Hi,
I'm using the Clinique Moisture Surge for years and it works fine for me.
The only thing is that my skin is not prone to breakout but I am sure that it's suitable for all skin types especially if you need hydration.
I can't comment on the Biotherm one as I have not use it.
I had recommended the Moisture Surge to my family and friends and all are satisfied with it. Not a complain yet.
I strongly recommend it and hope that you get the result you wanted if you decided to go for it.