QUOTE(beavis68 @ Jul 7 2010, 08:58 AM)
i think your opinion is back to square one. if you do enough research, the yellowish screen is due to the glue not properly dried. this is not due to hardware problem. how they going to improved it? dun use glue? they will still use the glue on the screen maybe this time apple will let it dried properly before they send out to their customer.
calculation on signal bar is due to software problem, in future u might get an iphone which already updated to their new software to rectify this issue. but then this is also a software problem and nothing is done on hardware. still the first batch get the software update as the same as 2nd batch iphone. unless u say they totally changed their antenna hardware, then it can consider 2nd batch is better, that will net be likely going to happen.
so 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th batch basically is all the same. i stated 20th batch it a just a sarcasm.
I don't think I am back to square one, is that you are missing the point. Yeah I know it is due to the glue problem that is why I said a manufacturing/assembly problem. They may improve it by using another type of glue, there are so many types of glue and no glue as you said is also possible. Or maybe let it dry longer I agree with you. Hence they are doing this to improve further quality of the 2nd and so on batch of iphones.
I just want to point out to you that there are differences with the 1st batch and 2nd batch it does not necessary be a whole revamp ie. antenna design revamp, it can be minor changes along the line to reduce a defect occurrence hence lesser warranty claims lesser fuss .
So there is a difference between 1st and 2nd batch, for you I guess the improvement is not sufficient.
Added on July 7, 2010, 11:06 amQUOTE(xaw5126 @ Jul 7 2010, 10:33 AM)
you know... for all the bleating & complaining I keep hearing... my response has always been the same.
1. there is no better phone on the market. NONE!
2. I will personally share with anyone who wants to learn about iPhone3G or 3G[S] or iPhone4 ... everything I know about it.
3. Even if the reports are all true, there is still no better phone on the market right now, and I have no faith that Samsung / RIM / HTC can actually engineer a better phone. They simply don't understand that it *must* be made simple enough that an 8-year old can pick it up and start using it, before the mass-market consumer types will buy it.
4. If the reported issues are really scaring you away from the best phone in the market right now, then
get out of the way, we want one!
Wow even engadget do not dare to say that "there is a no better phone on the market. NONE!" or "there is still no better phone on the market right now" when comparing the iphone 4 with the HTC Evo.
However I will stick to Engadget review between the phones rather than yours which is more professional.
Quoted from endgadget:
Hoo boy. This is a tough one, isn't it? In our years at Engadget, we've rarely seen such deafening debate and adulation for a pair of devices. In one corner we have the iPhone 4, coming off a few relatively easy rounds atop the smartphone mind share heap. However, the Droid and its ilk have weakened Apple's spot, and here comes the HTC EVO 4G in for the kill, sporting a larger screen, 4G data, and all manner of HTC sexy. If the devices themselves weren't enough, the debate has turned into something larger and metaphorical, with Apple representing tight restrictions and a singular top down vision, while Google's Android stands for something perhaps a bit more haphazard but democratizing. The gloves come off after the break.
Of course, the easy answer is that they're both great phones. The truth of the matter is that what might make the EVO the perfect smartphone for one person doesn't necessarily pop up on another person's radar. In many cases (like this author's, for instance), there are many pros and cons on both platforms and devices that makes the decision difficult, almost painful. We're going to try to lay out the facts, so that you have the best material at your disposal for making the decisions,
but we're not going to call the decision "easy" or "cut and dry" for anybody. This is a road we all eventually walk alone... into an Apple or Sprint store.
Wrap Up:
You know the facts, you've heard the arguments, you've passively observed the roar of comments from each side... now follow your heart! ( I don't read a "no better phone on the market.NONE!")
This post has been edited by ck_yoong: Jul 7 2010, 11:08 AM