Help - Search - Member List - Calendar
Full Version: Gigabyte: Asus Lied & Fooled Customers
Lowyat.NET > Computers > Hardware
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
SlayerXT
ASUS always overpriced. Thats it, if mainstream user better stick to other brand.
means
I do not care about the EPU or DES, but if Gigabyte would let people to believe the test results he shows, they need to duplicate the exact same environment.
He use his high end P35 vs ASUS P5K SE, what does he want to show? His high end board in P35 series is better than ASUS's low end in P35 series?
what about P45?
Expecting ASUS P5Q
WebWalker
QUOTE(means @ May 27 2008, 05:34 PM)
I do not care about the EPU or DES, but if Gigabyte would let people to believe the test results he shows, they need to duplicate the exact same environment.
He use his high end P35 vs ASUS P5K SE, what does he want to show? His high end board in P35 series is better than ASUS's low end in P35 series?
what about P45?
Expecting ASUS P5Q
*



If you read the article, it is not much on comparison.

It is much on the false statement (advertisement) that Asus made on their product.
johnkor
STOP.....................GAME .......ON !
Federer
QUOTE(pikacu @ May 26 2008, 11:57 PM)
There is two common type computer user (from my personal opinion)

1) Idle (Torrent, Download, Chatting, /b/,  etc..)
2) Active (Gaming,OCer,3d Renderer, etc..)
For user type 1) , they would go for power efficiencies motherboard.

For user type 2) , ...go figure tongue.gif
*



If staying at college never care about the bill. Overclock kaw kaw tongue.gif
Terence573
QUOTE(Federer @ May 28 2008, 07:42 AM)
If staying at college never care about the bill. Overclock kaw kaw  tongue.gif
*



Next time college will charge "overclock" overclocking system usage bill wahaha..
dadurtyz
asus be expensive bcz of their adds and popularity, but quality??
PGV3910
now on ASUS = ASROCK laugh.gif laugh.gif ..jk..jk
Bigblock
QUOTE(dadurtyz @ May 29 2008, 09:54 AM)
asus be expensive bcz of their adds and popularity, but quality??
*


But still they cant hide frm customers also..customers arn't stupid either..


Added on May 29, 2008, 10:38 am
QUOTE(sonic_cd @ May 27 2008, 03:07 PM)
i belong to category 1 .. but then again i orefer high specs to g with it ... haha .
*


i'd second to that bro...agree icon_rolleyes.gif
tachlio
then all go DFI lolz~~
johnkor
so many brand ! can go FOXCONN MA or MSI or GIgabyte Y because asus sux!
nelienuxe_sara
gigabyte fanboy ^^
or anti asus fanboy ^^
Core_Tracer
QUOTE(johnkor @ May 29 2008, 12:08 PM)
so many brand ! can go FOXCONN MA or MSI or GIgabyte Y because asus sux!
*



maybe sux for u....but not me icon_idea.gif
nelienuxe_sara
say edi...
gigabyte fanboy n u asus fanboy
super macgyver
QUOTE(heizad @ May 14 2008, 09:57 PM)
then buy dfi..LOL
*


duno now wat happened to local dfi distri, as they now more focus on biostar only. sad.gif
Matrix
QUOTE(jinaun @ May 16 2008, 05:48 PM)
ASUS Retaliates Against Gigabyte, Issues Official Statement
http://www.vr-zone.com/articles/ASUS_Retal...ement/5780.html
*



ASUS lies..again.

Gigabyte was talking about an older model..P5K or E or something, while ASUS say it's P5Q, which has all the function. See how ASUS tried to divert the issue?

The P5Q is a new board with the enhanced function while Gigabyte is saying their older ASUS mobo don't meet the specs.

Gigabyte sure win liao.

btw, after the last round of bad experience with the ASUS M3A mobo, i never want to touch an ASUS mobo...ever.

So happy with Gigabyte E-P35 mobo now. thumbup.gif
nelienuxe_sara
QUOTE(super macgyver @ May 29 2008, 12:58 PM)
duno now wat happened to local dfi distri, as they now more focus on biostar only.  sad.gif
*



this happen coz ppl buy biostar make their profit high ler...
dfi stuff exp... not all afford it
Irishcoffee
QUOTE(super macgyver @ May 29 2008, 12:58 PM)
duno now wat happened to local dfi distri, as they now more focus on biostar only.  sad.gif
*


so far i know
biostar veli cheap can earn more thn others
johnkor
wah this war wouldn end like that ! ASUS LAST MOVE OR SHUTDOWN!!!
zeustronic
QUOTE
wah this war wouldn end like that ! ASUS LAST MOVE OR SHUTDOWN!!!



