the thing is,how would you monitor 'girls only can reply'?u can change the sex profile anytime ler 
in b4 this is my 1st time posting here liao.so dun flame me 

i know but they need to check every single one that posted here on /k/
how long that would take?

haha if it's okay with the mods then i suppork u la 

hurm but they can cr8 a dupe acc and put it as female tag
u can see a lot in /k/

support. i will help to report to mods any cross gender poster in girls only thread

Hmm... if you ignore them by not replying, I don't think it will cause into any 'keyboard war'.

And if you notice something, not all forumers disclose their gender here. There are some without gender tag.

I'm not helping the guys... It's just that I don't think it's really necessary.

Easy to identify a guy or girl reply?
Found this quite funny
As long as we experience in plying with forum, we can mimic any gender style of replying.
Thus, any crap will appear anyway.

In forum, i suggest u to learn to filter replies instead.
There are always crapping replies, just like u cannot stop people from talking by using any rules or laws.

Furthermore, the bad thing of this thing is,
all replies will based on one gender sided perspective, which is what u want.
However, consider a case where girls deal with problems of bf, can receive advice from both gender.
Provided the worst case where female keep shooting the guys based on how bad the TS describe, most probably that relationship wont survive.

Good or bad, thats up to u how u filter the message.

To think on the moderator perspective,
i dont see the use of this idea.
Like somebody say, u can always ignore people.

just accept the fact that males are everywhere.

hey...dis is sexist.....
oh well, guess i'll change my tag to female tag....

---

Added on October 30, 2010, 5:19 pm
if a thread is wit only female reply, it will b a 1 sided guy bashing thread.

sarahFaizal: its quite obvious most of the girls aren't around here anymore. even the female mods aren't around. that says a lot about this section. this board description says "Guys stay OUT" but it seem to be opposite.

http://forum.applemint.com/

based on your past posts, you are obviously a guy. if this rule is enforced, this kind of post would be reported. it's not 100% accurate but is workable. people that have female tags can still be reported.

guys, maybe this will help train you guys to think and act like a girl if you want to create dup to post here. so both side will benefit. later the girls club will be all guys pretending to be girls. 

ya.. maybe i'm on my period and i want to discuss about it with other girls only, ok?

i don't mind supporting, but i can tell you it's gonna be a lost cause.
rather than trying to be a hero(ine),
why not fight other serious issues like scams and frauds?
even those serious issues are hard to control, what more silly stuffs like this?
the best thing is, just ignore the male comments, or go to another girl forum.
you tak suka you keluar.
oh btw, why are you not out in the club during that time?

what rules? female tag rules? , coming from u that sound ridiculously idiot, i mean how do u exactly know someone is male or female on the internet anyway? id requirement for registration?  , u need to make a photocopy of your id then email it to the admin just so u can open an account here?    ..do me a huge favor, u female should do what u do best, go to kitchen and make sandwich, at least its more productive, 

Congrats. This statement of urs have managed to show that you're definitely not from the civilized part of the world, or have never received any proper education before    go back to zaman batu yo.

Just a girl club, not Girl forum
check you dictionary properly please.

I dont need to be owner to actually speak up the point I see from a petty chicks like you.
What bullshit?

1. I dont see the issue you started workable.
2. Your option of female tags are on forum-er to set their gender. You can set your female tags, or male tags or not to put your gender tags & people don't trust till they know you.
3. Your solution is NOT WORKABLE BUT MORE OF POLICE-ING who are male or female.
4. politic & bullshit are always with Malaysia culture. If you dont like can just tape yourself with tapes available from 7/11.
5. I dont really see you as main user in GC either. You are more in Kopitiam. See yourself in the mirror before speaking up you are in GC.
6. There is no thinking high, but from what I read validity of yours, you are trying to make yourself someone in here.   Makcik, better go Stuff For Ladies & sell your undies & bras.

Omg OMg Butthurtzzz so pain ful   Ouch!~~

snap what out of topic?
there`s no ego to play here. Its more of your immature ability to think further thats all I can say.
/k/ is as usual, K.. just read your topic.. what shit you got? trolled on?

your daily k isnt good enuf mak cik!
get on with your hubby & get a baby please.

