Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 Lecturer's salary and prospects in Malaysia

views
     
firstamongequal
post Apr 24 2010, 11:29 AM

New Member
*
Newbie
2 posts

Joined: Apr 2010


QUOTE(futuristicwiz @ Apr 24 2010, 11:16 AM)
ISI journals are NOT the yardstick to justify the quality of the journal. My question is HOW many of those ISI publications are from the Premium and Leading???

http://www.comp.nus.edu.sg/~wang06/SoC%20J...l%20Ranking.htm

Publishing ONE journal article in Premium or Leading category takes MANY stages of reviews, at least 2 stages based on my experience. Therefore, it takes MORE THAN ONE YEAR to publish a journal article most of the times. Now, based on your attached document,

Professor Ng Seik Weing published 185 ISI journals in one year alone. This is IMPOSSIBLE considering that the review cycle of the Premium and Leading is so long, unless the ISI journals are of poor quality. Think logically, and you'll understand my points.

futuristicwiz
*
WTF, first, you guys say Malaysian universities do not consider ISI, then when UM's website shows lecturers publishing in ISI, you say it is poor quality etc. I think for you guys, you should just end the conversation by saying Malaysian universities sux, foreign countries better, malaysia is unfair due to NEP etc etc etc. Typical Malaysians, complain complain complain. If you guys claim that you have so many good things to offer to the country, do something? Yes yes, there is no chance for non bumi bla bla bla. If you want to contribute, just contribute. Don't think about money, opportunity etc.

I think the websites posted demostrated two things 1) Someone mentioned malaysian lecturers never show their CV and profile, then posted an NUS website link. So the UM website shows you that you are wrong, the CVs are available! 2) Malaysian universities don't really focus on ISI, again wrong, because the links show that they do. But please don't compare with universities in US, UK etc. Are you telling me that all universities in the UK, US , are good? How about East London University? How about those lowly ranked universities in the UK?

Someone showed the australian journal ranking ERA.. well, FYI, some of the ranked A journals are not ISI, while some ISI journals are not ranked well in ERA. Forget about ranking of journals. You mean whenever a lecturers want to publish, he has to look at the ranking?? Perhaps the journal's theme is suitable, is is a relatively good journal, good editorial board members, papers there are of good standard etc? What is the point of publishing in ISI journal when your paper is not cited at the end? What if someone publishes a paper in a non ISI journal but the paper is cited 1000 times?

Professor Ng Seik Weing published 185 ISI journals in one year alone. This is IMPOSSIBLE. How do you know? Did you check the journal ranking? Did it show that they are poorly ranked journals? Nothing is impossible.

firstamongequal
post Apr 24 2010, 12:09 PM

New Member
*
Newbie
2 posts

Joined: Apr 2010


QUOTE(futuristicwiz @ Apr 24 2010, 11:47 AM)
Fact is fact, nothing to complain. We are just telling fact. You don't like the fact, you should stop ranting.
You don't have the say to tell "Forget about ranking of journals" because the employers at overseas are looking at ranking! However you spin and explain about teh quality of your journal, lowly ranked is lowly ranked. No one is going to listen to your explanation.

I didn't defend my journal.  I am just giving an example.  You like Singapore a lot.  Look http://www.ntu.edu.sg/HSS/econ/research/jo...alRankings.aspx  Number of citations in important as well.. hence H-Index is also considered.
185 ISI journals is REAL IMPOSSIBLE. Don't fool people around alright? There is only one reason, that's he himself is the editor of the journal, and so he publish his own article in his own journal. Note that, such a journal is of POOR quality.

TOP tier journals publish about 15 articles from around the world per month, that's about 180 articles per year. how did he managed to published that 185 articles? BULLSHIT!

Show the proof that he publishes in his own journal or that the journals are poor quality.  If you are such an outstanding scholar, show that facts intead of just saying someone is bullshitting.  His field is in Chemistry, if you know the nature of chemistry research, you will know it is possbile, or you are too big headed to think that someone in Malaysian can publish so many ISI papers. If this guy is an American, you will say this guy is great.

There are tens of thousands or even more journals in the ISI Knowledge, it's FAIRLY easy to publish one. Each journal could be as short as 8 pages.

It does not take a PhD to understand simple thing you know? I'm MORE interested to know how many of those 185 journal articles are of Premium and Leading levels by Singapore standard.

Yes, CHECK and LET US KNOW instad of accusing this guy.  AND... SHOW US WHICH JOURNALS YOU PUBLISHEd IN? Use http://www.harzing.com/pop.htm and you can filter you name, and show us your H-Index.  If not, don't say how bad others are.  And where are you working now? NUS? NTU?
futuristicwiz
*
This post has been edited by firstamongequal: Apr 24 2010, 12:11 PM

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0289sec    1.08    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 18th December 2025 - 06:45 AM