I've been using my Solo for the better part of the year, and all I have is discoloration on the white band, mostly due to wear. The hinges works as well as it should, the sound gets better and better as it ages, and the comfort and audio seal is as good as I took out of the box a year ago.
I never had a problem with cracked edges, or broken hinges, and I don't baby this thing, I use it while on the plane, on the move, everywhere I go. Maybe my head isn't big enough to force the pads into breaking, nor is my hair is fashioned after some spiky hairdos that would scratch the top section. I wear this most of the time over my cap while I'm on the move, so it does have a smooth surface to rest on. Only when I'm listening on the plane on the MBA/iPhone/iPad that it rests over my hair.
I've come to appreciate the passive noise-isolation method the Beats headphone employs over the negative noise-cancellation used by the Bose QC3 I have, since with passive noise-cancellation, it doesn't introduce that uncomfortable feeling of "overstuffing" your ears with the "anti-noise" soundwave to cancel out ambient noise from the outside. Also with the Beats, compared to the Bose, I don't have to rely on the need to power it up since it doesn't require any power. The earpads are super-comfortable as well.
I was thinking of getting the B&W P5 as well. Now with the Beats Solo HD purchase already made via Amazon, I hope I'm happy enough with it, and NOT stumble upon the P5 when I'm in LA later, and forces another purchase.

Same pricepoint for both the P5 and Beats Solo HD.
This post has been edited by stringfellow: Jul 7 2010, 04:14 AM