Hate me as you like, haunt me as you like..but if a girl with a good mind who know How to read statements & make opinion out of it, i`m not sure your valid topic is there.

Just do understand, your participation is in Kopitiam, please go back there. or better still keep mouth shut & go make babies with your hubby.

---

Added on November 1, 2010, 11:46 am

Mak cik, please divert your reply to obi wan kenobi, `im not him either.

Good you have such good hubby, but sorry to say your topic has no relevant to what OP had started argued about.
Again, I hav no issue with female either ways. Its just this female in particularly(sarahfaizal)  here have problem of sticking a stick to her head.

thats all I got to say. No idea why small thing she cant reason out why? but only know how to make big hoo ha.

are you trying to mummy me over too?
from my view, i think its really OT, she got no spine either.

& please, parables not valid here. I think someone just making it personal issues like you.

If you want to mummy, please go on obiwan kenobi.

& that painful, is just a hype of situation.. nothing more to make TS felt like I was hurtz.
Good Kampung, atleast someone come up with sensible talk rather talk only, no details.

Allow me to share my opinion on this issue.

I am sympathetic towards the plight of female forumers here. Their concerns are legitimate. However, i also question the proposal, especially the effectiveness of this proposal of having "tag" of female replies only thread.

It may only solve part of the problem. Gender tag can be changed. Some people do not have gender tag too. The proposal will only heighten the scrutiny of gender tag which i think is superficial. The very basis of TS and the proponents to have this proposal is to prevent..

Example of view from this thread:
The TS basis is to prevent unnecessary reply on the GC board. Hence, i believe that people should look at the problem and solving it, not a short-term solution which may cause implications such as judging people........."purely" on gender tag. What they decide on gender tag, is personal issue, but we need to look at more important thing such as the quality of the post.

Solutions?

1. Get one more moderator who is active in GC.

- Moderators, i believe they are humans too. They have real world life that they need to tend to.

2. Change the guidelines (Rules and Regulations) for posting such as people who post sexist comments might be held liable.

Introducing tags will not work, what is needed is the participation of forummers, such as girls to report any comments such as sexist ones....and they need to be educated on what is not acceptable or sexist, or something which do not contribute in answering the problem of any TS who start threads here.

Judging people based on gender tag is unfair, i suggest look at the weight and quality of posting instead.

Conclusion : Tag introduction will not work. Participation from "stakeholders" (especially girls who participate in this board) is important and also look at the quality of the comments instead of gender tag alone.

even though v r guys & dis is girls's club, there is no rule against guy not allow to reply on an existing thread.
also, v giving opinion, not spamming.

Wow! 12hours and all that happened! I missed out all the fun!

You girls know what? We should snap out of it and stop replying to those opposing to the idea, and yet have nothing to contribute. They do nothing but aggravate and damn, they're abrasive! 

And why are we letting men dictate what GIRL's Club should be? It's for girls, and it's a club. The exclusivity of a club simply evades idiots.

If girls wanna talk about their 'pettiness' (as quoted by negativity), then why let it be questioned? Don't like it, don't join the discussion! If the men don't like it, GTFO. You don't see many men in female forums, that cos they don't like, they GTFO. So if men in lyn don't like Girl's Club, GTFO!

I saw it and i do agree that it happens.

That is why i suggest, tweaking some rules and regulations.

At the same time, the power is more on girls to report any breaches.

When there is action being taken, naturally, it may help to reduce future breaches.

is this kind of post still not violating R&R in LYN? Sounds like a direct challenge to the moderating team as well.

Moderators, are like us. They need to tend real life activities as well.
I noted the situation.

That is why a combination of...

Active moderator + active observation and participation (also scrutiny) from girls = big difference

Not foolproof (due to the context), but it will help to reduce replies that can be deemed not constructive.

If Moderators in Girl forum do really pay attentions to this Girls Club, i`m sure they will do their work removing those topics that are like..
what...