Hi Gals,

Im looking for a black gel liner...
Beacuse i have oily eyes.... will smudge easily....

Thanks for your suggestion!!!

Stay Pretty !

Try Kate's eyeliner. Its waterproof so dont have to worry about smudging. Price is reasonable also.

will it dry easily??
i bought etude house gel eyeliner... i hardly pick it up to the brush!!

Elf Gel liner also quite good.. u can try it..

a more reasonable price is maybelline's gel liner. i have oily lids too and it doesn't smudge on me at all ^^

i never use elf product.... will getting soon from sgdrugstore... hehe...
thanks for the recommendation....
stay pretty ... love ya!!

---

Added on September 15, 2010, 11:50 pmoh... really!! happy that its work on you..... maybelline more easy to get in Malaysia.....
thanks ya!!!
stay pretty!!! keep in touch!!

This post has been edited by ~butterflyznie~: Sep 15 2010, 11:50 PM

The eye liner is liquid ones .. my sisters are using it ..

i bought that one was in pot with pink lid.....

Try Shu Uemura Liquid Eyeliner , RM 95, it is proven for me as I have oily eyelids . Can last all day long without smudging.
Precise and easy application too and you can buy refill.

http://www.shuuemura.com.my/index_flash.htm
Go - Products - Makeup - Eyes - click the 4th picture ( which is a black pen with white brush)

This post has been edited by hoopsyoyo: Sep 20 2010, 12:32 PM

maybelline or loreal for sure

i've used elianto black liquid eyeliner before. the one with some shimmer. it's not very sparkling actually. and it's waterproof.

that one i wear to swim, bath, and put on for the whole day also won't smudge or come off. cost about rm20 or so i think.

Kate's ! So far is the best as I know.

thanks for the link!!!! really helps!!
stay pretty gal!

I have the Kate one and Bloop de paris (jusco & sunway pyramid). I find the kate colour not so intense, whilst it doesnt smudge sometimes it might fade a lot after a few hours. I use this when I want a more natural 'light makeup' look. The bloop black is more stronger and intense, and the colour stays longer. I only use for night-time stronger look.

Both i keep for one year already still can use, a little dryer but no problems.

will try it on when watsons got sale on it!!! yeah!!
thanks...
stay pretty!

---

Added on September 25, 2010, 3:42 pmBloop de paris? i never use this brand....
is the the packaging of this product were pretty cute ?? hehe.... thanks....

This post has been edited by ~butterflyznie~: Sep 25 2010, 03:42 PM

my fav is majolica eyeliner, the color wont smudge and love the packaging

majolica majorca does carry eyeliner in pen and pencil type only right???
ehhe..!!! sounds good!

This is their website -->ClickHere
I think they are a Malaysian brand, I heard about the product when searching for info on gel liners.
Their website kinda useless, I think they are sold in some Jusco's and have a store in Sunway Pyramid (directly downstairs from The Body Shop, in the 'middle' of walkway). I recall the price around RM45 with brush. Got lots of other cutely packaged cosmetic stuff, the store look a bit like selling candy and cakes.

I may do a blog review of the Kate and Bloop gel liners in the future if anyone's interested?

my friend just brought me a dolly wink liquid liner .
once i tried and i fall for it.
the brush is comfortable and easy to control plus i did a rub test on it and it did not budge.

hi...
compare dolly wink and majolica moajorca....

all of the colour of gel liner (Majolica majorca) is iz got shimmer on it ????

thank....

yes. some of the color have shimmer.
if u wan to try out black color becareful when u purchase because they have black pearl and pure black.
still love mj because is cheaper

Cyber Colours (RM39.90) larrr... or KATE (RM49.90)... but Cyber Colours is the best.... Cheap, no smudge, deep colours... I'm not joking bout this either...

u can try koji eye liner pen, gel liner still not good for oily skin..

my fav will definitely be bobbi brown's gel eyeliner.

if you want a cheaper one you can try maybelline gel eye liner too.

I love gel eyeliner that is really black!

Do you have the Koji pen one? Is that the long lasting one, i've seen adds for that and wondered how good is it.
Do you know if it has 'brush' like tip or marker pen tip?

ya.. much more long lasting than gel as i have tried many type of eye liners.
It is just a pen and can draw out very fine line..

MAC has the best gel liner. Always sold out

hi, just sharing. as 2 prevent eye liner frm smudging, can apply eyeshadow on top. as 4 those that r worried about gel liner frm drying, can try cream type 1. sasatinie has them. havent try b4, but frm the tester, the eye liner seems like creamy or like powder. 1 more thing, after taking the gel liner frm the bottle, remember 2 close the lid or invert the bottle as this can prevent drying. i try kate gel liner b4, BK01. i like it n 2 me, it is black enough. hope this helps.

bobbi brown gel liner is good... i heard maybelline's good too!

I like MAC fluidline, but best is Bobbi Brown, although the latter dries a lot faster than MAC.

Where can I get non-waterproof gel eyeliner?

I just bought Kate's. It's good. I use it for casual outings. The color is not that intense.

try priming your eyes? it helps to reduce your shadows from creasing.. Cause im sure eyeliner is not you only product that you use on yout lids:)

yes!!! thanks for your advice.....
using eye primer from etude house will help unsmudge crease for almost 8am to 6pm... hehe.....

indeed.. I love Bobbi Brown gel liner.. It did a great job.. It last for the whole day... so far i still love it the max...

hm... i used Bobbi Brown before but gosh...it smudged teruk teruk
Now I've changed to Shu. Still smudge but lesser. Still i think liquid works the best but gel liner easier & faster to apply... Got any product combi benefit from Gel & liquid eyeliner ma~??? i will rush to buy de...

MAC Gel eyeliner is the best among the best !
My friend study at make up academy , they all used this brand one..

Do you try bobby brown?

I'm using Maybelline's Gel Liner, although I'm going to switch back to liquid liner or pencil liner because I'm lazy to wash the brush.

i jus wondering ..waterproof means no smudging? as far as i know, eyeliner smudges because of oil, not water.

Try Wet and Wild Gel Liner. I always use it.

is there pencil liner which doesnt smudge? Prefer drugstore brand.

i'm using MAC gel liner now...long lasting without smudge

If u have extra money to splurge:
-->Bobbi brown Gel Eyeliner


If u r on tight budget:
-->Maybelline studio Gel eyeliner


Both are superb and serve their purpose!

It all boils down to yr preferrence (and yr wallet)

what about silky girl gel liner.i'm very new to applying make-up n my hands are very shaky,which gel liner should i use?

Bobbi Brown's one FTW ! If you have oily lids, this is the longest lasting one!

Any oil proof liner?

Babe, I'm using Maybelline Gel Eyeliner too and it's the best! Cheap, good, long-lasting and damn waterproof. For priming, Elf Eyeshadow Primer is a must for me so that it can last longer.

This post has been edited by Vanillababy: Dec 27 2011, 03:24 AM

haha! maybelline gel liner smudged on me. it actually depends on individual.. it mght work on someone but not to another. i have oily lids btw and maybelline gel liner always got transferred to my lower lid. sigh.

i think i prefer liquid liner. been using deja vu liquid liner.. so far so good.. not the best but better than maybelline gel liner.

many ppl said bobbi brown gel liner is the best; however some ppl have said it smudged on them terribly.. hence again, one product work great for one doesn't mean it will work as well as to the other.

happy experimenting!

---

Added on December 30, 2011, 3:51 pmmajolica is not gel liner though. it's liquid liner and yes it has light shimmer.

This post has been edited by oatkrunch: Dec 30 2011, 03:51 PM