Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Bump Topic Topic Closed RSS Feed

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

PC Audio Edifier Fan Club V2, where great sound comes to life =)

views
     
blurrystart
post Dec 27 2006, 01:32 AM

New Member
*
Junior Member
7 posts

Joined: Dec 2006
I have somthing unclear about these speakers. Pls help me !
in comparison :
---------
I/
--1/AL CS-21 -->109$
--2/Klipsch GMX A 2.1 (using now but i will sell it soon) -costed me 160$
--3/Edifier S 2.1(D or non D) ~115$ + shipping (~10-20$)
--4/AL MX 5021 --> 149$
Which one is the best ? (for the Performance and ratio Performance/Price )
---------

II/
Let's take AL ATP3 (the best price i may pick it up is 49$) as the base line for this little battle on speaker. (my friend's small but powerful speaker).
Have a see @ these speaker :

--1/ Logitech X-230--> 55$
--2/ Edifier M2300 --> 42$
--3/ Edifier M3300 -->42$
--4/ Edifier M3400 -->49$
--5/ Edifier M3310 --> 46$

Which one will outperform AL ATP3 ? (In clarity and bass reproduction - I care much about the clarity ). Which one has the best ratio Performance/Price ?

Regard,


blurrystart
post Dec 27 2006, 06:52 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
7 posts

Joined: Dec 2006
QUOTE(besaid @ Dec 27 2006, 02:58 AM)
for I/,i would not dare to say much as i myself did not really tried any of the above mentioned speakers...but from comments by fellow LYNs,i guess Klipsch GMX A 2.1 easily rule them all.if u want a change,i would recommend waiting for the Edifier S2.1 MKII,it really got everyone excited.downside is...its still awhile from being available in market...

Performance and ratio Performance/Price???i guess you should not mind so much bout it since you can afford a klipsch,the MKII price is something everybody is waiting but expect somethin 500-700 in malaysia,dont know bout your place...
(where are you from?USA rclxub.gif ???)

for II/...i do not want to comment on logitech as i also never tested in personally but for edifiers...go for M3300 if u want more bass while M3310 if you want something less bassy...both satelites are the same.any M3XXX beats ATP3 easily.M2300 lacks tweeter,so forget bout it.give E3100 a try also if bass is not your priority.the clarity is GOOD thumbup.gif  thumbup.gif
*
Thx for your nice reply ..but i got the completely advice from my friends hmm.gif They told me that AL ATP3 wont disappoint me at the price 49$. Maybe Edifier is so new in my place.
We dont have the authorized distributor of Edifier in Vietnam and some local warehouses have just brought on some sample speaker sets of Edifier. I'm from Vietnam.

The reason for me to a look @ Edifier brand is that i had heard that they were selected as the 1st Speaker Manufacturer in China rclxms.gif (i forgot the year they achieved it doh.gif ).


Topic ClosedOptions
 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0430sec    0.52    7 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 3rd December 2025 - 01:01 PM