QUOTE(davidmak @ Jun 23 2009, 01:07 PM)
Wow... USD$94.99 is no small deal. Might as well get a standalone navigation device. No need to worry about battery operating time since its a dedicated device. And no crashes. Last time on my WinMo, Symbian phones with GMXT installed... at times it would just pop off and kick back to the home screen, right before I am expecting an exit. What would you do? Stop and reset? Hahaha! I guess those platforms have always been nasty. I don't know about iPhone though, but I am expecting something better on the experience.
Having said that, I would rather buy a proper device and be done with it. Also, you get to update your maps for free (in the case of Garmin and the Malsingmap collaboration). The rest of the maps... well you can always

Tell that to Garmin when they release their Nuviphone. Your point on "dedicated device" is bust when Garmin themselves are trying to cash in the lucrative mobile phone business.
The point here is, as long as the mobile platform is stable, there should not be any problem using that as your primary navigation device. With Winblows Blowbile, you'd half-expect the instability of that to interfere with the navigation program, therefore making it problematic as you described earlier. With stable mobile platforms like the Apple OS, or the mobile Linux OS Garmin is using for their Nuviphone, there shouldn't be any problems.
Carrying two devices when you can carry one? I thought Apple advocates are more open to mobile convergence when their iPhones itself symbolizes this.
The argument of "dedicated is better than convergence device" only holds true when the convergence device is unable to provide a service matching the dedicated device. Once the convergence device is able to provide operating standards that matches that of the dedicated device, then why hold on to that dedicated device anymore? It can be your standby unit, but most of the time, that convergence device can do, on par, what the dedicated device does.
The battery issue is also rendered moot since you will be using this in your car, and "hi there car charger"!
Which brings back to my point: Malaysians love free things. Malsingmaps provides free relatively updated maps. IF there is an AppStore app that can read and display these maps, then all you need to do is just buy that app, and load up your free Malsingmap and be done for, if you're not into buying maps from other providers. The question is, who will step up and make this AppStore app?
OT but somewhat related: The only reason why MalsingMap exists is because GPS users in these two countries were appalled at the level of coverage and map updating quality from the providers of maps such as Garmin themselves, or other alternatives like TeleNav, etc. That is how they embarked on their own self-dedicated journey on creating an updated map of Malaysia/Singapore (hence Malsing) for their Garmin GPS devices. Now, if these big-scale map providers like Garmin, Navigon, TeleAtlas themselves took heed and do the region proper with dedicated and updated map for this region, to a level surpassing MalsingMap, there would not be a reason to prefer the MalsingMap over these maps, other than the fact that MalsingMaps are free. I don't blame the early adopters for going their own way, look at what they have achieved with MalsingMaps. But "Free stuff" can only remain "free" so only so long.....
This post has been edited by stringfellow: Jun 23 2009, 01:30 PM