QUOTE(andrekua @ Oct 24 2009, 12:20 AM)
Thats why he said its not going to work.
Basically there are two category of card owners. One with money and one without. What they did will deter those with money who use card for convienient or to earn rebates. But that RM50 is nothing for someone looking for credit. This latter category of card owners are those who keep registering new cards to balance transfer to get out of blood sucking interest rate. This free up the credit in the first card and the spending continues. This cycle continue each and every time the card owner need fast cash and fast way out. So if you want to stop prudent spending, suspend all new cards or limit one card per person.
Yes, it won't stop the 2nd category of ppl. It however will stop the first category from falling into the trap of accumulating debt. Yes, such ppl initially subscribe to cards for convenience and rebates and benefits and what nots, but there are numerous of such ppl who fall into the trap of delaying payment.
Such ppl start out harmlessly claiming they just want convenience. Which at that point was all they needed. But since cards rewards more the more you spend, they start shifting all expenditure to the card. To top that up, they start spending more than usual because what they purchase in this month, they can worry about it with next month's income. Then something pops up next month, messes with their cashflow, and they realise they're paying ridiculous interest. So, they apply another card to balance transfer. And while they can't make purchases with the card with transferred balance, they could always apply another one, and then the vicious cycle repeats itself.
You're looking at it from 2 extremes, that ppl either spend wisely on cards or start off looking for credit. I'm saying that there're ppl who start of being the former, but gradually shift to the latter, and thus fall into the trap of accumulating debt. Once they're there, they get used to the luxurious lifestyle, that they don't want to stop.