U really speak without any common sense at all.


Added on May 30, 2008, 9:56 am
QUOTE(super macgyver @ May 29 2008, 01:58 PM)
duno now wat happened to local dfi distri, as they now more focus on biostar only.  sad.gif
*




QUOTE(nelienuxe_sara @ May 29 2008, 03:16 PM)
this happen coz ppl buy biostar make their profit high ler...
dfi stuff exp... not all afford it
*



Biostar RMA quite fast, the supplier oso do 1st year 1 to 1 exchange if faulty.
pikacu
Gigabyte bowed down to ASUS: http://www.digitimes.com/mobos/a20080530PD205.html
QUOTE
The legal battle between motherboard makers Gigabyte Technology and Asustek Computer looks set to be over before it even started, with Gigabyte agreeing to issue a public apology.

Tensions between the two companies flared up over "defamatory" comments and comparisons Gigabyte made in a internal document which challenged Asustek's claims of using high-quality components in its motherboards, and the merits of Asustek's EPU energy saving technology and its own DES equivalent.

Asustek took issue with the particularly strong wording used in the document and that Gigabyte failed to present independent test results. Problems also arose from the juxtaposition of an image of "blown" capacitors on an unidentified maker's product alongside an Asustek motherboard, which Asustek alleged was an attempt by Gigabyte to imply Asustek products were of equally poor quality. In response Asustek lodged a complaint with Taiwan's Fair Trade Commission (FTC) and initiated legal proceedings against the Gigabyte employee responsible for writing the document.

While stressing that it stands by the original intent of the document – that its DES technology is superior to Asustek's EPU – Gigabyte said it acknowledged the grievances raised by its competitor and has agreed to issue an official apology which will be published, at its expense, in Taiwan newspapers on June 1.

In turn, Asustek has agreed to drop all proceedings related to the issue.


Gaygaybyte bowed down upon Assus wrath laugh.gif

the fairy tails end..
tolong_saye
so
asus not a liar
and gigabyte has make a msitake?
pikacu
it seems so smile.gif

gaygaybyte cannot "fight" assus..thats all.
capiche
~boring ending... yawn~~~ sad.gif
zeustronic
QUOTE(pikacu @ May 31 2008, 12:56 AM)
it seems so smile.gif

gaygaybyte cannot "fight" assus..thats all.
*



Juz like a village trying to war with an empire tongue.gif .
goldfries
bottomline - You don't start some accusations without SOLID evidence.
SlayerXT
I still dont like lame packaging form Asus's mainstream mobos. Whether DES or EPU for ocers it is the same at the end.
jinaun
QUOTE(§layerXT @ May 31 2008, 11:39 AM)
I still dont like lame packaging form Asus's mainstream mobos. Whether DES or EPU for ocers it is the same at the end.
*



its not the packaging that matters.. its the quality of the content
Zavia/GenX
Waittt, something not right here

QUOTE
The battle of the Taiwan titans rages on but this time, the stakes have been raised as, after a little PR rumble, Asus has announced that it has sued Gigabyte for defamatory acts. It all started with Gigabyte holding a press event in which it made claims and showcased results regarding Asus' energy saving technology centered around the Energy Processing Unit or EPU. Asus responded to Gigabyte's event through a press release last week and today it upped the ante with a new release which reads:

Also, in a press briefing presentation, Gigabyte used a photograph with blown-up (exploded) capacitors and led the audience to believe it was an ASUS product, to support its false allegations that ASUS uses questionable quality components. However, the image was found to be taken from a photograph of a VGA card manufactured by another vendor. The action of misrepresenting a third party product to be an ASUS product is truly defamatory and clearly outside the realm of decent competition.


QUOTE
Asustek took issue with the particularly strong wording used in the document and that Gigabyte failed to present independent test results. Problems also arose from the juxtaposition of an image of "blown" capacitors on an unidentified maker's product alongside an Asustek motherboard, which Asustek alleged was an attempt by Gigabyte to imply Asustek products were of equally poor quality.


From reading the articles, asus sued them over... the image, and strong wording? ONLY?

QUOTE
While stressing that it stands by the original intent of the document – that its DES technology is superior to Asustek's EPU – Gigabyte said it acknowledged the grievances raised by its competitor and has agreed to issue an official apology which will be published, at its expense, in Taiwan newspapers on June 1.


Asus didnt win nuts. Its like the other statement where they showed their exclusive features to the unrelated mobo, this is the same thing.

