it in the movie where Katniss told him that it was all an act to keep them alive and how he was so heartbroken about it.
The part where he saved her life by giving her the bread also didnt tell much. How he rather be hit by a rolling pin from his mom so that he can give the breads to Katniss. It was the hardest point in Katniss's life after her beloved father died and her mother went into a depression that she had to scrape around the garbage bin to find food for them. Then the next day when she was no longer starving, she saw him at the school and when she turned around, she saw the dandelion on the grass which reminded her that there is always the option to go into the woods like she used to with her father to hunt for more food. That's why Katniss will always remember him because it was the thing that had kept her and her family alive. But I guess it was too much to put into a movie with only 2 and a half an hour show.
I dun feel the draggy-ness. Maybe its due to the book. In the book, when katniss is in the arena, she had a hard time finding water and how bad her condition was until she found the spring but in the movie, XD she found water instantly. Lol. They didnt even explain much about her designer Cinna as well. He was a very good friend to her. Volunteering to be district 12 designer. Katniss was lamenting what type of costume she will wear remembering how when one year, the tributes were practically naked and covered in coal dust.
I personally don't like the shaking cam as well. I know they wanted to make it into Katniss' pov since the book is from her pov but it caused us to lose a lot of action scene. But i guess overall, the director did a good job on the storytelling. Most of the important plot was told.