Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

Outline · [ Standard ] · Linear+

 MMU Law Graduates are Exempted from CLP Exam, What do you guys think?

views
     
TSsolstice818
post Jun 21 2009, 03:15 PM, updated 17y ago

You'll Never Walk Alone
*******
Senior Member
4,503 posts

Joined: Jun 2008
From: The Far Away Venus Status: Being Insua-fied


QUOTE
On May 6, we were told by one of our readers that the law graduates of Malaysia Multimedia University (MMU) is now exempted from the Certificate of Legal Practise (CLP) Exam. In fact, the reader came to know about this from a student’s blog .

After doing some preliminary verification, we immediately posted a thread at eLawyer Facebook announcing this ”gospel”. To our surprise, in less than 2 days we received a total of 22 comments on the thread which consist of mixture feedback (some welcome, some disappointed, some happy about it and some were upset comments).

On 14 May, based on a reliable unofficial source, MMU have in fact received the exemption letter from the Legal Profession Qualifying Board few weeks ago. They have communicated this information to the existing students. However, till today there is yet any official announcement on this matter. We believe this is due to the fact that such exemption is only effective and valid after the same have been gazetted per Section 3 of the Legal Profession Act, like what happen in UUM case. 

We were further told that such exemption will be reviewed by the Legal Profession Qualifying Board every 2 years.

Currently there are few hundreds law students studying in the Law School of MMU, which is located at Malacca. MMU (owned by the largest telco - TM Malaysia Berhad), the 1st government-approved private university started its 1st campus at Cyberjaya which focused in providing IT related courses in 1996.

The 1st batch of (about 39) law students graduated in 2008 from MMU.

In view of such exemption and limited admission in the law schools of local public universities, we believe there will be even more students enrolling for the law course in MMU.

Below are the admission requirement (reproduce from MMU website):

For Bachelor of Laws (Honours), the minimum qualification is as follows:
STPM with at least 3 Cs AND a minimum of 5 Credits for the subjects taken at SPM inclusive of English; OR

Related diploma from a recognized institution by Senate AND a minimum of 5 Credits for the subjects taken at SPM inclusive of English; OR

Any other qualification equivalent to (a) or (b) and approved by the Senate.

For candidates to be qualified and be called to the Bar, candidates MUST have credits in Bahasa Malaysia at SPM examination or they should have been exempted  from the Bahasa Malaysia Qualifying Examination conducted by the Legal Profession Qualifying Board.

If this is true, it will mark an unprecedent milestone in Malaysia legal education history, whereby MMU will be the 1st private university in Malaysia obtaining exemption of CLP exam for its law graduates.

Would this mean that ATC College or Brickfields Asia College which have a longer history in providing law programme will be exempted too if one day they are upgradeted to private univeristy status and decided to offer 4 years law course?  what about those law schools who have obtained college university status, e.g. Taylor College University?


http://www.elawyer.com.my/blog/malaysia-mu...-from-clp-exam/


What do you guys think? unsure.gif
khiahsu
post Jun 21 2009, 03:20 PM

New Member
*
Junior Member
48 posts

Joined: Dec 2007
(C+P from my comment at the source page)

Exempting MMU law grads from the CLP examinations inevitably sets a precedent that will ripple throughout the legal scene in Malaysia. Even though the exemption is subject to a review every 2 years, it is highly unlikely that its prized status would be revoked in a blink of an eye anytime soon once granted. Hence, MMU may experience a flood of applications for the coming intakes of its law foundation/ degree programme itself.

At a glance, it seems rather unfair that students of a private college will be able to escape the much-dreaded CLP while other students, who are following non-local syllabuses are still subject to it.

However,other private colleges like Brickfields/ATC/Taylors will find it hard to be able to cry foul over the non-exemptions of their respective courses from the CLP . The English law remains the basis of the external UoL LLB and UK Degree Transfer program syllabuses, unlike MMU/UiTM/local universities, whose focus remains centered on Malaysian law. The difference however, may not be as vast as some parties paint it to be- Malaysian law is also mainly rooted on the common law legal system, and most law graduates who have completed a non-local degree have encountered no problems in adapting what they have learnt to put into practise here.

If MMU is granted this prized exemption, what is there to stop other private institutions from following in its footsteps now; by setting up a similiar 4-year law programme catering to “Malaysian law” in order to get around the CLP? We would have scores of private law schools churning out graduates by the dozen, flooding the market with an overwhelming supply.

Some view this move as ” lowering the standards required to become a lawyer” . Should the scenario in above materialize, private institutions of higher education would be tempted to lower the entry requirement threshold in order to admit more students and milk them for all their worth. Argue as you might over standards and integrity, but quality takes a backseat whenever business concerns and education cross paths. Without a proper qualifying exam, it will be difficult to discern the quality of these graduates, be they local or foreign educated.

Whatever happened to the proposed Common Bar Course for *everyone*? That seems like a fairer move in my opinion.
finaltrooper
post Dec 2 2009, 11:02 PM

Getting Started
**
Junior Member
134 posts

Joined: Oct 2006


sounds racist but true. no sugar coating. the gov just wanna churn out more malay lawyers, as usual, giving them the easiest way. i hope i'm a malay.
sameer27
post Dec 3 2009, 10:15 AM

PlanTheFutureForABetterPast
****
Senior Member
684 posts

Joined: Oct 2009


QUOTE(finaltrooper @ Dec 2 2009, 11:02 PM)
sounds racist but true. no sugar coating. the gov just wanna churn out more malay lawyers, as usual, giving them the easiest way. i hope i'm a malay.
*
Then, marry a Malay girl for fast conversion or just convert. tongue.gif

MMU has yet to make an official statement that their law graduates are being exempted from taking the CLP.
XterNalz
post Dec 3 2009, 10:24 AM

Casual
***
Junior Member
330 posts

Joined: Apr 2007
From: Malacca/Jurong/Hsinchu


I don't see why a private university cant be provided such an exemption provided that the quality is up to par. FYI, MMU does have a lot of good debaters.

This post has been edited by XterNalz: Dec 3 2009, 10:25 AM
SUSOptiplex330
post Dec 3 2009, 11:42 AM

10k Club
********
Senior Member
12,696 posts

Joined: Aug 2008
QUOTE(XterNalz @ Dec 3 2009, 10:24 AM)
I don't see why a private university cant be provided such an exemption provided that the quality is up to par. FYI, MMU does have a lot of good debaters.
*
You are right. And that is why any other college/overseas universities etc that has the same high quality should also be exempted. No discrimination allowed but do you think that is possible? That my friend, is the main thing why people complained.


sameer27
post Dec 3 2009, 12:09 PM

PlanTheFutureForABetterPast
****
Senior Member
684 posts

Joined: Oct 2009


It seems that only 3rd year and final year students are exempted from CLP. Not the latest batch.

 

Change to:
| Lo-Fi Version
0.0133sec    0.35    5 queries    GZIP Disabled
Time is now: 6th December 2025 - 10:54 AM