Edit: Thinking about it, after your compeditor and 2 diffrent reviews say more or less the same thing, you don't just sue, you also show it to the reporters that it is untrue. Odd behaviour imo. Someone start a lawsuit againts asus with the gigabyte>asus article, may win some cash!
tauruskong
I think there sumthing happen behind that the press or neither us know?sneaky!!!!
pikacu
QUOTE(Zavia/GenX @ May 31 2008, 06:10 PM)
Waittt, something not right here
*




QUOTE(tauruskong @ May 31 2008, 09:04 PM)
I think there sumthing happen behind that the press or neither us know?sneaky!!!!
*



QUOTE(pikacu @ May 30 2008, 11:56 PM)
gaygaybyte cannot "fight" assus..thats all.
*



as i say...gaygaybyte cannot "fight" assus. laugh.gif

gstoh
QUOTE(pikacu @ May 31 2008, 10:15 PM)
as i say...gaygaybyte cannot "fight" assus. laugh.gif
*


is it like altantuya's family cannot fight with "someone" whom ordered to kill altantuya ? hmm.gif
Thunderbolt
QUOTE(gstoh @ Jun 1 2008, 12:37 AM)
is it like altantuya's family cannot fight with "someone" whom ordered to kill altantuya ? hmm.gif
*

That is another story wink.gif
cstkl1
i wonder where my loyalties lies..
die gay gay die tongue.gif
tauruskong
u know mayb some join venture or asus provide great deal for giga
nimrod2

i was just thinking.

it could be a marketing strategy by both companies.

do u think so?

i mean they say there is no such thing as 'bad' publicity kua.

BuLaNaR
haha, im using abit now..gigabyte n asus most expensive brand n now become liars???
elipy
Gigabyte had steered us into the war of words in haste. As a marketing stactic, I think it is successful, many people stand by him, but I do not enjoy that. You could criticize your competitor, but slander, so ignominious. Now go out for apology, a little ungainly. Just my opinion.
Everyone has his thought.
johnkor
yay asus lost so no more " REPLUBLIC OF GAMERS " HUHU! NOW can GO FOR MARS!!
kaiser_falco
hmm..but this i think only for their previous model..and actually i dont really care bout power saving its all about overclocking which where gigabyte failed to provide with their bios,so little option for overclocking setting coming from dfi lanparty x48 and now on asus i may say the board doesnt lack any tweak setting that i want,eventhough i may say that dfi is the most fully overclocking mobo..
tech3910
just couple of weeks ago.......i saw on tomshardware.com, gigabyte apologizing 2 asus regarding their claim (flashing on the advertisement bar......)
johnkor
THE war is not ended but the Journey has just started LFMAO!
FoxNope
Wah wah... i still thinking want to get Asus P5K-Deluxe... Omg.. should i get it now or not lerh... I think is time to think about Biostar !!
gigabyte prove that Asus chart are fake, but is the chart that gigabyte provide is true? gigabyte can make fake chart too.. ^.^

No Offence ...dun pwnd me
pikacu
^
I sense gaygaybyte vs asus fight is...scripted drama =/
mls_gamer
haha i have turn to gigabyte supporter 3 month ago.
sukhoi37
gaygaybyte apologized through Tomshardware already, you guys still wanna sibuk? tongue.gif
mls_gamer
QUOTE(FoxNope @ Jun 22 2008, 11:23 PM)
Wah wah... i still thinking want to get Asus P5K-Deluxe... Omg.. should i get it now or not lerh... I think is time to think about Biostar !!
gigabyte prove that Asus chart are fake, but is the chart that gigabyte provide is true? gigabyte can make fake chart too.. ^.^

No Offence ...dun pwnd me
*



i think gigabyte is saying the truth la....bcos already spread all over the world.if not gigabyte will fall.
Aquariusdenz
hey hey.. dont say gaygaybyte until very bad lah... gaygaybyte supporter here leh... hehe
FoxNope
QUOTE(sukhoi37 @ Jun 22 2008, 11:37 PM)
gaygaybyte apologized through Tomshardware already, you guys still wanna sibuk? tongue.gif
*



apologized about what(sry i did't manage to view through all the page)???
About too rude ? or about give wrong information ?
blush.gif

Coz i am choosing btw 3 board now
Asus P5K-Deluxe/Wifi, Gigabyte EP45-DS4P, XFX 680i

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «



Added on June 23, 2008, 12:09 amOh.. saw the article already... seem
Gigabyte said sorry because the word using in the document.. Not really about the EPU.. but gigabyte and asus also can't prove with any evidence.
So.. still a mystery...
The solution i think is, buy 2 equally board and test ourself(not me) ^^
Suk
it's normal in the competitive environment.. someone trying to flame each other
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
All Rights Reserved 2003-2006 Vijandren Ramadass
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.