Refer to title

For me,

Most Overrated: MW2 (although I find Uncharted 2 to be overrated too)
Most Underrated: Ghostbusters

Overrated: None, played too little game last year

Underrated: Death Smiles

Death Smiles?

Most Overrated: Uncharted 2
Most Underrated: Ghostbusters

most overrated : uncharted 2
most underrated : the saboteur ...

That's why I say underrated

ghostbuster really good meh?

Uncharted 2 not overrated leh.... Is a great game...
MW2 is overrated man... Dragon Age also quite overated

Uncharted 2 isn't as great as everyone makes it out to be.

Maybe its excellent technically, but the story leaves much to be desired.

Also, the Multiplayer didn't stick around for long

I wanna know why ppl vote uncharted 2 for overrated, can give the reason but please not bcoz u dun like like it or bcoz this game just won GOTY, Best PS3 game and best graphic game???

This post has been edited by nakata101: Jan 27 2010, 05:31 PM

off the top of my head:
inconsistent graphics(horrible snow,beautiful Nepal)
issue with the controls(O used to roll,stick to walls AND drop down from a ledge)
no real feeling of being in danger when it comes to climbing/jumping off cliffs, as things dont break until you actually jump.(most of the time,anyway)
no compass of any kind(more to multiplayer)

Its not that the graphics aren't good.

Everyone seems to think Uncharted 2 is the best thing since sliced bread, when it really isn't.

Tell me, is Uncharted 2's story really as fantastic as every review site said it was?

bioshock is overrated. although it is 2008 game...

Overrated: AC2
Reason: Lousy graphics and controls. WTF storyline.

Underrated: Dont know, normally buy 9/10 games only.

For me the story line are fuxxing epic, i m still remember my cousin n my other family members dun wan me stop the game when i reach the last part.... me ad playing 3 hour non-stop n they all eating snack n watching me playing the game let my hungry alone.

To each his own

Personally, I felt that Uncharted 2 was very predictable.

As soon as Elena and that annoying reporter guy showed up, it was pretty easy to guess how it would end up.

msg4!

i know my time machine is on!

left 4 dead 2 << sarcasm~

here coems the fanboys

overrate - fifa10
underrate: ghostbuster

overrated : mw2
underrated : mw2

i mean its the most overrated game of 2009 but underrated due to the fact that it was overrated and undershadowed by the overated which causes it to be underrated.

if u get waht i mean

kidna agree with some of u..ghostbusters deserves at least an 8.5 isntead of an 7.5 rating

Added!!!

lolz WE2010 always so anticipate by true football game lovers, so it won't classify as underrate game la

overthetoprated: Uncharted 2
underated: NGS2


real men play NGS2

real men don't need a game to feel like a real man

overrated: FF XIII (it's just FF on HD...anything new? and it's hyped for like...errr ever since the new gen console was born)
underrated: Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood (i kind of liked the old western style fps )

Overrated: FFXIII
Underrated: Demon's Souls

real men play Demons Souls.

One moment you said you hated DS as a popular game, next moment you say underrated.. hippokrit

real men are hipokrits

Overrated: MW2 (multiplayer is awesome but single story is meh)

Underrated: Saboteur. (I don't understand how this can get average review only. The only thing i hate is the clunkiness of the climbing)

overrated: Left 4 Dead 2

underrated: Borderlands

extremely overrated - MW2
underrated - none

[quote=gundamalpha,Jan 27 2010, 05:24 PM]
That's why I say underrated



[/quot



wow...not bad..niceeeeee

quote fail

But, indeed, it does look nice

This post has been edited by gnsumas: Feb 1 2010, 06:43 PM

2nd that

overrate - GTA4, fifa10, dragon age, star ocean,
underrate: magna carta,

Overrated: Dragon Age (same typical bioware storyline, more on the linear side)
Underrated: AC2 (i didn't play this till last week, guess the horrible memory from AC1 still scares me till then)

as for ppl voting for UC2 as overrated, well to me the story is epic. it pays homage to indiana jones and other great adventure movies.

the multiplayer is awesome. the technical advantage makes me wonder why can't more developers make games that's that good.

ah, too bad it's only for the x360.

Small developers have no choice since the 360 is cheaper to develop for and Sony isn't too friendly towards them..

NGS2 for PS3 not underated...i hate screen tearing on ps3 version...
But i love so much Ninja Gaiden game.. ...no plan for NGS3?

New patch fixed this issue but the prob still remains intact occasionally

most likely there will be NGS3, after saw the PS3 ver ending and upcoming DOA5

Ending got show sign of DOA5??? Damn... i dint finish the PS3 version ad sold it out, i only try out the goyang goyang papaya.

I finished the game, but not sure about got show sign of DOA5..
btw, i oso love goyang goyang papaya..