Personally, I think it's not much of a point not buying a title just because it doesn't come with HD audio.

First off, how many of us actually have a receiver capable. A lot of people aren't early adopters and a lot of receivers aren't "there" yet (IMHO). Of course, we have the option of getting those Blu Ray with HTIB sets when they come out.

Secondly, how many of us can actually tell the difference between true HD and 'old school' Dolby Digital? Hearing a glass that breaks with that extra '2 clink' for that True HD and lossless sound just doesn't really sound that appealing (well.. to me, that is).

If the title doesn't come with True HD audio now, do you think they will release a version in the future with True HD audio? Somehow, I doubt it...

I think to a lot of folks, Blu Ray is all about 1080p (the PQ) more than True HD audio.

thundercat... hehe..

as you said, many of the 'elites' here have True HD audio capable receivers but not everyone has them.

aiman,
It really isn't just about preference. It's about one's capabilities. The question that's in most people's mind... can I afford that receiver? Is it really really worth forking out a few grand on at this moment? Speaking of which, how much would the cheapest True HD receiver cost? And I'm not talking about plugging in 6 analogue inputs for True HD Audio (argghh! I hate messy wires!! see attachment )

For me, (my personal take) is that I'm waiting for 7.1 to really be the standard in all BDs before I start forking out some serious cash for a serious setup.

yea, you are right... a lot of people can't tell the difference between lossless and lossy. Just like how a lot of people can't tell the difference between the bass drum and bass, etc. It's also that some people don't really bother with sound that much.. except when its really bad (like "cinema recorded bad") while others really don't see the point of forking out 5 grand just to hear the extra sound of a glass hitting the floor.

Not everyone can tell the difference between 128kbps and 320kbps MP3 songs.

For those interested, take the test... http://mp3ornot.com/


Attached thumbnail(s)

Why do people always think that another opinion is always an arguement?

Aiman, just so you know... I'm not arguing.

I already agreed with you that people can't tell the difference. I didn't say that it's wrong or stupid to only buy Blu Rays with True HD audio.

The test was for those interested in telling the difference. Not everyone is an elite in this field. For some, sound comes naturally, for others the ear needs to be trained to hear the difference. So, there is a point of discussing bitrates, equipment and cost.

The difference between lossy (MP3 format) and lossless is big but to a lot of the untrained ears, the difference between Dolby Digital and Dobly TrueHD isn't that big for some.. especially to those who hadn't really had the chance to compare both formats.

So, let's keep an open mind, shall we? No harm, right? Your (and other elite's) recommendations are always appreciated because you guys have been using TrueHD format for some time now. The latest tech would be better than previous tech. That's for sure... my view wasn't saying that TrueHD sucks or anything... it's merely some folks may not be able to afford it yet or may not want to adopt it yet. Yea... the choice is theirs to make.

And I did branch the topic out by asking how much would the cheapest True HD receiver cost. Why? Because I'm curious about the price difference. I bet for a mid range performer, it won't be much but I wouldn't know... not many AV shops here compared to back in KL to go survey.

---

Added on August 24, 2009, 10:51 amOh yea... a great way to share is.. perhaps, telling us what you hear (the difference) in a movie with TrueHD and Dolby Digital. Some sounds in certain scenes which we don't hear (on DD). That would be totally intriguing...

This post has been edited by azxel: Aug 24 2009, 10:51 AM

Nah, I'm not offended. Always enjoyed reading you guy's posts in here.. knowing what to buy and what not to buy as well as where to buy from!!

Speaking of Blu Rays... how many of you actually pre-order BDs? How many of you wait for it to come out first then purchase them when their prices drop back down...?

Gotcha pal... I spent over RM100+ for a Belkin Surge and I still think RM4 for wantan mee in PJ is way way overpriced (it's only RM2.50 here in Penang!)

went through it... and it further places itself on my TO BUY list!!

try watching the actual movie... that might change your mind

Troy (the BD version that's the 'special edition') was fantastic... I enjoyed it more than the theatrical version.

woot! my shipment has arrived.. suppose to arrive sometime in Sept but it was 'dilepaskan' on the 21 Aug and today I got in (MC yesterday) and its on my table!!

Amazon should put in some gift or discount e-vouchers... every month buy stuff sure pokai...

is it because Amazon US ships faster? I notice that my shipments seems to arrive 1-2 weeks earlier on Standard Shipment...

I think the distance from Amazon US is nearer to M'sia compared to Amazon UK...

Items shipped on August 11, 2009:
Delivery estimate: September 17, 2009

but arrived yesterday 24 August 2009.

Think yours should be arriving soon.

ppsst... sell to me 3rd hand after you done la.. RM40 plus postage?

oh man... that's tough luck.. My order was just slightly over RM400... always take care not to exceed RM500.

I think its because... Your order is already RM463.50, I guess your shipping should be just slightly below RM200 making it all way above RM500. even if you ship standard, it should be slightly below RM100... also kena tax...

USD42.99 is the DVD version bro..

BD is still at USD45.49

sigh... this is so cool... anyone here got this?


Attached thumbnail(s)

cool..! thanks for the recommendation.. was wondering whether to get this or not.

wow.. yesasia's anime blu rays sure are expensive..

Watchmen. Great adaptation IMHO. Humanising Heroes and Super Heroes.
The movie can get a bit slow for some but the ending totally rocked.

Anyone bought Celine Dion Live in Las Vegas? I hear it's really good...

good eh? I have the DVD version (got it from Speedy along with Simply Red an Il Divo) but yet to watch it, will try to get a hold of the BD and do some comparison!!

Checking out amazon, I think there's simply not enough concert BDs to get around with.. btw.. anyone watched Cirque De Soleil BD? Is it good? Thinkin of gettin it..

You will totally like Troy Director's Cut and its features!

so many days busy, now login and see deals you guys posted here, went to amazon to order and RM400 gone...

i hate you all..

oo.. coraline comes with 4 pairs of 3D glasses??

oh.. and its just put on glasses, select 3D version of the movie to play right? no other stuff needed?

This post has been edited by azxel: Sep 4 2009, 04:10 PM

let us know if the 3D is ok or not.. hear a lot of folks complaining about the 3D.

done.. posted.