Which trasnfer gave the greatest impact to their team? Discuss.

This post has been edited by liez: Nov 12 2010, 04:35 PM

Surprised Yossi is there on the list

Voted for Vdv

This post has been edited by SGSuser: Nov 12 2010, 04:37 PM

i go for chamakh... he just awesome..

---

Added on November 12, 2010, 4:38 pmi go for chamakh... he just awesome..

This post has been edited by ReBeLLioN: Nov 12 2010, 04:38 PM

VDV by heads above the rest. Nuff said.

only epl teams?

This post has been edited by Envoy: Nov 12 2010, 04:41 PM

yes choose VDV ...

chamakh still doesn't score consistent enough ... j.cole play normal only ... benayoun no need say ...

yaya the biggest flop consider his salary is 220k.

quite obvious who has the biggest impact. Chamakh for Arsenal is still normal. Just someone to replace Van Persie for the time being? I think they should have just used any of their subs cause they're good.

the list will be too long and the comparison will be too vast and sometimes might get off the line since every league differs. Fro example: Suarez's stats is much more power than Messi doesn't mean he is gonna achieve same feat in Liga BBVA. Nevertheless, one can discuss and compare it too. I just didn't feel like listing everyone in the poll so I put an option of 'others' in it.

Chamakh. Imagine if Chamakh didn't join Arsenal, and Robin van Persie, Bendtner, Walcott are (and they were) injured...

chamakh of course.
got him for free.
and he's been scoring a lot of crucial goals.
a few assists here and there.
and the number of penalties he won for arsenal.

Based on the money involved.... Chamakh

There there, there's no need to say who's the flop coz TS din ask for that, try to prevent good-thread-turn-bad

Voted for VDV Meireles also quite good for Liverpool ma

TS mention most impact, not most bargain buy..

VDV win hands down, the rest not even close

few names i feel should not included in the list

benayoun - injured most of the time, and still injured
jovanovic - couldnt adapt to EPL?


This post has been edited by uNeVErwaLkaloNe: Nov 12 2010, 06:24 PM

Vdv the best for me. Scoring in every games he has started

i will go for konchesky

If the best transfer is not judge solely by the number of goals scored or assists
Then surely Cheick Tiote from Newcastle at £3.5m is a much better purchase than £8m VDV (Yes i'm being bias here)
Look at where Newcastle is at the moment compared with Spurs

---

Added on November 12, 2010, 6:49 pm

This post has been edited by arcaloveher: Nov 12 2010, 06:49 PM

that's great and all but the only way you can do that if you watched all or most the BPL matches. if not, people will just go on for the player in their team (since they watch all their team match) or just go via the goals/assists stats

i voted for Marouane anyway

Milos Krasic to juve....
And For EPL Chamakh to arsenal

i was torn apart between chamakh and vdv.these two has brought much impact to their team.without chamakh,arsenal will be headless like last season when we lost both rvp and bendtner.without vdv,tottenham will have even more struggle to cope with CL and EPL.

Chicharito...i sense the arrival of another Ruud in the making

(only the goal is a better sight to see than Ruud's)


but Javier Hernandez is good too.vote to him

This post has been edited by ayanami_tard: Nov 12 2010, 07:34 PM

VDV definitely although my vote went to Little Pea~


Made a great impact and gave Spurs a new dimension in attacking

another one:Kagawa Shinji

for 3 weeks of Roo's paycheck one can have another Fabregas in the making....

but it is bundesliga though(bundesliga and la liga is always behind BPL in term of difficulties)

to me, if is individually I think Little Pea "Chicharito" will win my vote but if is make an impact for the team then I will vote for VDV.

+1
VDV kicks others ass upside down at the moment...

as a NUFC fan...i vote for Tiote!

other than that maybe VDV,Javier or Chamakh.

VDV, with Chamakh separated by a thread only.

as suggested by the pole result
1. vdv
2. chamakh

how about bebe?

This post has been edited by ayanami_tard: Nov 12 2010, 10:14 PM

Most impact? VDV for sure! No doubt about that

vdv hands down

VDV just friggin pawn everyone in the list. Instant impact I'd say and still have until now. BEST 8million pound ever spent.

