i cant live without eye liners, so gonna list dwn those tat i've tried, i have single and oily eye lid

1. kate - like the glitter ones but very cakey, the particles tends to go into my eye and the thing i hate is it dries up too fast. Despite all the bad comments, it does comes with a quite good brush
2. maybeline - worth every single cents, smooth, long lasting even on my oily eye lids, only complaint too little colour to choose from
3. Elizabeth Arden - i got tis long time back, dual color (copper and dark brown) because i felt in love with the copper colour one> Too bad to say this is not a good product, smudges off even i was using it in a less humid weather country and the brush tat comes with it is a rubbish
4. MAC-havent try on myself yet, but from the look of it the colour is very intense, good for more dramatic eye makeup

BB, Loreal and clinique will b those in the q of my shopping list. Other than gel, i use powder, liquid and pencil eye liners too depending on the occasion, cant live without them

Urban Decay pencil liners ftw <3

shinryu, where can we get urban decay product here??

i am using it and i have oily lids. it doesn't smudge on me.. a friend of mine who is having much oilier lids than me and i tried on her, it doesn't smudge too. as long as you didn't use your fingers to scrub it, i think it will pretty much stay there. i use it to tight-line as well.. it didn't transfer or stain my lower lids.

super easy to remove and i am using cleansing oil

Hai.

Personally prefer Bobbi Brown also ,
but for the burget brand Maybeline is a good choice

My friends bought for me from UK. Does that count?

haha, count oso lah
i got from uk oso, i tot can get here in malaysia, i like their eye primer much better than MAC