Which trasnfer gave the greatest impact to their team? Discuss.

This post has been edited by liez: Nov 12 2010, 04:35 PM

Surprised Yossi is there on the list

Voted for Vdv

This post has been edited by SGSuser: Nov 12 2010, 04:37 PM

i go for chamakh... he just awesome..

---

Added on November 12, 2010, 4:38 pmi go for chamakh... he just awesome..

This post has been edited by ReBeLLioN: Nov 12 2010, 04:38 PM

VDV by heads above the rest. Nuff said.

only epl teams?

This post has been edited by Envoy: Nov 12 2010, 04:41 PM

yes choose VDV ...

chamakh still doesn't score consistent enough ... j.cole play normal only ... benayoun no need say ...

yaya the biggest flop consider his salary is 220k.

quite obvious who has the biggest impact. Chamakh for Arsenal is still normal. Just someone to replace Van Persie for the time being? I think they should have just used any of their subs cause they're good.

the list will be too long and the comparison will be too vast and sometimes might get off the line since every league differs. Fro example: Suarez's stats is much more power than Messi doesn't mean he is gonna achieve same feat in Liga BBVA. Nevertheless, one can discuss and compare it too. I just didn't feel like listing everyone in the poll so I put an option of 'others' in it.

Chamakh. Imagine if Chamakh didn't join Arsenal, and Robin van Persie, Bendtner, Walcott are (and they were) injured...

chamakh of course.
got him for free.
and he's been scoring a lot of crucial goals.
a few assists here and there.
and the number of penalties he won for arsenal.

Based on the money involved.... Chamakh

There there, there's no need to say who's the flop coz TS din ask for that, try to prevent good-thread-turn-bad

Voted for VDV Meireles also quite good for Liverpool ma

TS mention most impact, not most bargain buy..

VDV win hands down, the rest not even close

few names i feel should not included in the list

benayoun - injured most of the time, and still injured
jovanovic - couldnt adapt to EPL?


This post has been edited by uNeVErwaLkaloNe: Nov 12 2010, 06:24 PM

Vdv the best for me. Scoring in every games he has started

i will go for konchesky

If the best transfer is not judge solely by the number of goals scored or assists
Then surely Cheick Tiote from Newcastle at £3.5m is a much better purchase than £8m VDV (Yes i'm being bias here)
Look at where Newcastle is at the moment compared with Spurs

---

Added on November 12, 2010, 6:49 pm

This post has been edited by arcaloveher: Nov 12 2010, 06:49 PM

that's great and all but the only way you can do that if you watched all or most the BPL matches. if not, people will just go on for the player in their team (since they watch all their team match) or just go via the goals/assists stats

i voted for Marouane anyway

Milos Krasic to juve....
And For EPL Chamakh to arsenal

i was torn apart between chamakh and vdv.these two has brought much impact to their team.without chamakh,arsenal will be headless like last season when we lost both rvp and bendtner.without vdv,tottenham will have even more struggle to cope with CL and EPL.