This post has been edited by Belphegor: Nov 12 2010, 11:15 PM

Surprised someone voted for Yossi...Chuckled when I saw that

to be honest, the Man City newcomers didn't really provide a huge impact to the squad. it's always Captain Tevez stealing the show instead of them.

Yaya Toure seems a good buy. I like him more than Barry, and he's tough as a rock.

Problem for City is that they need a creative midfielder, not more defensive midfielders

im confused liao..chicarito and javier hernandez not the same person meh?

no ..chicarito just nickname....same person

This post has been edited by THE ZUL: Nov 13 2010, 02:04 AM

you potong btol la

i am an Arsenal fan, i hate Spurs, to hell with VDV
so its Chamakh



This post has been edited by Quick`: Nov 13 2010, 04:59 AM

Bebe is too far out of the league to first be compared with.

VDV - is quite good

D.silva - is not bad

chamakh - got a few goals/assist/penalties

undecided.....

VDV......

clearly VDV at the moment...

Milos Krasic (CSKA to Juventus)

Zlatan Ibrahimovie (Barcelona to AC Milan)

Hernanes (Sao Paolo to Lazio)

Alberto Aquilani (Liverpool to Juventus)

but from the poll i would vote for Rafael VdV... Clearly a revelation for Spurs

Voted :
VDV - Real Madrid to Spurs

Others :

Nor Shahrul Idlan Talaha - UPB MyTeam - Kelantan FA

From a struglling and now defunct football club to Malaysia Cup winner earning Best Striker and Most Valuable Player Award in the process. Quickly turning into national football icon in one year. What a year it have been to the lad.

In terms of price, Chamakh ahead of VDV....

In terms of contribution, VDV ahead of Chamakh

ya, won the least impact award

sorry, hernandez doesn't give massive impact to man united team ...

for man united this season so far the player that give the most impact is Nani.

Do not really agree, in terms of contribution, both players gave their very own type of it. Both had the same amount of goal scored (though VDV goal per game ration is higher). But of course you can't judge only on goal score... VDV control the midfield quite well as he is able to march forward the team to opponent's half and orchestrate the attack at times, gave assist and also score some box to box and middle range goal.

Chamakh had his very own aerial accuracy type of damage which will fear opponents in set pieces such as middle range free kick and corner kick, this in turns contributed when opponents have to give exclusive attention to him and loosing some attention to the former's team mate. Also, Not to mention that he won numbers of penalty more than any other strikers in the penalty won per game ration although this is still debatable.

in terms of price....Res Ipsa Loquitur.

Real madrid throw away all their useful players....all the time



first makelele, then robben, then snjeider (my fail spelling), huntelaar, metzelder..

now its van der vaarts turn.

well,most of the ppl vote for vdv jst see the goal ratio..they forget spurs still got bale who contribute most..
enough said for me.without chamakh arsenal still struggling.

real never wanted to sell makelele but this guy want more money ... thats why he went to chelsea ...

for robben and snjeider, both of the position now occupy by ronaldo and ozil ... which play so well now

huntelaar and metzelder simply not good enough for real ...

It is true that Gareth Bale contribute alot of Tottenham. But this is not one man's team, without a finisher, even how good Gareth Bale is, Tottenham is still unable to score.

If you see Tottenham match everytime you will find out that Van der Vaat is keep roaming and dominate the centre field and gareth bale keep attacking from the left. Each has his own responsibilities to deal with. Especially right now you can see that Tottenham striker is not at a good mood at the moment. Van der Vaat is trully a great player, there is no doubt about it. You wont expect midfielder can keep scoring other than Malouda or Nolan. If you think that van der vaat is not worth it as good bargain transfer in EPL. Who will it be? Somemore he's just join in at 8mil transfer fee which is no one would expect that cheap from him

This post has been edited by Jet23sky: Nov 18 2010, 10:55 AM

ah yes, Milos Krasic too. when transferred to Juve, gave quite a huge impact ever since Nedved retired.

no la, since VDV came, he's the one banging in the goals wat, and shows that how much of an impact he's done. of course Bale is there to contribute, but VDV is there to score.
well, we ARE talking about which transfer gave most impact to team.

dude, read the title again

---

Added on November 18, 2010, 5:32 pmdude, obvioulsy the poll are for EPL.

This post has been edited by BoltonMan: Nov 18 2010, 05:32 PM