First of all, thanks alot to the seller for her prompt and courteous reply . As for the product, I totally LOVE it! Been searching high and low for eyeliner which doesn't smudge on oily eyelid after few hours of application. I was abit skeptical at first but decided to give this a try. Put it on this morning, hoping that it won't disappoint me. By noon, check out my eyes and boy I was impressed. By evening, no smudges seen! The liner just stays there! Only one word to describe this pencil eyeliner. GREAT product !