Im not sure if i can get what u trying to say, but base on my understanding about what u talking on the first thread i think u actually miss the "believe by reasoning" part, what i can see is using feeling to determine whether u believe it or not

Happiness, sadness, love, all this we describe in words can be "feel" through our emotion and we usually use it to express how we feel or what is our current emotions are, we dont need much reason to say it is real or not because thats how we feel.
For god and other unexplanable feeling, at least so far there is no any explanation on how god feels like, how do we actually know that that "feeling" is call god by not others?
In my opinion, feeling can be manipulate. One good example is how many people especially teenagers think that someone or the one he/she like has the same feeling as them.
Same thing can happen when someone say that when something bad happen they heard a "voice" that telling them what to do. That "voice" most probably caused by their own conscience if we view it in a scientific way where we tell themself what is right and wrong when dealing with the reality where we exist.
But it can be vary due to what a person believe. They can treat a good message from that voice (produce from own conscience) as a voice from god telling or advice them what to do, or treat a bad message as a devil speaking to them.

In the end, at least for me, god is not to feel.
Feel can easily mislead us to all types of situation, especially when our mind is close enough to believe that all unexplanable events is related to what we wan to believe