Easy to identify a guy or girl reply?
Found this quite funny
As long as we experience in plying with forum, we can mimic any gender style of replying.
Thus, any crap will appear anyway.

In forum, i suggest u to learn to filter replies instead.
There are always crapping replies, just like u cannot stop people from talking by using any rules or laws.

Furthermore, the bad thing of this thing is,
all replies will based on one gender sided perspective, which is what u want.
However, consider a case where girls deal with problems of bf, can receive advice from both gender.
Provided the worst case where female keep shooting the guys based on how bad the TS describe, most probably that relationship wont survive.

Good or bad, thats up to u how u filter the message.

To think on the moderator perspective,
i dont see the use of this idea.
Like somebody say, u can always ignore people.

Many guys talking here....
hope to see some gals' replies now.

Anyway, to think in the moderator perspective:

1) Who so free to 'stalk' and check the reply style of particular member? Its not like mod are paid to do so, or they have too much time to spare without their own life to live with.

2) Provided that it is really working to identify guy pretending to be gal. Can u ensure mod wont banned gal reply in guy style accidentlly?

3) In developer perspective, u think so easy to go into the HTML of the forum to add one extra tag and set functionality rules to disallow guys to reply? To banned member with guys tag is okay. To manually banned them, refer to the first point.

4) If this idea is really approve in the end, i would request for another thread only for guys. Otherwise, sexism issues confirmed will occur and extra problems + headache for LYN. While adding anothet thread for guys also created problems, consider girls thread got one "The bad things about guys" and guys thread got "The bad things about girls". In the end, to begin with this idea is problems + problems + problems...... need further thinking?

So, i still suggest gals who wan to go with this idea, do:

Go inside the room and invite girls only to talk about the girly subjects.
When people of opposite gender enter the room, try to ask him out.
While if he dont, ignore his existence and whatever he say.
In the end, the girly subjects still goes on and the extra comments will not affect anything.
Win for the gals.

Eh....
body shaping really not so important for me.....unless u are talking about extreme out-of-shape
And i never care bout body building also.

Steoreotyping is an absolute bad fallacy.

Actually, my main point wasn't simply to say that im not interested in that,
me as an ordinary guy dont interest in those thing,
eseentially there are many other out thr who dont interested like me.
Just like not all guys love plying dota and watching football.

This is just my opinion to avoid generalization here.

So..... what bout the rule for girly tag?
Under construction?